Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Critic's Notebook: Does 'The Avengers' Belong at the Tribeca Film Festival?

Photo of Eric Kohn By Eric Kohn | Indiewire April 27, 2012 at 10:05AM

"The Avengers" will play like gangbusters at the closing night of the Tribeca Film Festival this Saturday. This is less prediction than absolute certainty. But does it belong there?
"War Witch," winner of one of Tribeca's top prizes.
"War Witch," winner of one of Tribeca's top prizes.

Crucially, "The Avengers" arrives at the end of the festival but does not define it. With a program large enough to represent a vast range of international cinemas, the festival evades an issue facing the European festival circuit, where many large festivals must include a certain number of national films. At least on paper, Tribeca contains a very diverse program, even if the lineup has yet to garner significant respect within the industry. Yesterday's awards ceremony illustrated that it's largely not the new movies that dominate the festival. "War Witch," Kim Nguyen's intense, thoroughly engrossing African drama about a teen bride pursued by insurgents, premiered in February in Berlin, as did "Una Noche," the acclaimed Cuban drama that nabbed Tribeca's acting prizes.

But that's an issue pertaining to the quality of the lineup, not the special events, which usually generate more talk than any of the world premieres (nobody remembers that awful Cameron Crowe documentary about Elton John from last year's opening night, but many fondly recall John's lovely performance after the screening). "The Avengers" belongs at Tribeca because the festival's strongest suit is its ability to throw a big bash, which is not a pithy achievement and could actually help more movies. "The Avengers" doesn't need the help, but I'll gladly play devil's advocate on this one: If Tribeca can do this for "The Avengers," it can do it for anyone.

An experienced colleague from the festival world recently suggested to me that Tribeca may want to drop the "film festival" label altogether and embrace its existing strengths. Call a spade a spade -- or maybe call it a "celebration of film." No longer facing insurmountable expectations, Tribeca could effectively remove itself from a supremely competitive, premiere-oriented world in which every lineup is held hostage by the calendar. By those standards, "The Avengers" (which actually premiered last week in Los Angeles) doesn't only fit in at Tribeca; it epitomizes one part of the festival that works as well as the commercial feat behind the movie's existence.

This article is related to: Critic's Notebook, Tribeca Film Festival 2012, The Avengers, War Witch (Rebelle), Una Noche

IndieWire Newsletters

Win an Apple TV set before it's released! in News - Indiewire on LockerDome