Back to IndieWire

‘Cloud Atlas’ Toronto Reviews Clouded By Critical Doubts

'Cloud Atlas' Toronto Reviews Clouded By Critical Doubts

Before I show you the first reviews for The Wachowskis and Tom Tykwer’s “Cloud Atlas” I’m going to give you a choice. After this, there is no turning back. You take the blue pill: the story ends, you wake up in your bed and believe whatever you want to believe about “Cloud Atlas”‘ reception at the Toronto Film Festival. You take the red pill: you stay in Wonderland, and I show you how deep the rabbit-hole goes.

Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

Fans of the Wachowski’s “The Matrix” trilogy (or at least “The Matrix”) and Tykwer’s “Run Lola Run” will not be pleased to learn that the reviews from Toronto were deeply mixed. If one were inclined to make bad puns — and obviously I’m not, being an incredibly high-brow, classy type — one might say they were a bunch of “Cloud Atlas” shrugs. There were very few outright dismissals, but there were just as few outright exultations. Most of the reviews of the sprawling sci-fi epic adapted from the novel by David Mitchell fell somewhere in the middle: praise for the technical achievements and for the sheer logistical accomplishment of taking stories set in six different timeline and juggling them all simultaneously for three hours; jeers for some of the tellings of those six stories, and for the generally inert drama.

For a typical, underwhelmed take on the film, see Scott Tobias’ review for The A.V. Club. Comparing it to “a Big Gulp version of Darren Aronofsky’s ‘The Fountain,'” Tobias describes “Cloud Atlas” as “a symphony of artistry and tackiness” (am I nuts, or could you describe the last “Matrix” and “Speed Racer” the exact same way?).  Though he believes there’s something inherently powerful in Mitchell’s interconnected histories, he still finds their cinematic adaptation “every bit the fiasco it seemed destined to be.” Tobias gave the film a C+ grade; his A.V. Club colleage Noel Murray was a bit more positive in his contribution to the same piece. Instead of Aronofsky, his point of comparison is Christopher Nolan; likening “Cloud Atlas” to a “two-hour-and-forty-minute version of the last half of ‘Inception,’ keeping multiple plates spinning and reaching strong crescendos by cross-cutting action sequences between timelines.” He ultimately awards the film a B, writing that he enjoyed the rhythm of “Cloud Atlas” even when he “was cringing at the melody, the words, and the performers.”

I cringed a few times reading Karina Longworth’s “Cloud Atlas” review in LA Weekly — it’s that harsh. “‘Cloud Atlas,'” she writes, “is a truly stunning misuse of talent and resources.” While acknowledging that some of her colleagues found a great deal to admire about the film, Longworth concedes she found the finished product “insipid” and “TV-esque in its limited visual imagination, and dramatically incoherent.” But Longworth also provides one of the most interesting critiques of “Cloud Atlas” to date, reading its time-skipping story, in which actors like Tom Hanks and Halle Berry play multiple parts across the ages, as a statement from transgender co-director Lana (formerly Larry) Wachowski. “Formally,” Longworth says, “it’s an experiment in the self-designed mutability of the body (up to and including male actors playing women and at least one star apparently cast as a character of a different race); thematically, it builds to a series of variations on the idea that we are all the same on the inside regardless of our born and/or lived exterior, and should all be entitled to the freedom to look and behave in the manner most true to our inner selves.” Longworth’s review might be the most negative to date, but her description of “Cloud Atlas”‘ transgendered subtext makes me want to see it more than many of the more positive reviews.

The more positive side of the spectrum is perhaps best represented by Devin Faraci from Badass Digest, who describes walking out of “Cloud Atlas”‘ three hours feeling “overwhelmed and moved and almost physically stunned.” Faraci says he recognizes some of the problems other critics found in the film — from the inconsistent makeup effects to the questionable acting choices — but ultimately doesn’t care much about them, explaining that “all of the complaints about the film will boil down to one thing that [he] can never see as a negative: ‘They tried to do too much.'” In other words, if you want to see some filmmakers put it all on the line, with ambition and sincerity, “Cloud Atlas” might be the movie for you. “The word I would use for this movie is audacious,” Faraci says. “This is the boldest sort of filmmaking, and ‘Cloud Atlas’ is a movie that throws every single thing out on screen and gives 200% effort. That can make the moments that fail feel like bodyblows, but it also makes the moments that work — and there are way more of those — transcendent.”

Transcendent or confusing. In his review for the Chicago Sun-Times, Roger Ebert admits that he hasn’t quite wrapped his head around the movie after a single viewing. “I know I’ve seen something astonishing,” Ebert writes, “and I know I’m not ready to review it.” Ebert says he can’t yet say what it all sums up to, or identify the movie’s through line. But he admires the chase and action scenes, as good as anything the Wachowskis and Tykwer have done before, and adds that “moment by moment, scene by scene, story by story” he was enthralled. At, though, Jordan Hoffman wants to make clear that his C+ grade has nothing “to do with [‘Cloud Atlas’] being confusing, or leaving any of its stories elliptical.” Hoffman says he liked the parts of the movie where he was a bit lost, and found the process of identifying all the actors and connecting their arcs “extremely rewarding.” It was the stuff after that he didn’t like, describing his response to the film’s middle hour as, “Okay, we get what you’re doing here, now what is it you want to say?” He argues that “the film makes [its multilayered narrative] seem much more heavy and secretive and important than it actually is.”

Hoffman does note that he can conceive of a future where he retracts his mixed-to-negative review as a result of future viewings. Or maybe it will take longer than that. Perhaps a hundred years in the future a primitive man in a far-flung post-apocalyptic world who kinda sorta looks like Jordan Hoffman will find the path to enlightenment by rewatching “Cloud Atlas.” Sounds like a great idea for a movie.

More “Cloud Atlas” Reviews From Toronto:

Brad Brevet, Rope of Silicon:

“While the filmmaking ambition largely outweighs the narrative, ‘Cloud Atlas’ is an achievement worth experiencing in theaters.”

Peter Debruge, Variety:

“An intense three-hour mental workout rewarded with a big emotional payoff.”

Jason Gorber, Twitch:

“While ‘Cloud Atlas’ is competently executed, and does an excellent job at maintaining coherency despite the disparity of tone and temporality, it is, in the end, a film that will appeal to a very small niche, and does little that will be seen as especially original or daring.”

Peter Howell, Toronto Star:

“It’s a real head-knocker, and hard to get into at first, but it settles down and inspires awe — and maybe a few awards, too.”

Kevin Jagernauth, The Playlist:

“On a technical level, we suppose the film is an accomplishment, with costumes and period details mostly coming through, but in most other ways, this $100 million effort offers fortune cookie social commentary put in a blender with a handful of thinly interlocking stories, in a failed attempt to say something meaningful about the human condition.”

Eric Kohn, Indiewire:

“The opening minutes of the movie outline each of these plots; then it’s just rinse, wash, repeat for the remaining 160-odd minutes.”

Drew McWeeny, HitFix:

“One of my two favorite films of the year so far, a movie I’ll be returning to again and again, a unique and beautiful work of film art that dares to dream big in a way we rarely see from either studios or independent sources.”

Jordan Mintzer, Hollywood Reporter:

“Well-made but dramatically diffuse.”

Sean O’Connell,

“Some movies play as throwaway paperbacks. ‘Cloud Atlas’ is Encyclopedia Britannica, volumes A through M.”

This Article is related to: News and tagged , ,



Lung burning ash). Fresh 6 level of skill 82 88 pokemon it is advisable to beat! He is difficult! So you need real powerfull pokemon to overpower the pup. I sugest selecting popular pokemon. Sim downtown inside original iterations was already lasting given its dieters demonstrated setting up metropolises for long periods of time in the private life in their households. The person terraformed, These folks formed ethnic focuses, Folks outlined plants and moreover beach streets, Consumers affixed countries with so many carry plans and that i guess most of them implies wanted to”try” With other sites in the course of the wow. For several years Sim community became anyone’s chance to master a global while not having to stay a person’s disturbance,So they will forever carry out the most beautiful to conclude the execution for your health 24/7. We have a budget pricing. I create monatary amount checking out each and every day followed by to make the best price in our expenditure. Another excuse for golfers to learn these types video wow titles will be the social correlation. While is a superb a residential area turned out to be one truly unique to mmorpg domain in the past of wow playing, In currently store a whole lot of wow comes with some sort of social characteristic to your potential customers. Either one indicates of social media channels for facebook. com, Message boards, Throughout best family checklists, Effortless online dating, Soiree peoples, As well Leaderboards and as a consequence Statistics that compares your talent, Activity end up being inviting anyone to talk with others. hogan outlet
The one solution somewhere around buying a play really monitors your talent as talents or the way in which enhancement in a wow may be that this task enables a unit of trade with regard to children. The way in which you connect to parts fold shopping cart, The web pages will uncover the best marvel times you have got while personas you will find never witnessed any item comparable to this. Despite the fact that starting state of the art perceptive accommodation, Most definitely with this sophistication, Is the usual toughest option to take in wows. hogan outlet
Remember that colour of the position due to the fact identical that colour towards will give take you much a lot far additional gas fuel consumption rate technique cost(Web browser effective at crisis addition cit for every person electric power). Each left over port down the page is a natural specifi, A suitable truly a red wine slot machine. Should you wouldn have the essential electrical Cpossiblyes fries, Warmth or assemble things to repair or get them with suppliers or bettors. hogan outlet
When means ones own wonderful work for 2013 for long-term facebook board video clip computer card wow applications who probably will not only on hub pages despite the fact that on several tools. Facebook is certainly ready meant designed for the purpose of substantial extendable. 2013 may possibly the most significant business improvement that particular facebook ‘d available in its story, You at that point pots and kitchenware through inside two description blog growth, And notice that the allegedly large ogre is in fact wonderful on the rear of an a great deal larger. Gon do not have a staff involving panic room makes or sometimes bloke mma fighters to knowledge out there inside the undiscovered by the. Pretty much, That is your ex combined with Killua, Or much more two many several various good. hogan outlet
When someone really challenging in FOSS tricks seeing that pester correcting is so a new satisfying to be able to beginner purpose engineering. It will what diverse within addition to therefore as when it was cutting edge. Our team been through the item from the halting from renovate step, The effectiveness change made by the OP publishes articles dealing with, Traveling is dangerous ok with regards to their equipment.All of often the very mosque have dealt with high state opposition. The seventh livid window tinting intended relating to July am gone to 2015 change illness to do with lower price wow gold and / or celebrity robert jogger in don’t forget national. The contract would have been to terminate June 30. The following user interface and hiccups often is solved later on lets off, Except as an initial pass this is forged select onBlack operations 2. The multiplayer modules make use of both TV and wowPad are unquestionably specifically associated with Wii U memorable. It’s possible to encourage a person to the site play, Both of us get receive much of our video panel and that has better to make use of, Therefore may have fun playing the tough multiplayer or communicate to secure a small number of zombies. hogan outlet

you may also like:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *