Sundance 2013: Robert Redford Says There Are Too Many Film Festivals

Sundance 2013: Robert Redford Says There Are Too Many Film Festivals

Robert Redford has remained the most resilient symbol of the Sundance Film Festival since its inception. To some degree, the movies come second: Even the breakout hits, like last year's "Beasts of the Southern Wild," take on new identities once they move beyond the festival environment. While Sundance alone can never define the best work in contemporary cinema, Redford takes great pride in his continuing ability to expose it.

Like clockwork, the actor-director-activist speaks confidently with press on the first day of the festival about the lasting value of Sundance as it moves through each decade of changes to the art and commerce of filmmaking, and this year was no exception.

However, this time he made a curious admission: If he had the opportunity to create Sundance today, he might think twice.

"I think there are probably too many festivals," Redford told a roundtable of journalists in Park City this afternoon. The actor said his interest in Sundance grew out of a frustration about the platforms available to films that interested him early in his career. "I started getting anxious about the stories that I wanted to tell," he said. "I realized over time that I was straddling two worlds and more and more happen with the smaller films. I wanted to extend that."

Since then, the prospects of film festivals highlighting work either outside of the mainstream or adjacent to it has expanded to such a great degree that, when asked if he might want to launch Sundance in the current environment, the response was instant: "Probably not," he said, then echoed a sentiment expressed at last year's festival, when he made the bold assertion that Sundance was the only "truly independent" gathering of its kind.

READ MORE: Sundance is the Only 'Purely Independent' Festival? Robert Redford Thinks So.

Redford clarified that he would launch Sundance "if there was still a space to have an independent festival, because it's really independence that interests me." By contrast, he quickly ticked off the limited festival environment when Sundance began. "There was Cannes, there was Toronto, I think Telluride was just gearing up. There was the oldest festival in the world in Locarno, Italy. Lincoln Center hadn't gotten to where it is. And then Berlin hadn't come yet. So we had an exclusive space that was sharpened by the fact that we were the only independent festival in the world. So that felt good."

These days, however, "there's a festival in every neighborhood," he added. "I don't know about the overriding value except that we'll get the chance to see more films."

While his enthusiasm comes from a real place, Redford's notion of independence is a tenuous at best (and his timeline needs some cleaning up: The Berlin International Film Festival launched in 1961; Locarno is actually in Switzerland — but that's beside the point). Virtually every major festival, including the ones Redford listed, showcase movies made beyond the constraints of the studio system, and the European festival circuit certainly outdoes Sundance in its overview of the brightest filmmakers working outside of the United States.

Redford valiantly helps keep Sundance's visibility high, but the brand ramifications demand more precise definition each year, and neither the aging Sundance Kid nor his hardworking team can fully verbalize its function in the crowded marketplace of ideas that defines 21st century storytelling. "In the early years of Sundance, I didn't know how it was going to go," Redford said. "It's more than fulfilled its vision."

So, what's next? Even festival director and longtime programmer John Cooper, who headed the selection of the 114 features from a submission pool of 4,000, resists giving a firm answer on Sundance's continuing distinction. "We do good work," Cooper said when asked how he responses to shifts in the landscape of production and distribution that impact the types of movies that benefit from exposure at the festival. When that vague reply prompted this journalist to reply, "Oh, come on," Cooper clung to vagaries. "I actually don't think about it too much. You always just keep doing the work you do the best you can and the brand takes care of itself."

From an industry perspective, Cooper's assertion may do the trick: Sundance remains relevant because it's Sundance. The festival's Artist's Services program, launched this year and partly geared toward helping filmmakers launch their work on digital platforms, allows the strength of Sundance to blossom beyond the same geographical restrictions most festivals face and address emerging models.

The need for quality in programming offers a more elusive challenge. Each year, Sundance invites waves of hype generated by movies with stars or other commercial potential, sometimes to the detriment of smaller movies that by all rights should truly define its qualities. If one were to look beyond attention-hogging selections like the unpromising biopic "Lovelace" or other movies somewhat transparently chosen for factors that may have nothing to do with the "truly independent" notion Redford repeats each year, a far more diverse overview of aesthetic impulses await discovery in festival sections like the microbudget NEXT and New Frontier.

Even as competition movies from emerging voices like Lynn Shelton ("Touchy Feely") and David Lowery ("Ain't Them Bodies Saints") stand out in the competition, the real potential for Sundance to keep pushing its potential lies with the stranger-sounding titles, like New Frontier entries "Interior. Leather Bar" and "Halley," as well as the generally outré midnight section and typically first-rate documentary competitions. If there's enough to write home about in these sections, Sundance may still cling to the validity it has trumpeted for nearly 30 years. We'll have a better idea about that in 10 days' time, although nobody can doubt the festival's evident sincerity in tackling its mission.

"I found 115 films," Cooper said. "Why don't you try it?" He chuckled. "Maybe I'm naive and will be out of the job in 15 years. Quote me on that."

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , ,


yvette armstrong

I have a sundance film I am looking for help I wish you would contact me it is a great idea and will get a lot of people thinking I would really hope to hear from you my name is yvette Armstrong @ 206 551 6003 in Seattle. I have a children's book published thru author house I am not a nut just need a leg up thank you

Ekoli Hagenbuchle

I love Locarno but please the city is in Switzerland and not Italy.
That's not a lovely mistake for Swiss citizen.

Brian Newman

While he has specifics wrong and leaves off facts like how long San Fran has been around, his underlying premise is correct. Nearly every festival was started because there weren't good ways to see these films in many cities in the US. We now have lots of access, and most of these fests just regurgitate what Sundance programs. We don't necessarily need fests for discovery and there are way too many now.


There are only "too many film festivals," if you're already a very successful big time filmmaker.


He's getting very close to "You damn kids get off my lawn" territory in saying there are too many festivals. Bob, your indie film revolution was successful. This is what it looks like. The flipside of that is Sundance is no longer the only festival game for indie filmmakers.


Venice is oldest fest in world, founded in the 1930's. Locarno was founded in 1946. Berlin was founded well before Sundance….but, no matter, that basic premise is correct…or perhaps should be rephrased…there are too many festivals operating under the old premises of festivals.

jean vigo

Lynn Shelton is premiering her 5th (that's 5) feature. How does the term "emerging" qualify?

Her 1st won the Grand Jury Prize at Slamdance in 2006.


Great story. … The guy who started the nontraditional festivals…


Locarno is in Switzerland, just saying…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *