Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Celebrating 17 Years of Film.Biz.Fans.
by Peter Knegt
July 16, 2012 1:12 PM
18 Comments
  • |

2012 Emmy Predictions: The Comedy Categories

"Modern Family"

The Emmy nominations are being announced this Thursday, July 19th and Indiewire is offering previews of what could go down in the three primary category subsections: comedy, drama and TV movie/miniseries (we already offered up a wishlist of "most wanted" nominees... read that here).

First up is comedy, where television had yet another very strong year. Veteran series -- and Emmy favorites -- like "30 Rock," "Parks & Recreation," "Modern Family" and "Curb Your Enthusiasm" all had reasonably strong seasons. "Louie" -- which managed a best actor nomination last year but not one in the tip category -- became arguably the most praised comedy series on the air, which could push into more extensive contention.

"Community," which has never been nominated in major races, is coming off a big win at the Broadcast Critics' new television-centered awards. Add that to more questionable Emmy regulars like "The Big Bang Theory," and to a wonderful crop of  newbies  ("Veep," "Girls," "New Girl," "Enlightened," "Life's Too Short" and "Up All Night") and it should make for a pretty interesting Emmy race when it comes to comedy categories (though this is true of all the categories, really).

But getting one's hopes up when it comes to the Emmy's is historically a losing game. The awards have tended to reward the same shows over and over, particularly in the comedy categories (where -- lest we forget -- "Frasier" won the top prize five years in a row while "Roseanne" was never even nominated). That said, the last few years have shown signs of intelligent life in Emmy voters (Louis C.K.'s nomination last year, for example).  So perhaps there will be a few happy surprises Thursday morning, even if they might all be disqualified when Jon Cryer gets a best actor nomination for "Two and Half Men" over a few dozen more worthy possibilities.

'Parks and Recreation' Tyler Golden/NBC

A few things are definitely certain, whether warranted or not: "Modern Family" has won the top prize in the comedy category two years running, and last year every single adult cast member got a nomination (and two of them won). Expect a similar domination this year, which only already takes up 25% of the potential acting nominees.

One category "Modern Family" is not eligible for is lead comedy actress (all its cast members submit in supporting), which is a good thing because the race is already remarkably crowded.  While the category's male counterpart is comparatively slim on contenders, the reality that television (comedic or dramatic, really) is the best medium for great roles for women is markedly clear if you scroll through the possibilites.

There's last year's six nominees -- Amy Poehler ("Parks and Recreation"), Laura Linney ("The Big C"), Edie Falco ("Nurse Jackie"), Tina Fey ("30 Rock"), Martha Plimpton ("Raising Hope") and the surprising winner, Melissa McCarthy ("Mike & Molly"). That group in itself is quite impressive (even if some of the shows the actresses are on are much more mediocre than their individual contributions).  But add them to the slew of actresses coming in from new series, and one starts to wish the Emmys would expand the nominee count.

There's the exceptional trio from HBO -- Julia Louis-Dreyfus ("Veep"), Lena Dunham ("Girls") and Laura Dern ("Enlightened") as well as a couple strong options from the networks in Christina Applegate ("Up All Night") and Zooey Deschanel ("New Girl"). How these 11 women are narrowed down to six nominees is perhaps Thursday's biggest nail-biter. Other than Amy Poehler, it seems reasonable to wager that everyone is vulnerable.

Shaky predictons in that category and the other major comedy races are on the next page. Check back for Indiewire's take on the drama categories tomorrow.

18 Comments

  • tomincmh | July 18, 2012 5:20 PMReply

    I'm so tired of 'Modern Family' dominating these awards. It's like they fall in love with one series in drama and comedy and just shower those shows with awards year after year even when they don't deserve it any longer. And BTW, I'm still not sure why Parks and Rec gets more critical love than Community. Is it the Amy Poehler/SNL thing or something else?

  • Michael G | July 18, 2012 9:07 AMReply

    I want Emma Rossum to be nominated!

  • F.P. | July 17, 2012 7:10 PMReply

    Ugh, Lena Dunham, the actress, is the worst part of 'Girls.' I know that this is indieWire and all that but, come on. She'll get nominated for her writing, and maybe even her directing (the Jody Lee Lipes episodes were actually the best ones though), but if she ends up the only nominated actress from the show, God help us all since we'll be seeing her act more. Bleh. 'Enlightened' seems like the HBO frontrunner anyway, for virtually all of the categories (Dern, Ladd, Wilson, plus the writing-directing-producing team). 'Veep' felt overly mannered, but Julia will likely sneak into a nom. Plus, given your arguments, 'Glee' ain't going anywhere. Whether it's as good as it was before or not, they stage some of the best things on TV and it's unafraid to inject realness into the show (sometimes to its earnest detriment). It shouldn't win, but Jane Lynch, and Chris Colfer, and the show runners made a good comedy series this year. That said, Max Greenfield is a future Emmy winner, this year or next, despite Burrell's genius as Phil.

  • Joe | July 15, 2012 11:03 PMReply

    Has anyone seen Modern Family this year? It was not as nearly good as the past two. If the emmy voters have common sense they wont give the award to a show that had a so-so season. My prediction would have Modern Family at #4 or #5 and Parks and Rec winning if life was fair.

  • Adam | July 7, 2012 4:17 AMReply

    I'd love to see some Community noms. Donald definitely. And strangely, I think Gillian had a really strong season this year as Britta.

  • JXC | July 3, 2012 7:09 PMReply

    Where is Sutton Foster for "Bunheads"???????????????

  • Michael Ornelas | June 16, 2012 4:02 PMReply

    House of Lies should be toward the top of the Strong Newbies list, if not Very Possible. That was easily a top comedy this year. Writing was ridiculously good.

  • dabbas | June 11, 2012 4:50 AMReply

    Where's Happy Endings? Much better than New Girl.

  • DJ | June 1, 2012 7:39 PMReply

    It has already been confirmed that Jon Cryer is submitting Lead this year.

  • Jody | April 1, 2012 11:13 PMReply

    Max Greenfield for "New Girl", most definitely.

  • bryan | March 24, 2012 3:34 PMReply

    It's so exciting how strong this category has gotten. Just think, three years ago Family Guy was a nominee.

    Random thought though, for Supporting Actress I would add Mayim Bialik, Wendie Malick, and Eden Sher as possibilities. All three have been phenominal this season. And don't forget about Cloris Leachmann

  • Psyche | March 15, 2012 5:54 AMReply

    I'd put Mayim Bialik on the list for Best Supporting Actress for The Big Bang Theory as well.

  • Josh | April 2, 2012 5:45 PM

    Agreed, she has be incredible this season

  • Alice | March 15, 2012 8:52 AM

    Me too. She's been fantastic this season.

  • alex | March 13, 2012 3:31 PMReply

    jajajajaja OMG is serious??
    The Fallen Favorites?
    14. Glee

    Im not a fann of glee but this season have a great chance get it emmy nominations, dont have a solid season not yet but a very good when compared to the seasom 2, and this year we have a great performances example chris colfer, lea michele and naya rivera

    And Jon Cryer going to lead, 9. Zooey Deschanel, New Girl??? she have more chance that laura linney

  • PaulH | March 13, 2012 12:28 PMReply

    Kristen Bell in comedy SUPPORTING Actress? She's the lead on H of L. No effin' way. Why should she be on the wrong end of Showtime-imposed category fraud so overrated Falco, Linney and Louise-Parker can get first dibs on lead comedy actress?

  • dudebides | March 13, 2012 11:06 AMReply

    one word. Community! donald glover, joel mchale, danny pudi noms! + alison brie would be nice :P

  • Bogdan | March 13, 2012 8:37 AMReply

    DAMN! Such tight competition, it's amazing! :D