Back to IndieWire

Mr. Peabody & Sherman

Mr. Peabody & Sherman

As someone who grew up loving “Peabody’s Improbable History”
on Jay Ward’s animated TV series Rocky
and His Friends
and The Bullwinkle
, I approached this CGI feature with considerable trepidation. I’m
delighted to say that my fears were unfounded: this movie is a treat for diehard
Peabody fans and, I daresay, for newcomers as well.

Ty Burrell delivers a pitch-perfect vocal performance as the
world’s smartest dog, who has to prove himself worthy of being an adoptive
father to a wide-eyed human son named Sherman (nicely played by Max Charles).
In the old five-minute TV cartoons, there was no attempt to explore the nuances
of the characters’ unusual relationship. This being a feature, the fanciful
nature of their life together is sprinkled with a dose of real-life drama. Somehow
it all works.

Following the premise of the original series, Peabody and
Sherman travel back in time (via the WABAC machine) to propitious moments in
human history. From the French revolution to ancient Greece, our heroes find themselves
face to face with everyone from Marie Antoinette to Leonardo da Vinci. The gags,
both visual and verbal, flow at a steady pace, with some ingenious 3-D
flourishes along the way.

Some kids may ask for an explanation of a complex problem
that arises involving the time-space continuum, toward the climax, but I hope
the movie’s overall sense of fun trumps any confusion. It’s the characters that
matter most, and the film makes us care what’s going to happen to both Peabody
and Sherman.

Director Rob Minkoff has spent the better part of a decade
trying to get this movie made. It was well worth the wait. 

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , ,



Marketing is "key." I suppose we could explore the motivation for making this film, but LM had it covered.

Karen Colizzi Noonan

Your review has changed my mind about this film! The commercials and trailer did nothing to make me feel that this was a cheap rip off of the great TV shorts that I grew up loving. Peabody seemed too modern, not polished and refined as his character was in the original. But – if you say it works, then it's worth a try in my book!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *