You will be redirected back to your article in seconds
Back to IndieWire

How Authentic is ‘Transparent?’ A Transgender Activist on Jeffrey Tambor and Other Portrayals

How Authentic is ‘Transparent?’ A Transgender Activist on Jeffrey Tambor and Other Portrayals

Indiewire chatted with activist and writer Jen Richards, the co-director of the Trans 100 and creator of the website We Happy Trans, about her take on Jeffrey Tambor’s performance, the transgender roles that speak most to her, and which upcoming shows she’s most (and least) excited about.

What did you think of “Transparent creator Jill Soloway’s interpretation of a man coming out as a woman?

Let me correct you right away.

Please do.

It’s not a man coming out as a woman. It is a transgender woman who is coming out. There’s a line in the beginning of the second episode where Jeffrey Tambor’s character, Maura, is talking to her eldest daughter. The daughter asks, “Does this mean you’re going to be dressing up like a woman?” And Maura replies, “My whole life I’ve been dressing up like a man.” That is the distinguishing reality for trans people.

What did you think of Tambor’s performance as a non-transgender actor playing a transgender role?

He did an excellent job. I’ve met many women like Maura. The trans community is very diverse and people come out at all ages — Maura is very much like the older, middle-class, white trans women that I’ve run into over the years. These women have a combination of sadness over a lost life and enthusiasm for finally being true to themselves. There’s a natural and endearing clumsiness that comes with someone who doesn’t begin to express their femininity in a public way until they’re much older.

Were there specific moments when you were watching that seemed very true to life?


There were many, and I have to give credit to Soloway. She has a parent who is trans, and she’s drawing from some of her real experiences. The moment that stood out the most is the scene in Episode 4 where Maura is terrified to go into the women’s bathroom with her two daughters. Entering the women’s bathroom was the biggest fear I had the first six months of my transition — to be in a space meant for women and then be told I don’t belong there. It seems like a superficial thing — it’s just a bathroom — but think about how many times a day you use the restroom. If you’re terrified to use the restroom because there’s a possibility of harassment or violence no matter which restroom you use, then it begins to dictate your entire day. It dictates when you can go out, how long you’re in public, what you eat and drink…

READ MORE: ‘Transparent’ Creator Jill Soloway on Her Real-Life Inspiration

Is “Transparent” the best television representation of a transgender character?

I would not go that far. I would say it’s the most thorough and popular representation of a particular type of trans person. It is the best depiction of a family going through a parent’s transition, and I love that it includes multiple trans roles. But I can think of other representations that I personally find more identifiable.

Like what?

My personal favorite was the British show “Hit & Miss,” where Chloë Sevigny plays a transgender assassin who discovers she has a son with a former lover.

The show was not well received by the trans community because Sevigny said some really problematic things in interviews that turned people off–


What did she say?

She was talking about how she had a very different interpretation of the character than the director. Sevigny wanted to make it much more exaggerated because she thought that’s how trans women are, an “exaggerated femininity.” She wanted to play the role like an over-the-top drag queen, which was completely off base. Her performance is more the result of a very good director with a clear vision, guiding the actor to do it appropriately.

So what did you like about “Hit & Miss”?

Sevigny’s character, Mia, in “Hit & Miss” is a single, younger white woman who’s attracted to men. That’s more my experience, more so than Maura’s character on “Transparent.” Mia’s dating experiences mirrored my experiences: You meet someone, you really like him, but you don’t even bother developing a real interest because you feel it’s impossible. Then you get to know him better, there’s this rush of excitement, and then the anxiety kicks in because you realize, oh god, I have to tell him. When you tell him, he freaks out. Maybe he still wants to see you, but it’s really complicated. “Hit & Miss” captured the complications of a straight trans woman dating men better than anything else I’ve seen.

So often we see transgender people as the butt of a joke on a sitcom or the victim-of-the-week on police procedurals such as “CSI” or “Law & Order: SVU.” What are some of the worst representations out there?


You nailed it. It’s the nameless ones — the anonymous trans people who are used as punch lines or tragic plot points. Even if they have a name or face, then they’re not really human and are only serving a function. You see a steady parade of that over and over again on shows. Almost every trans person I know talks about how they gave up on watching television. If you’re not clued into it, then you just don’t notice how constant we’re joked about. It’s dehumanizing.

People are talking about the increase in transgender roles on television, from “Transparent” and “Orange Is the New Black” to “Boy Meets Girl” in the UK and “The Switch” in Canada. If we’re seeing a move from negative roles to more positive ones, what accounts for the shift?

If I had to credit one thing more than anything else, it has to be the Internet. About ten years ago, trans people began organizing and finding each other online. Before then, the tendency has been always to disappear from society, to “go stealth,” or cut all ties from your past and don’t tell anyone you’re trans. Now people are choosing to live openly as trans, and they’re finding pride in it. We’re working together and celebrating each other. That’s the positive side. But the cynic in me asks, is the media just looking for the next new thing? As soon as marriage equality hit a cultural tipping point, I think there was the sense that trans people are the next hot issue and there are some exploitive aspects.

But it’s entertainment. I’m not afraid of the exploitation. I expect it. It’s just part of the game. It’s a matter of how well trans people can play that game. Can they even get into the game?


Lana Wachowski is an example of someone who’s in the game. Along with her brother, Andy, she has a new sci-fi show, “Sense8,” debuting on Netflix next year.

Lana is an out trans woman, and she and Andy have crafted a sci-fi series where one of the main characters is a trans woman, played by trans actress Jamie Clayton. Here we have a trans woman who’s written a part for a trans woman and a trans woman is playing it. As far as I know, that is a first, where the entire vertical alignment will be true to trans experiences.

And Clayton is an incredible actress. Her work in HBO’s “Hung” — where her character, Kyla, hires Thomas Jane’s character, Ray, to accompany her to her high school reunion — is amazing. I’m looking forward to her work in “Sense8,” and I’m looking forward to the day when there are more trans characters that are simply part of the cast.

Laverne Cox from “OITNB” first garnered attention on VH1’s reality series “I Want to Work for Diddy,” and later this year, VH1 is premiering “TransAmerica,” a docu-series produced by Tyra Banks. Is reality television another gateway for the trans community?

Bottom line, yes. Right now I am of the mindset that what we need the most is simply more of everything. That said, I think reality television is inextricably exploitive by its very nature. I am extremely skeptical that there can be a positive depiction of trans people in reality television. I don’t think anyone really comes off good in reality television because what is shot and what ends up airing is always so different. I’m wary for the release of “TransAmerica” because I think it’s going to be a very specific depiction of trans women. That said, I’m still all for it because I want more out there. There are a huge variety of us: We also have hot messes and crazy party girls. As long as we have that and we have “Transparent” and “Sense8” and “Orange Is the New Black,” then that’s the key.


Next week AOL is releasing the docuseries “True Trans,” which features Against Me! frontwoman Laura Jane Grace. It tells the story of Grace’s transition and her struggle with gender dysphoria. Are you less wary of this series?

Yes. I’m very excited for “True Trans.” The series will show Laura on tour, and at each city, she meets up with trans people and talks about gender. I was on location when they shot an episode in Illinois, and I was really impressed with the team behind the series. It was obvious they had learned so much about trans issues, and it felt very sensitive and respectful. The experience was like Laura herself — she’s a rock star but she’s also fun and sweet and humble. She will bring a quality to the show, and you will see a great cross section of trans people.

What transgender stories still need to be told?

For me, the serious concern is that in almost none of the current depictions do we see what are the really big issues facing the trans community. I love all this visibility. I think it helps humanize trans people, but my hope is that will bring more resources. There is a crisis going on in the trans community: HIV rates are astronomically high among trans women. There is also a crisis of violence, especially against black trans women. This is happening all over the country, and it’s the worst of the violence. There are homicides. Those stories are not being told on television.

READ MORE: Review: ‘Transparent’ Showcases Jeffrey Tambor’s Tremendous Talent (But Don’t Binge-Watch It)

This Article is related to: Television and tagged , , , , , ,


Comments

Lorelei Erisis

Ah! Finally, another trans woman who connected to the portrayal in "Hit or Miss"!! There were a few moments in that series that were so dead-on accurate to things I’ve been through that they knocked the breath out of me.

Kira Wright

I’m m2f just the idea of going to jail over a ticket that cost me my job was terrifying, there was talk of them running a train on me, then when I’m hemorrhaging from rectal trauma that they would impail me with a broom handle, being transgender is still a high risk status in many parts of society. You can be shot just for winking at a guy.

vicky

Love the fact that more about the trans community, which I am apart of, is getting aired.

Shelley Belsky

To me, the gold standard for the correct portrayal of a transwoman is Steven MacKintosh in "Different for Girls".
Nothing in any medium has done as well.
Though some have come close.

Melyssa Gentry

The truth about most transitions is there are some very difficult choices to be made, and while it is improving, there is the transgender day of remembrance for a reason. The violence by society, and even upon ourselves via suicide, should NOT be glossed over. Loss of long term loved ones for us more mature trans-women is a huge bitter pill and price to pay. There is truly deep emotional pain for many of us. THAT is one aspect of this show, or any really, has not yet addressed. Maybe next season.

PJ

This article, and the show are fantastic. Granted, I’ve only seen one episode, but Jeffrey Tambour is wonderful so far. Maura actually reminds me of a woman I know who happens to be transgender. I wanted to share a couple of points- My child is transgender and she came out a number of years ago. We have a habit of watching "Friends" reruns, and I’ve come to realize that most of the episodes usually have a trans joke in them, which has soured my experience of a show that normally offers me a lighthearted laugh. My daughter has not commented, however. My other comment was regarding the "exaggerated femininity" piece which I think may have two bases that "informed" this actor’s perspective: 1) she equates transgender women with drag queens,which those of us intimately acquainted with this topic know that is comparing apples with, say, blood oranges. The blood orange is red, but it still ain’t an apple. 2) women who come out later in life often have to contend with testosterone induced "male" physical traits, such as bone structure, hair loss, larger frames, etc. As a result, those women may resort to more pronounced methods of dress or make-up application, particularly if permanent body changes are not a priority or an option, that others misconstrue as "exaggerated femininity" when it may just be a case of over-applied make-up and too many accessories-fashion faux pas that natal women commit all. the. time. Finally, I will shamelessly plug my blog, only because I want to reach out to this community, particularly parents of transgender folks. It is: Parenting the Transgender Teen. If you enter transitioning family dot blogspot dot com, you’ll get there. If I give you the link here, I am not permitted to post as my comments are deemed "spammy." Thanks :)

benjamin adam

Unfortunately, the claims that there is a single distinguishing reality – "*the* reality" for trans people – is just as damaging and exclusionary as any other type of (mis)representation.

Kimberly Schroeder

This was very well written and carried a good coverage of our spectrum. The funny thing is we each want to stress the importance of our demographic and it’s bias concerning how we interpret the other subgroups in the community. Far from being a problem, it shows we are maturing because we recognize that our experiences withing the family are very different. The differences can be extreme. While most of us tend to be liberal i know of a few trans women who are right wing conservatives who even speak of the evil gay agenda. Others i know embrace the tr@nny image. There is no real trans culture, just people in every part of society who are trans.

Jen Richards

Let: I was fine with it in this case. The character is only beginning transition, so it makes sense to cast a cis man. Practically speaking, the studio also needed an actor strong enough to cast an ensemble cast and familiar to put producers and audiences at ease given the risky conceit. Most importantly though, Jeffrey took the role very seriously and spent a lot of time with trans people (big kudos to Zackary Drucker, Rhys Ernst, Jenny Boylan, Alexandra Billings, Trace Lysette, Ian Harvie, and Van Barnes for their input and guidance on and off set). His portrayal is nuanced, informed, respectful, and artful.

Let

But what did they think of a cis man playing a transgender?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *