Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Steve Carell Redefined His Career By Surprising Everyone in 'Foxcatcher' Steve Carell Redefined His Career By Surprising Everyone in 'Foxcatcher' Watch: Ellar Coltrane on the 'Brutal' Experience of Watching 'Boyhood' After Living It Watch: Ellar Coltrane on the 'Brutal' Experience of Watching 'Boyhood' After Living It Mortem Tyldum Explains Why Alan Turing Was the Right Subject For His First English-Language Film Mortem Tyldum Explains Why Alan Turing Was the Right Subject For His First English-Language Film Why Richard Linklater’s ‘Boyhood’ is a Great, Unexpected Awards Season Frontrunner Why Richard Linklater’s ‘Boyhood’ is a Great, Unexpected Awards Season Frontrunner Watch: Patricia Arquette on Stripping Away Ego to Get to the Heart of 'Boyhood' 
Watch: Patricia Arquette on Stripping Away Ego to Get to the Heart of 'Boyhood' 'Whiplash' Breakout Miles Teller Has Officially Arrived 'Whiplash' Breakout Miles Teller Has Officially Arrived Michael Keaton Dug Deep to Deliver the Best Performance of His Career in 'Birdman' Michael Keaton Dug Deep to Deliver the Best Performance of His Career in 'Birdman' Mark Ruffalo Explains Why Dave Schultz Was One of the Most Complex Characters He's Ever Played Mark Ruffalo Explains Why Dave Schultz Was One of the Most Complex Characters He's Ever Played Keira Knightley on 'The Imitation Game' and Why Awards Matter Keira Knightley on 'The Imitation Game' and Why Awards Matter Katherine Waterston On the Good and Bad of Working With Paul Thomas Anderson Katherine Waterston On the Good and Bad of Working With Paul Thomas Anderson Emma Stone Proved She Can Do It All in 2014 Emma Stone Proved She Can Do It All in 2014 Jon Stewart is Off to a Strong Start with Directorial Debut 'Rosewater' Jon Stewart is Off to a Strong Start with Directorial Debut 'Rosewater' Awards Spotlight: Don't Be Surprised When J.K. Simmons Takes Home Oscar Awards Spotlight: Don't Be Surprised When J.K. Simmons Takes Home Oscar Jessica Chastain Proved She's a Total Chameleon in 2014 Jessica Chastain Proved She's a Total Chameleon in 2014 Laura Poitras on 'CITIZENFOUR,' The Most Dangerous Work She's Ever Done Laura Poitras on 'CITIZENFOUR,' The Most Dangerous Work She's Ever Done Jake Gyllenhaal On Doing Very Bad Things in 'Nightcrawler' Jake Gyllenhaal On Doing Very Bad Things in 'Nightcrawler' Channing Tatum Explains Why It Took Him Eight Years to Have the ‘Balls’ for ‘Foxcatcher’ Channing Tatum Explains Why It Took Him Eight Years to Have the ‘Balls’ for ‘Foxcatcher’ Ethan Hawke Didn't Know That Richard Linklater Would Bring 'Boyhood' Home So Well Ethan Hawke Didn't Know That Richard Linklater Would Bring 'Boyhood' Home So Well Jack O'Connell Explains What It’s Like to Work For Angelina Jolie Jack O'Connell Explains What It’s Like to Work For Angelina Jolie 'Red Army' Director Gabe Polsky Reveals the Story of Soviet Hockey 'Red Army' Director Gabe Polsky Reveals the Story of Soviet Hockey How Felicity Jones is Getting Noticed This Awards Season How Felicity Jones is Getting Noticed This Awards Season Edward Norton Goes Full-Blown For Alejandro González Iñárritu in 'Birdman' Edward Norton Goes Full-Blown For Alejandro González Iñárritu in 'Birdman' How Eddie Redmayne Transformed His Body and Mind to Become Stephen Hawking How Eddie Redmayne Transformed His Body and Mind to Become Stephen Hawking Oscar Isaac Explains How 'A Most Violent Year' Fits With His Other Roles Oscar Isaac Explains How 'A Most Violent Year' Fits With His Other Roles Timothy Spall Almost Went Mad to Play 'Mr. Turner' For Mike Leigh Timothy Spall Almost Went Mad to Play 'Mr. Turner' For Mike Leigh 'Gone Girl' Composer Atticus Ross: How to Write a Score Without Seeing the Film 'Gone Girl' Composer Atticus Ross: How to Write a Score Without Seeing the Film How to Play James Brown, By Chadwick Boseman: Study the Man, Listen to Drake How to Play James Brown, By Chadwick Boseman: Study the Man, Listen to Drake Chris Rock on Why Making 'Top Five' Was a No-Brainer Chris Rock on Why Making 'Top Five' Was a No-Brainer Steve James and Chaz Ebert Tackled 'Life Itself' Steve James and Chaz Ebert Tackled 'Life Itself' Bennett Miller Explains Why He Had to Make 'Foxcatcher' Bennett Miller Explains Why He Had to Make 'Foxcatcher' How Do You Roll Six Movies Into One? 'Wild Tales' Director Damian Szifron Explains How Do You Roll Six Movies Into One? 'Wild Tales' Director Damian Szifron Explains How Rosario Dawson Stole the Show From Chris Rock in 'Top Five' How Rosario Dawson Stole the Show From Chris Rock in 'Top Five' Alan Hicks: From Drummer-Surfer to Oscar-Shortlist Filmmaker Alan Hicks: From Drummer-Surfer to Oscar-Shortlist Filmmaker Alejandro González Iñárritu: 'Birdman' Could Have Been 'so wrong' Alejandro González Iñárritu: 'Birdman' Could Have Been 'so wrong' Amir Bar-Lev Likes to Make People a Little Uncomfortable Amir Bar-Lev Likes to Make People a Little Uncomfortable

BERLIN REVIEW: 'Soldier/Citizen' Gets to the Core of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict With Startling Precision

Photo of Eric Kohn By Eric Kohn | Indiewire February 10, 2012 at 9:55PM

BERLIN REVIEW: 'Soldier/Citizen' Gets to the Core of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict With Startling Precision
1
The students featured in "Soldier/Citizen."
Berlin The students featured in "Soldier/Citizen."
Silvina Landesman's documentary "Soldier/Citizen" summarizes a decades-old debate in 68 minutes, capturing the heated dialogue of a three-week course in civic studies offered to young members of the Israeli military. When they're forced to question their existing allegiances by their worldly teacher, his unwilling disciples grow increasingly frustrated as they hit walls in their belief system. The course becomes their collective therapy session. 
 
Positioned as part of a curriculum for soldiers to obtain their high school diplomas, the class manifests a national mindset in visual terms as students wear their uniforms and keep weapons close at hand while sitting in the classroom and engaged fiery discussion. Their stubborn resistance to any form of sympathy toward the Palestinian experience means that the professor can push their buttons with ease. When he raises the notion of pluralism in the opening minutes, he faces immediate backlash: "Why don't you use Arabic for this fancy talk?" one student barks, defining the stonewalling of intellectualism that follows. 
 
Diving into the action and staying put, Landesman owes much to her editor as "Soldier/Citizen" breathlessly encapsulates hours of dialogue into a fluid and thoroughly engaging experience. The narrative only gets off track with fleeting tangents that elaborate on the overall educational program. The drama clearly lies in the classroom alone, a self-contained universe of contradictions and anger. 
 
Adding to its representational value, the filmmaker never identifies any of the participants by name (although a few slip by over the course of various conversations). Even the crafty middle-aged instructor, whose generational distance from his students enables him to strike a balance between comprehending their fury and pushing against it, takes on an abstract dimension: He's the voice of reason in a room of one-sided polemics, and skillfully keeps the back-and-forth in flux. Each time he guides a dogged student into the wall by uncovering the holes in their knowledge, the zig-zagging culminates in a near-comic punchline. Among other revelations, they learn that their government exempts Arab citizens from military service, that ultra-orthodox Jews ("the penguins," as one calls them) reject the existence of a secular Zionist state, and their own teacher has close Arabic friends. "I didn't know that," goes their typical refrain.
 
And yet for each "gotcha!" moment that points to intellectual progress, the students remain fixed their beliefs. They laugh off the possibility of negotiation (Can a suspected terrorist delay gunfire with a last-ditch call to the High Court?) and nimbly excuse their naivete because, as one of them puts it, "we're just kids." The teacher's bemused expression sometimes belies his commitment to a cause and hints at defeat, but the man relentlessly challenges assumptions whenever he can get that far. Usually, his audience shuts down any attempt at an empirical argument. "It's easy for the world to judge us because we need its approval," a soldier fumes, but they nevertheless display hints of introspection when faced down. 
 
Despite the way it tussles with polemics, "Soldier/Citizen" is essentially an apolitical plea for better methods of social discourse. Landesman renders the modern consciousness of Israeli youth culture in provocative physical terms. The camera simply watches, but the filmmaker curates a guide to the challenges of stimulating dialogue when one side is committed to an existing conclusion. Defending the actions of pro-Palestinian activists, the teacher claims, "they're defending the right to life." That one gets shot down without hesitation: "Do it when it's over." 
 
The teacher understands such circular argumentation too well, backing down with a meek "OK" whenever they wear their ideological blinders too tight. His respect for those boundaries makes the case for a "Soldier/Citizen" sequel 20 years down the road. The current movie ends with a test the soldiers must pass to conclude the course, but the questions it poses lack the same tidy resolution. 
 
Criticwire grade: A-
 
HOW WILL IT PLAY? Barely over an hour, "Soldier/Citizen" likely won't hit theaters anytime soon, but should play well on the documentary and Jewish festival circuits; it could also find a welcoming home on public television. 

This article is related to: Berlin International Film Festival, Reviews






Check out Indiewire on LockerDome on LockerDome

Most Read



Awards Season Spotlight

Contender Conversations

Indiewire celebrates the best and brightest from Independent film, Hollywood, and foreign cinema.

More