You will be redirected back to your article in seconds
Back to IndieWire



When people ask why my wife and I travel to wintry Syracuse,
New York every March—and celebrate our wedding anniversary there—I try to
explain that Cinefest is more than just a four-day marathon of truly rare
silent and early-talkie films. It’s also a “gathering of the clan,” a reunion
of old friends with whom we’ve spent quality time over the past four decades.
Not only is it fun to watch movies with this group, it’s educational: in the
audience are professional authors, archivists, and world-class specialists in
everything from silent comedy to copyright law. When I couldn’t remember the
name of a familiar character actor who turned up, younger than I’d ever seen
him, in the 1929 feature Why Bring That Up?, I turned to John Cocchi—who
can identify almost any actor in a vintage film, no matter how obscure—and he
replied, “Selmer Jackson…but I’ve never seen him without gray hair.” Thanks,

This year’s bill of fare was as varied as ever. Newcomers to
film buffery who watch only classic silent movies get a distorted view of that
era. For every Phantom of the Opera there were at least ten
undistinguished, bread-and-butter pictures to meet the demand of
entertainment-hungry audiences. On Friday, for instance, we watched an
enjoyable 1926 programmer called Wild Beauty starring Rex the Wonder
Horse, with some clever title cards and well-staged outdoor action, followed by
Maurice Tourneur’s deliciously ripe, stage-derived melodrama The Whip
(1917), which featured a train wreck that was staged just as we saw it—without
any special effects. Rob Stone brought along a selection of silent comedy
shorts featuring mostly-forgotten comedians from the Library of Congress,
chosen in conjunction with historian Steve Massa. One of them featured Billy
West, the most famous of Charlie Chaplin imitators; he had the costume, makeup
and even some of the great man’s mannerisms down pat. The only missing
ingredient was humor, at least in this example, Dough-Nuts (1917). Even
the presence of Oliver Hardy and onetime Chaplin colleague Leo White added
nothing to the film. On the other hand, a second show of comic rarities
included an amazing artifact from 1915 in which comedienne Dot Farley goes so
crazy for Charlie Chaplin at her local theater (where the familiar life-sized
standee is posted outside the entrance) that she makes her boyfriend (Sammy
Burns) wildly jealous. His only recourse is to try to pretend to be the Little
Tramp! Unfortunately, the surviving print of this film is missing the
conclusion, but it’s still an incredible find that bears witness to Chaplin’s
extraordinary popularity after just one year on the screen.

Elaina Archer, from the Mary Pickford Foundation, introduced
two rarities showcasing the beloved silent star: a 1912 Biograph short directed
by D.W. Griffith, So Near, Yet So Far, with fleeting cameo appearances
by the entire Biograph stock company (including Harry Carey, Lionel Barrymore,
Lillian and Dorothy Gish), followed by the rarely-seen 1916 feature The
, written by Pickford’s friend and collaborator Frances Marion.
Its story of an abandoned child who suffers a life of drudgery at an orphanage
and then in servitude to an unsympathetic landlady was copied, expanded and
refined in several later Pickford vehicles, but it was interesting to see this
early effort, mainly because it’s such a pleasure to watch Mary at work.

Other major silent stars were represented by little-seen
starring vehicles, including Jackie Coogan in My Boy, made the same year
Charlie Chaplin introduced him to the world in The Kid. This
heart-tugging story showed that it wasn’t just Chaplin who knew how to showcase
the adorable youngster…although the film was co-directed by Chaplin colleague
Albert Austin. (The main title also proclaimed that it was “supervised” by Jack
Coogan, Sr.)

The delightful Colleen Moore was featured in Come On
a crowd-pleasing 1922 feature which was part of our 35mm screening
program at the Palace Theater. Another film built on tried-and-true depictions
of Irish immigrants in New York City, it won over the Syracuse audience much as
it must have when it was first released, with such familiar faces as J. Farrell
MacDonald and Kate Price filling their expected costarring parts.

We also witnessed the first public showing of film buff
Michael Schlesinger’s faux 1938 comedy short It’s a Frame-Up, written,
directed and staged to resemble a lower-tier comedy team at work. This is
easier said than done, but Schlesinger and his talented cast managed to pull it
off surprisingly well.

One of the unexpected highlights of Cinefest was a showing
of home movies taken by comedian El Brendel on movie sets and locations in the
early 1940s. It’s rare to find genuinely spontaneous footage of actors and directors
at work—not to mention ordinary working stiffs walking to the commissary and
killing time between scenes. I’d always heard that actor-turned-director David
Butler had a bubbly personality on the set: now I could see it for myself.
Two-reel comedy veteran Jules White was also known as a ham, and Brendel’s
footage proved it. Glimpses of Bing Crosby, Gloria Jean, Curly Howard, and such
comedy short-subject favorites as Dorothy Appleby, Christine McIntyre, and
Vernon Dent got appreciative response from the Cinefest crowd.

One of my favorite discoveries of the weekend was a 1934
Paramount feature, The Pursuit of Happiness. This charming, witty
romantic comedy is set against the backdrop of Colonial America and deals with
the customs of the period regarding courtship. Francis Lederer plays a European
musician who is shanghaied along with other Hessians who are forced to fight
for the British cause—until George Washington lures them away with a better
deal. Lederer escapes and falls in love with Joan Bennett at first sight. Her
parents are played by Charlie Ruggles and Mary Boland in fine comic form. What
a treat to encounter a film from my favorite period of Hollywood that I’d never
even heard of before.

The nonstop feature films—with exceptional piano
accompaniment for the silents by pianists Jon Mirsalis, Andrew Simpson, and
Jeff Rapsis—were punctuated by a number of rarely-seen short subjects. In The
Fuller Gush Man
(1934) main titles are replaced by Walter Catlett greeting
writer-director Al Boasberg on the set and verbally introducing the costars and
even the crew!  Camp Meetin’
(1936) contrived a story around the beautiful vocal harmonies of the Hall
Johnson Choir. And there were a pair of 1931 two-reelers directed by Roscoe
“Fatty” Arbuckle—the best I’ve ever seen of his work behind the camera—Queenie
of Hollywood
, featuring the un-charismatic “Hollywood Girls,” and Honeymoon
, a fast-paced sight-gag comedy starring Arbuckle’s nephew Al St. John,
with Walter Catlett and Dorothy Granger.

No one would nominate Why Bring That Up? (1929) as a
great movie, but I am consistently impressed by the creativity of legendary
theater man George Abbott’s direction in his handful of early-talkie features.
This vehicle for the popular blackface comedy team Moran and Mack is a vividly
atmospheric backstage tale in which Abbott pays great attention to detail, with
his roving camera and use of ambient sound, to give us an unvarnished look
behind the scenes of show business…from his depiction of a theatrical boarding
house to glimpses of how chorus girls rehearse and get ready for a Broadway

I can’t go into detail about everything we saw—and I conked
out periodically, causing me to miss some of the goodies—but suffice it to say
that Cinefest offered a feast of unusual and rewarding films. A restored Our
silent played just before the recently-rescued Potash and Perlmutter
comedy, Partners Again, found in an 8mm copy in the UCLA Film and
Television Archive

Everyone who attends this wintry weekend event is grateful
to all the volunteers from the Syracuse Cinephile Society who put on such a
good show–at the expense enjoying it themselves.

If you have a large appetite for movies of the silent and
early-talkie period, I encourage you to attend Cinefest next year. You’ll see
one-of-a-kind prints that won’t ever turn up on DVD…or anywhere else. And if
you get to meet some of the savvy people in the audience, you’ll have an even
better time. 

This Article is related to: News and tagged



Hello Mr Maltin and other Cinefest Fans, My uncle, John Cocchi, always looked forward to his trip to Syracuse. It was like a pilgrimage to a religious shrine. Has anyone had any contact with him lately? Has anyone seen him recently? My family has had no contact with him in 3 weeks. Please email with any information that might help us get in touch with him. Your help is greatly appreciated. Thank you so much.

Brandy Dean

This was my first Cinefest and I'm totally hooked. It was amazing to meet you and find you so kind as to stand still for my camera for a few minutes. The movies were amazing – I'm with you on the revelation that was "The Pursuit of Happiness"- but the most exhilirating part of the whole experience was the fellow film buffs. Finally I've found my people – and their eyes didn't roll back while I geeked out!

Walt Mitchell

GREAT to see you again! The way you conducted the auction was perfect–moving right along without the breakneck pace. I'm so glad that you aren't an auctioneer by profession, or I'd never have been able to understand or keep up with you! Your exhortation when selling that fabulous film collection was very moving, and I was SO glad that it resulted in the lot being sold, even at the $3,000.00 minimum bid!

I was also relieved to read here that you conked out! So did I, and it was frustrating because it happened to me near the end of the movie I wanted to see more than any other: "Why Bring That Up?"! Fortunately, I woke up before it ended, but I later had to ask Gerry how Charlie Mack wound up in a coma and being taken to the hospital.

Leonard, I watched the end of that film and was stunned at what I saw! I refer to George Moran bringing Charlie Mack out of a coma by prompting him with something that he knew and could respond to! To think that that fictional scene would be played out in real life decades later by my dear friend Mel Blanc and his doctor–absoutely amazing!

One last note, so to speak: After the following movie, "The Woman Disputed," I went down to congratulate the pianist for his wonderful accompaniment. I also told him that, as something of a pop music historian, I had been aware that a theme song had been written for the movie, titled, "Woman Disputed (I Love You)," but I had never heard it. I asked him if he had played that during the movie. Without saying a word, he reached into his folder, pulled out the photocopy sheets of that very song for me to see–and then he GAVE them to me! WOW! Between all of that plus fun in the dealers' room, it was a series of memorable events! :-D!


I go to Cinefest mainly for the rare silents–like Behind the Door–but I enjoyed The Pursuit of Happiness more than anything else I saw this year. Clever and charming. The biggest disappointment was The Merry Monarch, which, for an Emil Jennings film, missed the mark by a wide mile.

Eli Savada

Sorry I missed this year's show, but a family commitment pulled me away. Can't wait till next year. Looking forward to a glimpse of Mike's film, too! Until next March…

mike schlesinger

Thanks for the hat-tip, Leonard! But please permit me to add that it wouldn't have been possible without our equally talented crew, most of whom have been in the business for decades. As I like to say, the only amateur on the production was me!


Maybe some of this material will show up on TCM…


Our Gang was one of my favorites growing up. It was probably around fifteen years ago, I was seven or eight years old, when my mom bought my siblings and me a VHS box set of Our Gang. It seems like something that one would have to special order or pay more for at a Barnes and Noble. (Relying on my faded memory) I think she had actually purchased it from kmart or walmart at an outrageously low price. It was a perfect series for such a large family. Eight kids in a small farm house!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *