Back to IndieWire

‘Penny Dreadful’: Why This Great Series Finale Shouldn’t Start a Trend

"Penny Dreadful" surprised fans by turning its Season 3 finale into a series finale. Please, please, don't do that again.

Penny Dreadful 309 Finale Josh Hartnett & Eva Green

Showtime

Penny Dreadful” creator John Logan is an expert at endings. From big, sweeping dramas like “Gladiator” and “The Last Samurai,” to ongoing stories like “Skyfall” and the first two seasons of “Penny Dreadful,” Logan is a writer who always seems to hit his mark in the end.

That’s why it comes as no surprise that Sunday night’s Season 3 finale of “Penny Dreadful,” “The Blessed Dark,” was a terrific episode of television – with one glaring exception.

What more could one ask for in a series finale? Simple: that we knew going in it was a series finale.

READ MORE: No More Excuses: Eva Green & ‘Penny Dreadful’ Need Emmys, Now

Building up to the final standoff between strangers-turned-allies, allies-turned-lovers, lovers-turned-enemies — Ethan Chandler (Josh Hartnett), a werewolf living in exile because of his uncontrollable affliction, and Vanessa Ives, a medium with powers so great she’s been coveted by everyone from Satan to Dracula — Season 3 led us to a place where we could accept finality because, as Vanessa put it in her waning seconds, it had to be this way: “My battle must end, or there will never be peace on Earth.”

In fitting if torturous fashion, it was Ethan who had to do battle with the love of his life (shortly after an aptly epic battle where every lead character joined together to shoot up a batch of vampires; apt because of the following scene’s stillness and because Logan is oh so very good at creating these kind of violent spectacles without losing substance). “You know you have a destiny,” Vanessa said to Ethan. “It’s why we first met.”

His destiny became hers, and Vanessa, the series’ driving force, died by Ethan’s hand.

Logan’s clever character trajectory — tying his players to each other at the very end with a connection from the very beginning — lent pathos to Ethan’s plight, and Hartnett’s committed performance (peaking in an earlier scene where he confronted the person who turned him into a werewolf) sold these final moments in a meaningful, lasting way. One could argue Green deserved a bigger scene to end on, but the queen of premium television has proven herself time and time again.

Penny Dreadful 309 Finale Josh Hartnett & Eva Green
From a critic’s standpoint, almost anything out of the ordinary is welcome. Surprises are good because they stimulate conversation, and the conversation is what we covet when it comes to TV. So when fans saw the words “The End” appear after John Clare (the great Rory Kinnear) read one last ode to his departed friend, people certainly started talking. Was this the end? Is “Penny Dreadful” over?

Yes. It’s over. But no, it’s not welcome — not like this.

After nearly a year debating whether or not Jon Snow survived his “death” in the “Game of Thrones” Season 5 finale, there’s a soothing side to the finality of “Penny Dreadful.” We don’t have to wait. We don’t have to wonder. We know. It’s over.

But there’s also something painful about it. We not only lost a series — which is a significant loss in this instance, even in a world of “too much TV” — but we lost a series while we were still grappling with losing Vanessa.

If we knew this episode was the end ahead of time, we could have been better prepared for loss — any loss. By airing a secret series finale, fans now face a cold narrative reality where Vanessa died and a cold literal reality where “Penny Dreadful” won’t be returning. The only difference between what we saw and a cancellation is that Logan had time to write and shoot a fitting ending; a gracious gift in today’s day-and-age, but the hidden way it was delivered turned that gift into a gag.

Shorter series are fine; more than fine when they’re as detailed,  and downright gorgeous as “Penny Dreadful.” And, perhaps, I’m still in phase one of grief: anger. But hiding the end from fans — especially a fanbase as devoted as The Dreadfuls — just seems unnecessarily cold.

Anyone watching in the future should be quite pleased with how “Penny Dreadful” wrapped up. It’s a fitting end for a series both dark and hopeful. But anyone devoted enough to be watching anywhere close to real-time are likely waking up to a rough world. And isn’t that who “Penny Dreadful” is really for?

Watch John Logan’s farewell to fans and read his final statement below: 

“I created ‘Penny Dreadful’ to tell the story of a woman grappling with her faith, and with the demons inside her. For me the character of Vanessa Ives is the heart of this series,” Logan said. “From the beginning, I imagined her story would unfold over a three-season arc, ending with Vanessa finally – and triumphantly – finding peace as she returns to her faith. To have had fans that have embraced us so passionately has been one of the most gratifying experiences of my career. This has been a very personal project for me and I will be forever grateful to have worked with the incredible cast led by Eva, Josh and Tim, our amazing Irish crew, and with our wonderful partners at Showtime and Sky.”

Stay on top of the latest TV news! Sign up for our TV email newsletter here.

This Article is related to: Television and tagged , , , ,