Back to IndieWire

Inconceivable! William Goldman Says He’s Having Trouble Writing ‘The Princess Bride’ Sequel

Inconceivable! William Goldman Says He's Having Trouble Writing 'The Princess Bride' Sequel

Even if you aren’t morally opposed to the idea of sequels, it’s hard to fathom that a long-dormant – yet still incredibly popular – title or franchise could produce a sequel that would live up to the expectations of the fans. For every time a studio thinks that a “Ghostbusters 3” or “The Dark Crystal 2” is a good idea, there’s examples like “The Godfather Part 3,” “Tron: Legacy” or at the bottom of that barrel – “The Son of Mask.”

One title that’s long been rumored to have a sequel in the works is the classic 1987 Rob Reiner film “The Princess Bride.” With a working title of “Buttercup’s Baby,” the story idea William Goldman has so far (and has written as an extra chapter in printings of the book) involves a villain with no skin on his face kidnapping Westley and Buttercup’s daughter, Waverly, and throwing her off a cliff, with Fezzig, her babysitter, leaping off after her to protect her from the impact. But he still seems stuck on where to go next.

Celebrating its 25th anniversary at the NYFF (along with a solid anniversary Blu-ray release this week), director Rob Reiner, writer William Goldman and cast members Billy Crystal, Robin Wright, Cary Elwes, Mandy Patinkin, Carol Kane, Wallace Shawn and Chris Sarandon were on hand to talk about the film – with Goldman sharing his thoughts on the idea of a sequel. “I’m desperate to make it and write it and I don’t know how,” said Goldman, a writer who’s had no problem cracking difficult stories for scripts like “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” and “All the President’s Men.” “I would love to make it, more than anything else I’ve not written.”

Some other interesting tidbits were discussed at the event, most of which we covered in our own “5 Things You Might Not Know About The Princess Bride” feature, but of course this sequel bit is what most will flock to. It seems like Goldman is certainly game for giving himself the challenge of doing another ‘Bride,’ but given how long this has been talked about with zero follow through, we don’t see this ever happening. Unless an ill-conceived reboot or remake is in store, we think the original film has plenty of gas left in the tank to keep running for many more years.

This Article is related to: News and tagged ,


feenyx blue

Ummm… you do understand that z. Morgenstern never existed, that there is no bad parts version, that that part of the novel was all made up? Becauze thats part of the satire. Florin dosent exist.

Joe Assaf

Actually, Goldman really did write it. Morganstern was just a literary device that he used as part of the story. I fell for it the first time I read the book, and looked for the original unabridged edition to read, only to find out that Goldman was the only and original author.


This article is EXTREMELY misleading. The author clearly did not research the subject before writing on it. The Princess Bride was originally a novel by a Florinese man named S. Morgenstern. The version is around 1000 pages long and includes tedious descriptions of Florinese customs. It is heralded by Florinese scholars as a great work of satire. Goldman abridged it, keeping to the storyline and then also adapted it to film. The sequel, Buttercup's Baby, already exists. It, too, was written by S. Morgenstern. Goldman would love to abridge this version, but is being held up by legalties. The Morgenstern estate sent 11 lawsuits his way for his work on The Princess Bride. Eventually these were all dropped, but the Morgenstern representative was in talks with Stephen King to do the abridgment. Obviously Goldman wants to do it, but King, who has Florinese heritage felt that Goldman left out some important parts in his abridgement and believes he can do a better job. The sequel is being held up by legal concerns, not a lack of creativity of ability on Goldman's behalf.

Laurie Mann

Perfect works don't need a sequel…


Happy Anniversary Princess Bride! Come see our 1 minute or full 2 hour feature 'tribute' remake at


I'm not sure who that is in the little picture bubble but it's not William Goldman. At least not the William Goldman the article is about.
Interesting article all the same. I hope he figures out how to write it because I'll be first in line.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *