Back to IndieWire

Melancholia – movie review

Melancholia - movie review

Lest anyone mistake the man who made Antichrist as a purveyor of feel-good entertainment, Lars von Trier has opted for truth in advertising by titling his new film Melancholia. The Danish filmmaker enjoys courting controversy, and some of his films seem deliberately designed to provoke and upset audiences…but he’s also made some fascinating pictures like Breaking the Waves andDogville, so I try to take each movie as it comes without any preconceived notions.

To my mind, Melancholia is both absorbing and absurd. It opens with a visual prologue that turns out to be a précis of the film that is to follow. Kirsten Dunst (who won the Best Actress award at this year’s Cannes Film Festival) plays a beautiful bride who arrives two hourslate for the wedding ceremony her sister, Charlotte Gainsbourg, has painstakingly planned for her and the groom, Alexander Skarsgård. Von Trier disarms us by opening on a note of humor as the couple’s stretch limousine tries to navigate a severely winding road. (This turns out to be the only light moment in the entire picture.) Early or late, Dunst is destined to be unhappy, even on this ostensibly joyous occasion. Why her groom expected anything else from her is just one of the movie’s many unanswered questions.

With a nasty mother (Charlotte Rampling), a light-headed father (John Hurt), a domineering boss (Stellan Skarsgård), and a wealthy but imperious brother-in-law (Kiefer Sutherland), the setting is ripe for misery. Add to that one more pesky problem: an obscure planet may be on a collision course with Earth. That prospect suits the bride’s dismal mood to a T. This aspect of the story is explored in the second “chapter” of the narrative, which builds in intensity to a furious climax, set to the strains of Wagner.

Melancholiais fascinating, to a point, but full of frustrating, unexplained behavior by its downhearted cast of characters. I realize that this is a metaphoric tale, but there still ought to be some internal logic. Von Trier orchestrates his twisted story with great skill, and generates considerable dramatic energy, but it’s all sound and fury, signifying nothing.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , , , , ,


John Sluggett

Please explain what you mean by, "I realize that this is a metaphoric tale." I haven't seen the movie, so I am curious about this aspect of it.


The nature of the title "melancholia" kind of is the "internal logic." "Melancholia" was the medical term given to people with inexplicable melancholy. Also, this seems like an interesting nod to Durer's "Melancholia," a print that suggests an apocalyptic tone and sadness.


We are trying to drudge through this piece of crap movie that is in love with its own misery, it's own annoying pretentious theme music, and the lead character's depressed boobies. Save your $7.98 from Tivo. Use it to buy some generic antidepressants and send them, with love, to Mister Lars Von Booooring. I'd rather be hit with a planet than have to watch this thing again.

diane esterley

As in surreal art, it is not always necessary to make sense, i.e. or a point. This story and it's beauty will stay with you for a while.

Virginia Adams O'Connell

I agree with the reviewer–lack of internal logic.

Dale Nichols.

more like the "Twilight Zone" I was in awe of the ending, wondering along…..what if? It was slow at times & the dialogue at times were hard to understand, but overall, i liked it….if your're looking for action, don't waste your time. I would recommend this movie only to an adult.

Ed Casey

Having heard a great deal about von Trier, finally screened Antichrist and was intrigued by its visual creativity. Ultimately, some scenes were violent and disturbing and I was not able to finish it. Von Trier also made comments about being a Nazi at Cannes. Perhaps its time for film fans to walk away from this unique but possibly mentally unbalanced person. This latest film review gives witness to a person who may need mental treatment rather than an audience.


O.K., same script, modified, with new plot twist..Dunst on her way to her sisters wedding, becomes possesed , and needs a shot of estrogen, that can only be delivered by defrocked priest Skarsgard, with Sutherland as his CIA bodyguard, but it must be completed in 24 hours or the Earth will collide with all of the Hollywood scripts that are returning to Earth to fulfill their Ultimate Goal, destroy civilization on Earth with their lack of credibility…Rewrite…


For anyone who knows Depression, the film's logic and characters' behavior is sublimely coherent.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *