Back to IndieWire

Rob Reiner Talks Roger Ebert’s ‘North’ Review

Rob Reiner Talks Roger Ebert's 'North' Review

Of all of Roger Ebert’s reviews, perhaps none is as widely known as his famous zero-star takedown of Rob Reiner’s 1994 film “North.” In fact, Ebert’s review has by far eclipsed the film: far more people can recite its famous line (“I hated this movie. Hated, hated, hated, hated this movie. Hated it. Hated every simpering stupid vacant audience-insulting moment of it”) than have actually seen the film – and thank goodness, because it’s as abysmal as its reputation suggests. Reiner — whose new “And So It Goes” opens Friday — arguably has never fully recovered from “North,” either, delivering a handful of populist favorites like “The American President” and a whole lot of bombs along the lines of “The Story of Us,” “Alex & Emma” and “The Magic of Belle Isle.” 

Reiner joked about Ebert’s review at his roast a few years ago (“If you read between the lines, [the review] isn’t really that bad”), but he commented on Ebert’s take again in an interview with ScreenCrush. The whole interview is worth reading to get a handle on Reiner’s mindset during different points in his career – “Misery,” for example, reflects how trapped  and pigeonholed Reiner felt by his own success – but here’s the relevant passage:

“And ‘North,’ to me, my good friend Alan Zweibel had written this book and I looked at it and I went, Every single kid that I knew, at some point, thought about what would life be like with different parents. Would it be better? And I just thought, hey this is a little fable. I wasn’t thinking of the pictures I made and the pictures I’m going to make, or any of that stuff. But the critics! Roger Ebert said, ‘I hated this movie!’ Seven times! He said ‘hated’ seven times. And I’m thinking, that’s because Roger Ebert wanted me to do something. He wanted me to do something that I didn’t do for him. So, I wanted to make this little fable — this little kind of quirky fable about a boy whose questioning if he could have different parents. That fantasy that kids have at all times. So, I liked that.”

Reiner doesn’t really get into what it was Roger Ebert wanted him to do, which doesn’t seem much more complicated than “entertain.” Still, Reiner’s take-it-in-stride response to Ebert is refreshing, considering how often critics are blamed or dismissed by some in Hollywood when they don’t care for their latest project. He doesn’t apologize for the movie (not that he should have to), and he might not see what the fuss over his little fable was (see: horrible ethnic stereotypes, hackneyed jokes/storyline), but he’s not so myopic that he can’t understand how someone might not go for it. Hey, can we get more of that?

This Article is related to: News and tagged , ,



Rob(Meathead)Reiner only proves like Bill Maher that some people can live a long time without a brain he proves by opening his piehole that he is stupid

Barry Smith

I actually liked NORTH, and can't believe all the criticism it has received over the years. Critics made it look like this was most racist movie ever made. But I have seen countless other movies with a lot more offensive stereotypes than NORTH. Since this movie is a comedy, you do have to expect over-the-top characters.

Visually, the movie is quite good, and contains excellent cinematography. However, NORTH does have its flaws and missteps. I do agree that the subplot featuring Winchell is more than a bit flabby, and the sudden change in tone during film's second half, is indeed strange (The title character is pursued by a hit man!). Additionally, the "all a dream" ending is rather useless and hackneyed. But I do enjoy watching this film, and have it in my DVD collection. Sorry, Roger Ebert (RIP).

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *