Back to IndieWire

The Weinstein Company Lawyer Up To Fight The NC-17 Rating For ‘Blue Valentine’

The Weinstein Company Lawyer Up To Fight The NC-17 Rating For 'Blue Valentine'

“I just can’t wait to stand over your shoulder while you change the rating.”

Ever since “Blue Valentine” got nailed with a baffling NC-17 rating, things have been uncharacteristically quiet from the Weinstein camp. And now we know why. Harvey Weinstein has been busy hiring lawyers (in what we hope inspires the best “Law & Order: Los Angeles” episode ever).

EW reports that Weinstein has hired Alan Friedman and David Boies to help in his battle against the MPAA. Friedman has experience with the MPAA, helping Weinstein overturn an NC-17 rating for Kevin Smith‘s “Zack And Miri Make A Porno” while Boies represented Gore in Bush v. Gore and helped battle California’s Proposition 8 ban on gay marriage. In other words, Harvey is going in there guns blazing.

While there has been some speculation as to which scene in particular so offended the MPAA they had to tag the film with an NC-17 rating, according to Weinstein, the scene in question shows Ryan Gosling‘s character performing oral sex on Michelle Williams‘.

Pointing out the inconsistency of the MPAA, Harvey draws up an example of a film released by his brother Bob Weinstein‘s Dimension Films earlier this year saying, “If [‘Piranha 3D‘] got an NC-17, I’d be the first going, ‘All right, we gotta cut some of that stuff.’ It’s ridiculous — a penis got coughed up in the movie by a piranha! They show more in four scenes [in that movie] than we do in [all of ‘Blue Valentine’]! And ours is a serious love story. I don’t understand it.”

Moreover, Weinstein is fully aware of how an NC-17 rating will affect not only the box office but his awards chances adding, “….I’m worried that if we don’t get the R it could jeopardize the business of the movie and more importantly my actors … because they are eminently nominatable.”

As to whether or not they will edit the film in order to secure a much more box office- and awards-friendly rating Weinstein says he will not take any scissors to Derek Cianfrance‘s film. If there is anything to be learned from any of this, particularly for you aspiring filmmakers out there, its that a chewed-up and regurgitated penis is more likely to get an R rating than an honest, though not particularly explicit, sex scene in a relationship drama.

This Article is related to: Uncategorized and tagged ,



I was at a screening of this movie at the Denver Starz Film Festival yesterday, along with Derek Cianfrance and his family (he’s from Colorado, and went to school here).

At the end of the Q&A, the host said something along the lines of, “thanks Derek, we look forward to hopefully seeing your film in wider release later this year, depending on the MPAA …” and he cut her off, emphatically saying that the film WILL see a wider release in December, and it WILL be this version. Perhaps it was wishful thinking on his part, (so take it with a grain of salt) but he seemed pretty confident that he wouldn’t be making any cuts.

Oh, and I absolutely loved the film!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *