Back to IndieWire

What Makes a Great Biopic?

What Makes a Great Biopic?

Do you remember the feeling of watching a perfectly sculpted Angela Bassett breathe pain and life into the microphone as Tina Turner in “What’s Love Got to Do With It?” In the film, Turner’s “Proud Mary” becomes a salvation song, the performance a cathartic, explosive release for Turner during years of abuse and rising stardom. Its dramatic mix of golden shingled-dresses, penetrating vocals and embodied performances delivers a deeper understanding of the person it attempts to portray.

The subject of biopics seems to be on a lot of lips lately, especially those about Black figures. Films about Marvin Gaye, Nina Simone and Jimi Hendrix are all expected within the next year, with much controversy and anticipation. But here’s a chance to step back from that more fiery debate, and into one that actually considers the ingredients of a successful biopic. What makes the audience feel they’ve entered the world and life of a popular figure, which they’ve been allowed to access intimate moments that ring with authenticity and depth?

Casting stands as an integral component, and not just in regard to a physical likeness between the actor and the person they’re portraying. Recall Forest Whitaker as a terrifying, yet jovial, Idi Amin in “The Last King of Scotland,” directed by Kevin Macdonald. Facial features between them aren’t exact, but the way in which Whitaker enters Amin’s body is nothing but. He achieves the posture of Amin, the deathly glare that quickly dissolves into an absorbing laughter, and the specific Ugandan accent. Alternate between speeches of Idi Amin and scenes from “The Last King of Scotland” and you’ll notice Whitaker’s exact replication of this man, an artistic commitment that helped secure his Academy Award win for Best Actor in 2006. You’ll also notice the keen level of detail in every aspect of the production—from Amin’s military suit to his wife Kay’s cornrows.

Other than casting, there’s a more structural element involved in the writing and directing of these stories that involves presenting these people as humans, rather than “stars,” “saints” or complete villains. This is where extensive research becomes essential. In the 1999 television film “Introducing Dorothy Dandridge,” a wall is broken down when the audience experiences Dandridge’s 1954 Academy Award loss with her. She sits in the audience almost holding her breath, and we do as well, even though the outcome is evident. It’s a fascinating moment that brings in the larger context of racism that Dandridge faced during that time, and that many Black actresses still face today.

This balance of the portrayal is probably one of the more important ingredients of the biopic—between these figures’ internal conflicts and their love for their craft, between their mistreatment of the people close to them, and the love they share with their mother or father. We want to be in the presence of a fully developed person, and understand the basis for their talent: how a blind child named Ray Charles became a musician, how Tina Turner’s impromptu rehearsals in her mother’s house led to mega-stadiums, or how Malcolm X’s painful “conk” experience at the barbershop laid the groundwork for his encouragement of black pride and self-love later on. These flawed, proud, and beautiful moments become explorations of some of the most beloved public figures.

So, what do you look for in a quality biopic?

XFINITY On Demand™ is currently featuring the biopic “Coach Carter.” Learn more, and join the celebration of Black entertainment at

Editor’s Note: Shadow and Act partnered with XFINITY to celebrate Black entertainment. Be sure to visit, a unique digital community built around the love of Black TV, film, sports, music and more. Shadow and Act hopes to enrich this community and provide a launching pad for insightful discussion. Look to Shadow and Act for features and content examining and exploring key themes and topics that run throughout the history of Black entertainment.

This Article is related to: Features and tagged , , ,



The best biopics are those with the best writing (of a compelling storyline), and inspired portrayals. Nothing redeems or represents a life-story as does excellent writing and a skillful narrative. And, nothing sinks a biopic as completely as a trite, poorly conceived, formulaic, cliche' ridden screenplay and script. Frankie Lymon (Why Do Fools Fall In Love) comes to mind, as does Ruby Bridges (sorry Euzhan, I love you otherwise). As well, a biopic can sink or swim on the level of inspiration achieved by the key actors. I was an early detractor when I heard Jamie Foxx was slated to do Ray Charles but was floored by his performance. I recognize now that his work was an extension of his comedic ability to 'mimic' various characters, but he stepped beyond that zone to get to something that was really deep.

This is why Beyonce, could never get to Etta James — knew that wasn't going to work.

A better example is to check out Harry Lennix as Adam Clayton Powell — virtuoso work that went largely unnoticed. Lastly, I think 'star time', or attempts to fashion a heroic figure too often skews the story, i.e., the writer searches for the heroic moments that lead to an ultimate (and inevitable) triumph over forces of evil/the bad guy/the white man/ or the evil bad white man. All that's good, but give us some complexity a la Raoul Peck's rendering of the life of Lumumba — great, great storyline that needed no fake or added drama- just a skillful writer, performer, and director interested in exploring the possibilities of the art. No need for extra heavy-handed political overlay here. When all involved are comfortable and contemplative about their politics, the right vibe comes through!

Adam Scott Thompson

I think that the best biopics are about the most "filmworthy" period in a person's life rather than that life in its entirety. "Lawrence of Arabia" comes to mind. The only individuals we should follow to the grave (or the present day) are the ones whose whole lives entertain and intrigue — such as with "Malcolm X."

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *