Oscar Loves a Woman on the Edge: Eight Iconic Best Actress Snubs (CLIPS)

Oscar Loves a Woman on the Edge: Eight Iconic Best Actress Snubs (CLIPS)

Why does cinema favor the mad woman? It’s easy to see why Oscar does: roles like Jasmine French give an actress space to not only chew but swallow and spit up scene after scene. Cate Blanchett will almost certainly win Best Actress this year for her frittered, diabolical performance in “Blue Jasmine” as cinema’s archetypical woman-on-the-verge: that pill-popping, martini-swilling mad Medea who men fear and women sometimes dream of (being? playing? escaping into?).

Thus, here are eight classic Oscar snubs in the Best Actress category. Bow down to Gena Rowlands in “A Woman Under the Influence.” Watch clips after the jump. Also, check out our TOH! feature on eight scene-stealing female performances from 2013.

Who Won: Ginger Rogers (“Kitty Foyle”)
Who Should’ve Won: Joan Fontaine (“Rebecca”)
Who Was Nominated: Bette Davis (“The Letter”), Katharine Hepburn (“The Philadelphia Story”), Martha Scott (“Our Town”)

Hitchock’s delirious and deliciously twisted English gothic “Rebecca” tends to get lost in the ether when we’re talking about his very best films (“Vertigo,” “Psycho,” etc.) — as did Joan Fontaine in 1940 when she lost Best Actress to Ginger Rogers in “Kitty Foyle.” As the second Mrs. de Winter living in the shadow of the first, Fontaine delivers a note-perfect performance as an object of obsession driven mad by repressed spinster Mrs. Danvers, the live-in housekeeper who quite literally drives Fontaine over the edge. 

Who Won: Grace Kelly (“The Country Girl”)
Who Should’ve Won: Judy Garland (“A Star Is Born”)
Who Was Nominated: Dorothy Dandridge (“Carmen Jones”), Audrey Hepburn (“Sabrina”), Jane Wyman (“Magnificent Obsession”)

It was 1954 and Judy Garland was in the hospital when Grace Kelly was named Best Actress for “The Country Girl.” Allegedly, camera crews up and left the delivery room before Kelly even reached the stage. And what a wave of disappointment the bedridden Garland must have felt. Nothing in the world of movie musicals tops Garland’s virtual one-woman show in “A Star Is Born,” where a career-driven starlet becomes (as they often do) a pawn in the Hollywood game. You can’t experience Esther Blodgett’s highs and lows without feeling that it’s Garland’s torment, in a role that was intended to be her comeback, we’re really watching.

Who Won: Susan Hayward (“I Want to Live”)

Who Should’ve Won: Elizabeth Taylor (“Cat on the Hot Tin Roof”)
Who Else Was Nominated: 
Deborah Kerr (“Separate Tables”), Shirley MacLaine (“Some Came Running”), Rosalind Russell (“Auntie Mame”)

Though Taylor rightly won in 1966 for the best work of her career in “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?” the Best Actress prize could have easily gone to her for “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” in which she plays Tennessee Williams’ sexually rejected Maggie the Cat with ample flourishes of feline sexuality and woman-scorned bitterness. Every cutting jest slung at Paul Newman’s broken husk of a man, Brick, stings with venomous truth and anguish. That year she was beat by Susan Hayward in “I Want to Live” before finally winning in 1960 for “Butterfield 8”–an overrated movie and not her best work.

Who Won: Ellen Burstyn (“Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore”)
Who Should’ve Won: Gena Rowlands (“A Woman Under the Influence”)
Who Else Was Nominated: Diahann Carroll (“Claudine”), Faye Dunaway (“Chinatown”), Valerine Perrine (“Lenny”)

For my money, all actresses will forever be in the shadow of Gena Rowlands’ towering performance in the verite psychodrama “A Woman Under the Influence,” directed by John Cassavetes. Rowlands plays Mabel Longhetti, a nutty but lovable housewife with personality disorders for days, and a loyal husband who valiantly puts up with her manic bouts of loopy madness, despair and loneliness. It’s a truly astonishing embodiment of mental illness — and the beginning of a longtime collaboration between director and actress in which Rowlands would outdo herself again and again (see “Opening Night,” “Love Streams”). Burstyn’s is a worthy performance in Scorsese’s tender “Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore,” but she should have won in 2000 for another film (more on that later).

Who Won: Jane Fonda (“Coming Home”)
Who Should’ve Won: Geraldine Page (“Interiors”)
Who Else Was Nominated: Ingrid Bergman (“Autumn Sonata”), Ellen Burstyn (“Same Time, Next Year”), Jill Clayburgh (“An Unmarried Woman”)

In a year rife with great female performances, Jane Fonda won the Best Actress Oscar only six years after winning the same prize for Alan J. Pakula’s terrifically dark “Klute.” And while “Coming Home” holds up as a tender postwar film from director Hal Ashby, Geraldine Page (who won Best Actress in 1986 for “The Trip to Bountiful”) made a good film great with her unglued performance in Woody Allen’s “Interiors.” Playing the banished matriarch of a dissolute family whose husband leaves her for a bawdier, younger woman, Page throws herself headlong into the saddest work of her career–most memorably, a candle-side freakout in a New York church.

Who Won: Hilary Swank (“Boys Don’t Cry”)
Who Should’ve Won: Annette Bening (“American Beauty”)
Who Else Was Nominated: Janet McTeer (“Tumbleweeds”), Julianne Moore (“The End of the Affair”), Meryl Streep (“Music of the Heart”)

Annette Bening lost twice to Hilary Swank, first in 2000 and again in 2005, for Best Actress–but where few remember Swank’s performance in “Boys Don’t Cry,” Bening’s performance as suburban housewife Carolyn Burnham is unforgettable. She plays it tough and brittle throughout, but her deep-seated desperation and insecurity emerge quietly in a few key scenes — namely, in the empty living room of the house she can’t sell, pulling herself together, a flickering votive in cinematographer Conrad Hall’s visual cathedral.

Who Won: Julia Roberts (“Erin Brockovich”)
Who Should’ve Won: Ellen Burstyn (“Requiem for a Dream”)
Who Else Was Nominated: Joan Allen (“The Contender”), Juliette Binoche (“Chocolat”), Laura Linney (“You Can Count On Me”)

Julia Roberts dishes up some plucky charm in Steven Soderbergh’s whistleblower docudrama “Erin Brockovich” — the film that got Hollywood to take the seasoned romcom movie star seriously. But no brassy courtroom verbiage compares to Ellen Burstyn’s indomitable performance as starry-eyed spinster housewife Sarah Goldfarb. Yes, there’s that famous “red dress” monologue where she spills her broken guts to her drug addict son (watch it after the jump), but let’s not forget all the manic pill-popping, amphetamine-addled delusion that showcases her fearlessness as an actress — while at the same time dragging us down to hell.

Who Won: Jennifer Lawrence (“Silver Linings Playbook”)
Who Should’ve Won: Emmanuelle Riva (“Amour”)
Who Else Was Nominated: Jessica Chastain (“Zero Dark Thirty”), Quvenzhane Wallis (“Beasts of the Southern Wild”), Naomi Watts (“The Impossible”)

We all fell head-over-heels for Jennifer Lawrence as a grungy, all-cards-on-the-table kind of gal in “Silver Linings Playbook” — but did her win have more to do with Harvey Weinstein’s hawking and the Oscar machine than anything else? It’s hard to imagine that any female performance in 2012 could have been better than French actress Emmanuelle Riva’s startling work in Michael Haneke’s suffocating and tense “Amour” as a wife and mother who suffers a stroke and slowly, thereafter, debilitates. The performance lies mostly in silence and body language — no large feat coming from the star of Alain Resnais’ hushed (and doomed) 1959 romance “Hiroshima Mon Amour.”

Clips, after the jump.


This Article is related to: Features and tagged , , , , ,



Jane Fonda deserved her second Oscar for COMING HOME and if anyone was number 2 to Jane it was Ingrid Bergman for an astonishing turn in AUTUMN SONATA. Page, as good as she was, did her typical mannered work.

Salty Bill

Hilary Swank was great in Boys Don't Cry, I don't think of that performance as "forgotten."
I'm with you on Judy Garland and Gena Rowlands, though.


Wow … you are so incredibly wrong about Hilary Swank. Few remember? Should've lost to Annette? Wow … wow … wow. The rest I'll give you, but you're so completely wrong on Hilary Swank.


Hilary Swank was very deserving and won rightfully. And Trintignant was better than Riva in Amour, so the Lawrence was fine too!

Eddy Q

Few remember Hilary Swank in Boys Don't Cry? Really?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *