Back to IndieWire

Carl Franklin Exits Tupac Shakur Biopic – Benny Boom Replaces Him (Will the Film Ever Get Made?)

Carl Franklin Exits Tupac Shakur Biopic - Benny Boom Replaces Him (Will the Film Ever Get Made?)

In April of this year, John Singleton exited the long-in-development Tupac Shakur feature project, to be replaced by Carl Franklin.

It all started when Singleton gave an interview to XXL magazine in early April, in which he shared that his involvement in the Tupac film had been put “on hold,” as some key items apparently still hadn’t been completely worked out: “I’m putting my involvement on hold right now because we’re trying to figure out some things,” Singleton said, adding, “I got a script and I got the blessings from his family. We’ll see…. We’ve got to get it right.” 

He didn’t say what exactly was responsible for the hiatus; he didn’t explain what “things” they were still trying to figure out, other than to say: “It’s a very intimidating because, like I said, you just want to get it right. I think the picture is not going to be good unless it’s offensive to some people. So, whenever you make a movie, you always have different elements that people have their say about. But when I’m making my movies, John Singleton movies, it’s really just my voice. So I can’t be listening to all the other suggestions of all these other people and shit. So we’re not going to pull the trigger on that until it’s right. If somebody else wants to do something different then they can do something different. But if it’s going to be right, it’s going to be right. It’s going to be something that potentially adorns ‘Pac’s legacy.”

It wasn’t very long after that when we got official word that Singleton was out and Carl Franklin was in.

News of the director switch quickly traveled, and some hours later, Singleton eventually spoke publicly about it, via his Instagram page, saying the following: “Real talk! The reason I am not making this picture is because the people involved aren’t really respectful of the legacy of Tupac Amaru Shakur. I won’t say much if you want you can read my articles in Hollywood Reporter on authenticity in Black Storytelling … To Pac’s real fans just know I am still planning a movie on Tupac … It doesn’t matter what they do mines will be better… Tupac was much more than a hip hop artist … He was a black man guided by his passions … Of most importance was his love of black people and culture … Something the people involved in this movie know nothing about… Real talk! How you gonna make a movie about a man when you suing his mother to get the rights to tell his story?! They have no true love 4 Pac so this movie will not be made with love! And that’s why my ass isn’t involved ! If Tupac knew what was going on he’d ride on all these fools and take it to the streets… But I won’t do that … I’ll just make my own project. What Yall think about that?!!”

It sounded like a legal battle was brewing – assuming one wasn’t already at its peak. Morgan Creek never did respond (at least not publicly) to Singleton’s accusations, that I’m aware of.

I did receive an email them from a tipster who shared Singleton’s Instagram post with me, as well as the name and photos of the actor that the director had already selected for the part. His name is Marcc Rose – a newcomer who would go on to appear in the N.W.A. bio, “Straight Outta Compton,” playing Tupac. So it seemed very likely that he would also play Tupac in the Tupac biopic to be directed by Carl Franklin. 

But not-so fast.

An August casting notice suggested otherwise – that an actor was being sought to play Tupac; meaning Marcc Rose isn’t/wasn’t locked in for this, as I think we figured he likely would be. But Carl Franklin was still listed as the director at the time, so nothing had changed there.

But not-so fast… again.

Announced today, courtesy of The Hollywood Reporter, Franklin has apparently left the project, likely in part due to the uncertainties surrounding it, as summarized above. Taking over for Franklin is Benny Boom, the music video director turned feature film director, with 2009’s “Next Day Air” his most prominent film to date (it was also his feature film directorial debut).

And so we’re back to square one… again… it seems. Will this film ever get made? And when it does happen, will there still be strong audience enthusiasm for it?

No word on whether any progress was made on the casting of the film, since the August casting announcement, when Franklin was still attached to direct. Although, according to THR, Morgan Creek, the company behind the film, has a good reason to act with urgency here, because music rights to Tupac’s catalog revert back to Afeni Shakur by the end of this year, if production hasn’t begun on the film. So I’d expect that we’d hear much more about the project over the next month.

John Singleton did boast that he would make his own independently-produced Tupac movie, so it could be that Marcc Rose will be his guy, and another fresh face will star in Benny Boom’s Morgan Creek/Emmet-Furla Films production.

This Article is related to: News and tagged