Back to IndieWire

Underrated, Underdog and Misunderstood Films of 2010

Underrated, Underdog and Misunderstood Films of 2010

Thompson on Hollywood

Who doesn’t like an underdog? They’re not asking to win the Oscar for Best Picture, but these under-appreciated films deserve to be seen by wider audiences than their box office numbers, critics or lack of awards talk would suggest. After the jump is a sampling of the worthy films singled out by The New York Times, The Atlantic, Moviefone, The Playlist and Associated Content. Our adds to your bucket list of films to watch when awards season is over (or now, if you’re caught up) are:

Mademoiselle Chambon – because it takes its time and lets its actors feel their way through the action.
Sweetgrass – because what was meant to be a Netflix streaming sleeping aid (this documentary literally counts sheep) kept me happily awake.
Cairo Time – for every single subtle expression on Patricia Clarkson’s face.
Hereafter – because it doesn’t pretend to have the answer to – but still considers – life’s biggest question.
Fair Game – Watts + Penn + True Story = Must see.
Mother and Child – for the performance triad Annette Bening, Naomi Watts and Kerry Washington in this emotional yet rewarding melodramatic estrogen fest.

The New York Times singles out:

A Film Unfinished – “Above all “A Film Unfinished” is testimony, and if watching it is sometimes painful, it is also, like the film itself, an act of bearing witness.”

Animal Kingdom – “Mr. Michôd’s movie has its own distinct, almost ethnographic feel. Its criminals are all the more alarming for not being part of anything bigger or more organized than themselves and their appetites and impulses.”

A Prophet – “As Malik expands his range, the movie does too, eventually becoming a brilliant meditation on human possibility, its best and worst.”

Fish Tank – “In this fractious female household, kindness is in short supply…[Director Andrea Arnold] grasps the forbidden things people get up to behind their own backs, but she invites us to watch without judgment.”

Never Let Me Go – “Mr. Romanek skillfully seeds the narrative with hints…at a society growing harsher and more selfish by the day. One of the pleasures of “Never Let Me Go” is its beauty, but the mirror it invites us to look into could hardly be more unsparing.”

The Atlantic:

Green Zone – “is not a mere collection of fashionable political and aesthetic poses, but rather an immersive investigation into the vagaries of fact-finding, starring a wonderfully no-nonsense Matt Damon.”

October Country – “Michael Palmieri and Donal Mosher’s October Country is a heavily stylized portrait of a family—Mosher’s own family—and so about as far from strictly reportorial as it gets…[it] would make a terrific, if not terrifically cheerful, ring-in-2011 double feature with Mike Leigh’s Another Year

The Oath – “the most unjustly overlooked documentary of the year is Laura Poitras’s The Oath, which takes as its subject Osama bin Laden’s former personal driver, Abu Jandal, a walking contradiction par excellence. The Yemeni cab driver’s ability to talk out of both sides of his mouth has over the last decade made him both a friend to the FBI and a mentor to budding jihadis.”

Associated Content:

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World – “Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is pretty much a fanboy’s dream movie, with pop culture references and one of the best soundtracks in recent memory.”

Kick-Ass – “The superhero genre has gone surprisingly unscathed as far as satire goes…Kick-Ass does serve to pick apart the genre pretty effectively…What really makes Kick-Ass unique is Chloe Moretz as the vulgar, ultra-violent 11-year-old Hit-Girl. An actress as young as Moretz should not be this talented.”


Please Give – “Catherine Keener, Rebecca Hall and Amanda Peet all shone in the film that explored the difficulties, hardships and yes, the laughs when trying to balance caring for others while also caring for yourself.”

Trash Humpers – “Blurring the line between fiction, found art, provocation, snuff movie, documentary and feature film, Harmony Korine‘s latest is a dirty finger in the eye to Hollywood’s glossy, family-friendly, CGI HD 3D money train…The picture is gleefully freaky, relentlessly demented, absurdly hilarious and of course features moments of extreme perverse beauty.”

I Am Love – “Consider I Am Love the “real” version of Julia Roberts’ glossy Eat, Pray, Love. It concerns itself with similar thematic territory – the reconnection of a woman (Tilda Swinton) who, entombed in her life, explores her sexuality and her love of food – but is done so in a way that doesn’t belittle the material or turn it into an incredibly luscious commercial for The Olive Garden. Instead, there’s real sensuality in every frame of Luca Guadagnino’s debut feature.”

Biutiful – “Overreaching? Perhaps, but the film’s grim setting can’t cover up the deep humanity hiding below the surface. Hollywood certainly isn’t making anything close to the emotional complexity and philosophical depth of Iñárritu’s film, and while that alone is enough for celebration, when the results are this rich and the performances this real, it’s pretty much a crime for a picture like this to fall through the cracks.”

Ondine – “It’s a wonderful, romantic and dreamy little fairytale and yes, it’s flawed and has a twist ending that doesn’t really work. But the rest of it is so beautiful…Perhaps you can dub it a beautiful mess.”


It’s Kind of a Funny Story – “the hostility toward this exceedingly good-natured flick is baffling…[it] is a sharp, affecting dramedy about learning to chill out and live with yourself.”

Robin Hood – “don’t be deceived: this is still handsomely mounted, enjoyable stuff – not as good as the rest of Scott’s output, but well worth a couple hours of your time.”

This Article is related to: Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Thomas Frylink

Dont know why u ppl missed “Inception”. Not underrated but certainly most misunderstood.

Greg Beck

“The Killer Inside Me” was overlooked it is perhaps one of the best adaptations of any of the traditional pulp novels since The Maltese Falcon.Casey Affleck gave a performance that was so unnerving you were watching a psychopathic sadist and not an actor playing a part.It also has one of the best ironic endings in when Ford(Affleck) is in the movie he has created in his own mind.It also is the first of the so called neo noirs were style does not over take the story or performances (no winking at the camera lie Tarantino or The Coen Brothers have in their take on film noir)

Michael Heister

Cairo Time also features a wonderful performance from Alexander Siddig. He and Clarkson have fantastic chemistry in the film, and it was his touching work that made us feel hers all the more strongly.


Thank you Sophia Savage (of course not AT) for mentioning “Fair Game” and “Mother and Child” both starring the talented Naomi Watts who also stars in Woody Allen’s “You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger”. Watts excels in all 3 movies, in particular “Fair Game” which I think is the most Oscar-worthy of the year compared to all those being heavily hyped ones. The HFPA as usual and continuously for the 11the year (since Mulholland Dr. in 2001) ignored and snubbed criminally all her 3 great performances, and this will most likely influence and be followed by the Academy Awards. So thank you Sophia Savage (of course not AT).

Timothy King

I’d say Green Zone, Shutter Island and Robin Hood were my top 3 misunderstood/underrated films of the year.


I would definitely go with Green Zone and Hereafter. People were expecting some kind of spooky ghost thriller and got something else that they were totally unprepared for. Also the Aussie film noir thriller The Square that was totally overlooked. But my no.1 pick is the two part four hour French gangster film with Vincent Cassel, Mesrine: Killer Instinct and Public Enemy No. 1. Just an awesome dazzling movie which had a badly botched theatrical release

Dennis Cozzalio

I’m behind SWEETGRASS and MOTHER AND CHILD 100%, and PLEASE GIVE may just end up being my pick of the year (assuming I ever finish catching up!) But if underrated also means universally dismissed, then THE TOURIST has to be among these picks too. It was a perfectly enjoyable ode to CHARADE and a hundred other let’s-take-a-vacation-and-make-a-movie pictures which got dumped on to a degree far surpassing even its worst alleged offenses.

Nick Duval

Greenberg strikes me as the most misunderstood or underrated film of 2010. People were put off by it, but it was really valuable in a lot of respects. Ben Stiller and Rhys Ifans have never been better, and we need a provocateur like Noah Baumbach to push us every so often.

Also: Iron Man 2, which was put down as a bad sequel. Much to the contrary. Not as good as the original, but good enough (with Sam Rockwell going on all cylinders and with director Jon Favreau and cinematographer Matthew Libatique doing strong work as well) so that a third movie wouldn’t be out of the question.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *