Back to IndieWire

Cross Post: Oiling the Oscar Machine

Cross Post: Oiling the Oscar Machine

Sasha Stone from Awards Daily attended the Oscars last night and write a very good analysis piece.  She has a big section on Viola Davis and Meryl Streep which she has given permission to cross post.  You can read the full piece here.


When Best Actress finally came and Meryl Streep won I felt badly that I couldn’t fully rejoice in Streep finally winning an Oscar and I felt bad that her win felt so manufactured, gift-wrapped and delivered by Harvey Weinstein. And I felt bad that the Academy didn’t take the opportunity to change the course of the Best Actress race by doing the impossible. I knew that the fallout would be the fans of Meryl Streep rejoicing, chanting “I told you so!” and that those who were rooting for Davis would feel angry and crestfallen. I knew that the subject of race would come up again, and people would want to talk less about race and more about who deserved to win. As if there is such a thing as “deserves.”

The Best Actress race is not a fair fight to begin with. There aren’t producers and Oscar dream makers lining up to make Oscar-winning roles for black women in their 40s. And though people like David Poland and Jeff Wells say things like “Viola Davis will have plenty of chances,” those of us at this long enough know that just ain’t true. Davis was the ONLY actress in a Best Picture contender. It was the highest grossing of the Best Picture contenders. Much of its success was due to Davis and Spencer. But people say, oh the part wasn’t big enough. And Marlon Brando’s in The Godfather WAS? And Nicole Kidman in The Hours was?

Nobody wants to call anyone racist, certainly not the Academy, who have tried to change the errors of their waves in the past couple of decades, once people really started talking about it.  But the racism that afflicts the Best Actress race isn’t the Academy’s fault, particularly.

The key to this discussion is how impossible and improbable it would be for an actress like Davis ever to get a part like Streep got in The Iron Lady. When Meryl Streep told Hollywood to find Davis a movie, it seemed like the nicest thing to say at the time and it was well intentioned.  Streep couldn’t have been more gracious to Davis throughout and probably would have been happy if Davis had won.  But this was a year Streep wanted to win and everyone knew she was overdue, moreover, Streep was said to be heading into the “lifetime achievement” era of her career and some were saying her chances of winning another Oscar were going to get more and more rare.  I doubt that.  She will never run out of roles until she is unable to speak.

The Help was a rarity. Those kinds of roles in any mainstream Hollywood film hardly ever come along. They’re practically impossible for white actresses above 40, so you can only imagine what they are for black actresses. Viola Davis’ entire career has been making the tiny discards of the roles she’s been offered better.

Oh, it’s fine to give out plenty of supporting nods to black actresses but lead? Lead is a whole different thing, isn’t it. It’s a prom queen thing. It’s a Sandra Bullock, Nicole Kidman, Kate Winslet thing. It’s actresses who get their chances at bat throughout their careers, with plenty of lead roles offered to them and varying degrees of portraits. But Viola Davis? It just doesn’t happen.

Still, it had to have been hard for Streep to walk up there and accept that award when so many people wanted Davis to win.

You see, the Oscars aren’t really anything important. They aren’t curing cancer or helping the poor. They are a night for back-patting and really nothing more. They can’t mean anything because the people voting on them don’t consider them carefully enough for them to mean something. They for whom and what they “like.”  They are film awards as a Facebook status update.

For those who really really wanted Meryl Streep to win a third Oscar they will be happy tonight because the institution that they respect awarded the actress that they respect. But it’s a funny thing, to respect an established institution. That kind of establishment has a long history — and that history is far reaching. The reason that only stories about white people, made by white people, and starring white people, are what Hollywood makes is because that’s what the public buys. And the public buys that because those are the only narratives they have been conditioned to respond to. You see, it’s a vicious circle.

Change will come but it will take more upstarts like Davis. But never listen to anyone try to tell you it isn’t about race. It was about race the minute each actress in those films signed their contracts. It was about race because one has had an entire career to stretch and grow and play an array of leading ladies, and one has always had to play whatever tiny character parts the American public could accept a black woman in.

Viola Davis was still a winner tonight. She doesn’t have an Oscar but she has the stuff inside that matters.

This Article is related to: News and tagged , ,



I think Viola Davis is a wonderful actress, but Streep deserved to win. She completely transformed into Margaret Thatcher. The movie itself wasn't perfect (too much time was spent on Thatcher's dementia that could have been spent developing her earlier years), but she was phenomenal. It's hard to believe this was the same actress who played Julia Child. I think it's great that an actress in her sixties has been so successful.


Sorry, but Stone has behaved incredbily poorly throughout this Oscar season with regards to the Best Actress race. Some of her comments on twitter and in the comment section of her website have been very nasty(she even suggested that Streep only mentioned Adepero Oduye in her Globe speech as some sort of devious Oscar strategy to put it into the minds of voters that Oduye is the African American actress that deserves awards over Davis).

As a black woman, I really hope Davis' career takes off and more black women get good roles. Just as I hope ALL women get better roles. But going on about how Davis won't get the kind of roles that Streep has gotten is ridiculous, because no other major actresses will. No other actresess have managed to sustain a career at 60+ staring in movies and finding sucess at the box office like that. Streep is a freak case, and it's unfair to other actresses to compare them to her.

It took Glenn Close 20+ years to get a passion project like Albert Nobbs made. Close was a big star back in the day and has 6 Oscar nominations under her belt. But she still struggles for film roles. Fact is The Iron Lady would not have gotten funding with Close instead of Streep. And there's an endless list of other talented actresses that no longer get good work or even any work.

Stone has spent much of the season trying to stoke controversy by making it all about race and in the process, has actually been very anti-women.


Amen Sasha! You are right on, unfortunately.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *