Back to IndieWire

‘Blue Valentine’ Producer “Dumbfounded” By NC-17 Rating, Says They Won’t Change Film For Appeal

'Blue Valentine' Producer "Dumbfounded" By NC-17 Rating, Says They Won't Change Film For Appeal

In case you forgot, “Blue Valentine,” the prickly relationship drama starring Michelle Williams and Ryan Gosling, was recently slapped with an NC-17 rating by the MPAA much to the confusion of, well, everyone. While the MPAA keeps the reasons for their decisions secret, most believe it is due to a scene where the troubled couple, played by Williams and Gosling, have an argument in the midst of having sex. Yes, it’s a very uncomfortable and bracing scene but certainly nothing risqué about it. Regardless, the notoriously sex-afraid, violence-happy MPAA got their knickers in a twist and gave the hardest rating they could against the film.

While the appeal appears not to have happened just yet, and with The Weinstein Company surprisingly quiet on the matter, it hasn’t stopped talent behind the film from speaking out. Earlier last month, director Derek Cianfrance admitted he was “shocked” by the rating and now producer Jamie Patricof has revealed he has been left “dumfounded” by the decision but stands strong alongside the film.

Speaking with E!, Patricof draws parallels between “Blue Valentine” and some other recent films that have gotten away with lesser ratings even though they show more saying, “I’ve seen a lot of movies. I just saw ‘Jackass‘ and I was dumbfounded—you see a lot of fully frontal male nudity. I’m sitting there thinking, ‘Do I want my 15-year-old daughter seeing this?’ Probably not. Do I want her to see [Blue Valentine]? It’s probably not my first choice, but I don’t think it would harm her.”

He adds that during the appeals process he wants to tell the MPAA, “I want to talk to them and say, ‘Really, ‘The Lovely Bones‘? Raping and killing 13 year olds is cool?'”

The problem though is that the MPAA doesn’t allow ratings for other films to be used as evidence in stating your case so the PG-13 rating for “The Lovely Bones” and gratuitous full frontal male nudity of “Jackass” won’t matter. That said, don’t expect anyone to be making edits to the film, with Patricof stating, “We have no intention of changing the film.”

It’s just under two months until the film will get a limited release on December 31st. Just how limited it will be remains to be seen as an NC-17 will keep it out of most cinemas except arthhouse and independent theaters.

This Article is related to: Uncategorized and tagged , , , , ,



Yeah, you can now cite precident when you appeal to the MPAA. Thanks to This Film Is Not Yet Rated.


i think ryan gosling’s almost aborted baby is correct!


Good for them for not buckling under to this moronic and puritanical system. Why is it ok to show hundreds of people shot, stabbed, mutilated and blown up in the most gruesome ways imaginable but sex is verboten? The MPAA needs to get their heads out of their asses.


According to Kevin Smith, after the This Film Is Not Yet Rated, you can now refer to other films in the appeals process, he did on Zach and Miri, it’s on the dvd documentary.

ryan gosling's almost aborted baby

I’m the reason why this film is rated nc-17 and even I think it’s ridiculous!


Absurd. Unless there’s a scene where Gosling plays baseball using his fully shown penis as a bat (Jackass 3D), this entire system needs to go away right now.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *