Back to IndieWire

Film History On A Platter—DVD reviews

Film History On A Platter—DVD reviews

If you believe major studio spokespeople, the DVD business is dying, to be replaced by downloading and cloud storage of films and TV shows. But the business-related news stories that repeatedly state these facts don’t take account of smaller companies like Criterion, Flicker Alley, and Kino that cater to film buffs and still provide a valuable product that can’t be replicated online.

The recent Criterion release of People on Sunday (1929) is a perfect example. This legendary German silent film was made on a shoestring by a collective that included such future directors of note as Robert Siodmak, Edgar G. Ulmer, Billy Wilder, and Fred Zinnemann, as well as cinematographer Eugen Schüfftan. It is a beguiling (and utterly disarming) film about four acquaintances who escape from the city to enjoy a—

—day’s outing in the country. By using amateurs for its leading players, and interspersing staged scenes with casual footage of life in and around the city, the filmmakers create a snapshot of life in and around Berlin just before the Depression, and the rise of the Nazi party, changed everything.

Criterion has made a high-definition transfer of a print restored in conjunction with the EYE Film Institute Netherlands. One can choose from two musical scores, a modern version by Elan Kals-Chernin, played by the Czech Film Orchestra, and a period-style score prepared by Rodney Sauer from silent-film cue sheets and popular songs of the period, performed by his Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra.

There is a documentary made in 2000 by Gerald Koll in which one of the “stars,” Brigitte Borchert, and Robert Siodmak’s brother, screenwriter Curt, are interviewed. And, as a special treat, Criterion has included a rare 1931 short-subject called Ins blaue Hinein, running 36 minutes and directed by Schüfftan, which recaptures the spirit and milieu of People on Sunday quite nicely.

Film scholar Noah Isenberg provides a clear-eyed look at the making of the film—about which its participants disagreed over the years—and its significance. Two newspaper articles written by Billy (then Billie) Wilder at the time of the film’s release and a reminiscence by Siodmak years later complete the booklet, which is filled with evocative photographs from the movie.

Criterion has also issued a definitive release of Stanley Kubrick’s 1956 heist thriller The Killing with a similar array of extras, including a new interview with its producer, James B. Harris, and from a French television archive, two fascinating conversations with its star, Sterling Hayden. There are other goodies, an informative booklet, and as the ultimate extra another entire feature film: Kubrick’s lesser-known 1955 release Killer’s Kiss.

As a sequel to its three-disc release Saved from the Flames, Flicker Alley has issued Wild & Weird, an enjoyable collection of odd and unusual shorts, mostly from the silent era, accompanied by the Alloy Orchestra. Selections include Edwin S. Porter’s Dreams of a Rarebit Fiend, the incredible early trick-film The Red Spectre, The Thieving Hand, Princess Nicotine, the unforgettably absurd French comedy Artheme Swallows His Clarinet, Ladislas Starewicz’s The Cameraman’s Revenge, Winsor McCay’s The Pet, and the famous avant-garde short The Life and Death of 9413, A Hollywood Extra, made by Robert Florey, Slavko Vorkapich, and Gregg Toland, among others. Longtime film buffs will know most of these already, but the print quality is exceptional and the Alloy accompaniment unique.

I haven’t had time to fully explore Kino’s new release Buster Keaton: The Short Film Collection, which is available on Blu-ray and standard DVD, but just on the face of it this is an exciting release, gathering all of Keaton’s solo starring two-reelers of the 1920s, some in newly-found, improved prints, all retransferred in high definition. The set offers visual essays by a number of Keaton experts, a number of brief alternate or deleted shots from The Goat, The Blacksmith, and The Balloonatic, four featurettes spotlighting Keaton locations by that master sleuth John Bengtson, and much more, including two rare silent shorts, Carter DeHaven’s Character Studies, which features cameos by his comedy-star friends, and Seeing Stars, a behind-the-scenes release from 1922 with footage of Chaplin and Keaton, among others.

While I’m at it, I was remiss in not reviewing Criterion’s release of The Great Dictator, which has too many extras to enumerate, among them Kevin Brownlow’s terrific documentary The Tramp and the Dictator, a barbershop scene Charlie shot but deleted from Sunnyside in 1919 and a not-dissimilar one performed by his half-brother Syd in the 1921 film King, Queen, Joker. The accompanying booklet includes wonderful artwork by Al Hirschfeld and Chaplin’s rebuttal to the film’s critics, originally published in The New York Times. I was especially impressed by Cecilia Cenciarelli’s visual essay about Chaplin’s longtime fascination with Napoleon Bonaparte and how, in an indirect way, it led to him making The Great Dictator. And although Brownlow makes use of the material in his documentary, it’s fascinating to watch Syd Chaplin’s vivid color home-movie footage of that film in production, uncut and uninterrupted.

This is film scholarship at its finest, offering fans and students an opportunity to better appreciate the work of great performers, writers and directors. And since the majors studios have largely abdicated their role in documenting movie history (which they did quite well during the heyday of the DVD) we are all the more indebted to the individuals and entrepreneurs at Criterion, Flicker Alley and Kino who are staying the course.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , ,


Tim Davis

One evening, in the early 80’s, I was watching, I think it was “At The Movies” when Roger Ebert made the comment that it would be “Unbelievable to point to my bookshelf and say “I’ve got a copy of “Gandhi” right over there. Wanna watch it?”. Ever since then I have always wanted a version of a film I liked in a tactile sense. I want to hold it in my hands. I’m still mourning the demise of Laserdiscs for the same reason people miss LP’s vs CD’s: Large cover art and essays about the materiel inside. Put all of this on the “Cloud” ? Sure, you’ve got instant access, but there’s just something missing.

Robert Kass

Leonard, thanks for a wonderful response for everyone who keeps telling me that because of streaming my large DVD collection will become obsolete. Thanks to great companies like Criterion, Shout Factory, and Flicker Alley, among others, we have so much more than the films themselves, and I would never want to give that up.


Studio Execs are like Politicians, they are full of it. In trying to create a self-fulfilling prophecy, and push their agenda. They should just let the “market” decide what it wants. I miss Suncoast Video and its’ shelves full of tapes, but like the dinosaur they had their day. DVD’s appear to be more resilient and lasting. A side note on Chaplin, who created one of the most endearing characters in film history,”The Little Tramp.” Is it me or is the makeup so good , you can’t see the person behind the visage ? He is somewhat controversial ,but no one ever said he was perfect. His body of work is almost second to none, although I think Keaton might get the nod in a photo, either way, the film goer is the winner.

Brian Tucker

The rental of new release DVDs may well be dying, but I don’t see any slowing down in the collector’s market. I have 4,500 DVDs in my collection, and am still buying regularly. The same goes for my collector friends. In fact, we are probably buying more now than ever because it is nearly impossible to rent classic titles anymore.

Jeff Heise

I will also give kudos to Warner Archives, which is making so many wonderfully well-known and obscure films available that many of us have only dreamed of (the 1929 version of THE LETTER with Jeanne Eagels-not many people even knew that version still existed), and to Shout! Factory, which for their Ernie Kovacs collection and the Groucho YOU BET YOUR LIFE discs alone would put them in the pantheon for those of us who love classic comedy.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *