You will be redirected back to your article in seconds
Back to IndieWire

A Certain Tendency of the Documentary Cinema

A Certain Tendency of the Documentary Cinema

The celebrity-driven nonfiction film has become an unwelcome mainstray of the documentary form recently. Not only is Oscar-winning director Davis Guggenheim (“An Inconvenient Truth”) directing commercials for none other than public persona #1 Barack Obama, but a whole slew of pop-docs are premiering at the Tribeca Film Fesival next month, with new films on Joseph Papp, musicians such as Queen and Tony Bennett, and sports figures such as the Red Sox’s Tim Wakefield and the Met’s R.A. Dickey. There’s also star-studded docs on digital cinema (“Side by Side,” featuring James Cameron, David Fincher, George Lucas, etc) and Morgan Spurlock’s latest “Mansome” (with interviews with Will Arnett, Jason Bateman, Paul Rudd, Zach Galifianakis, etc). And do I care? Not really.

Tribeca has premiered its fair share of important docs, from “Jesus Camp” to “Taxi to the Dark Side.” But it’s also increasingly become a home for hagiographies and celebrity profiles, with films on famous designers (Halston) and famous musicians (Elton John) and figures (Joan Rivers). While I’m sure there’s place for these name-driven docs, and the star status of their subjects drive a certain amount of ticket sales, by and large, the films don’t interest me.

Granted, I have stayed away from many of them, so perhaps I can’t accurately judge this tendency in documentary filmmaking, but it seems to me that there is a general lack of complexity in the work. After all, how much can you paint a shaded portrait of a celebrity who probably has some control over the subject matter, and doesn’t want to be shown in a negative, or ambiguous, light?

At Sundance, I thought Joe Berlinger’s Paul Simon documentary “Under African Skies” largely avoided the pitfalls of the celebrity doc, showing some of the problems with Simon’s South African visit during the Apartheid years, but then again, the movie also suffered from it, and would have been far more complex and interesting, I suspect, if Simon wasn’t so actively involved. The problem is that celebrities are celebrities for a reason, they’re charismatic and persuasive and have a great screen presence, which makes them natural documentary subjects. (Look, some of the greatest docs ever — “Don’t Look Back,” “Gimme Shelter,” for instance, focus on pop stars.) But it’s necessary to inject any strong film with a level of ambiguity that is often lacking in these films.

Unlike the Premiere and Spotlight sections at fests, the competition slates at Sundance, SXSW and Tribeca are rife with documentary films that have not a single famous name in them. Perhaps that is where we should focus our attention.

This Article is related to: News and tagged



THANK YOU for this honest review finally voicing the general public feel.


It is a laudable effort to point to the crass commercialization of docs, but I think it extends to the necessity of Leo or Morgan lending their voices to docs to maybe get some distribution and to the music celebrity docs etc. – it is just a reflection of the overall decline into celebrity reality TV culture without any reflection and critical distance, but what is disturbing is the trend of festivals following suit, as they are also dependent on the same attention and dollars as is (what has become) mainstream schlock.

Bill Nichols

We had The Most on Heff long ago, Lonely Boy on Paul Anka, Dont Look Back on Dylan, etc so what's wrong with celeb dox, or like Hotel Terminus (on the search for Klaus Barbie) on the heinous and anti-celebrity? The main issue here, it seems, is hagiography not celebs as such. Can a filmmaker have a critical, distanced view of the subject or is all swoon and worship? Of course ads for Obama aren't even docs in any meaningful sense unless all nonfiction (I think they're nonfiction!) equals dox. Maybe the new feature on Sarah Palin will be the answer.


Or you can go to the many great regional documentary film festivals that actually celebrate these filmmakers in earnest, like Full Frame, True/False, etc. and avoid the for-profit festivals.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *