Celebrating 17 Years of Film.Biz.Fans.
by Eric Kohn
December 10, 2012 12:58 PM
  • |

Critic's Picks: The Best Movies Released in 2012

"Holy Motors." Indomina
Another year, another list. While the industry is in the midst of pricey marketing campaigns for awards contenders -- dominated this time by studios with the wherewithal to position their smart fall season product as the definitive movies of the year -- critics get to play a different game. Despite several critics groups already bestowing major awards on movies released during this serendipitous window when Academy voters are paying attention, the list-making process provides a different opportunity to evaluate the past 12 months of cinema. While I have no statistics to prove it, one can assume that no two critics see the exact same movies each year, but most see a lot.

A cursory glance through the not-quite-accurate listing of 2012 releases on Wikipedia tells me I've seen around 120 new movies this year, not counting a handful of titles that actually received limited award-qualifying openings in late 2011. A more complex list might be derived from Indiewire's  A-Z film library and counting new movies that screened in 2012 at various festivals but have yet to arrive in theaters or VOD. Many of my preferences can be found on my Criticwire page, and not all of them will fit into the 10-movie limitation here. But the nice thing about lists is that despite their inherent limitations, you can make a lot of them. Expect to find a rundown of the best undistributed 2012 films in these parts later in the week, along with top performances, a list committed to documentary achievements and other breakdowns of the year in moving images.

The following group represent the top 10 movies that delivered entertained, shocked, innovated or amused me more than anything else. Several of them played at festivals last year and opened in theaters months ago, with the lasting impact they've left on me since then contributing to their placement here. Only one entry hasn't screened publicly yet, and its quality shocked me to such a degree that it warranted last-minute placement here and nearly toppled my top choice. The art of list-making also encourages a representational approach: No two entries hail from the same genre or aesthetic; instead, the finalist each struck me as paragons of those aspects.

In another year, the "Zero Dark Thirty" slot might go to "Miss Bala," another lively attempt to render dangerous underground operations in close-up, visceral terms. Without Lynn Shelton's wonderfully awkward romantic comedy "Your Sister's Sister," the witty crowdpleaser of the year might be the wild Danish sex romp "Klown," with "Silver Linings Playbook" landing the runner-up spot. No filmmaker has ever appeared more legitimately frustrated than Jafar Panahi in the breathtaking "This Is Not a Film," but the hopelessly neurotic, lonesome auteur at the center of Hong Sang-soo's delightfully odd "The Day He Arrives" faces plenty of engaging hurdles. And it surprises me still that the fourth "Universal Soldier" movie delivers such a spectacular action ride that, I still believe after several viewings, outdoes the latest James Bond entry. But if I had room for another absurd spectacle, the honor would go to Joss Whedon's "The Avengers," the best cinematic realization of comic books' pop culture appeal ever made. (Sorry, Batman.)

The possibilities of an entirely different list replacing this one points to the subjective nature of year-end analysis, the need to push away from consensus choices in order to broaden the overview of new movies, and why any given list only represents one access point to current cinema. Read the list and share your own in the comments if you feel you've seen enough to weigh in. If not, you know what to do: Watch the movies and decide for yourself.

The best movies released in 2012, at least according to this critic, can be found on the next page.

You might also like:


  • HAHA | January 5, 2013 1:36 PMReply

    Sundance Film Festival News 2013 PREDICTIONS! Sundance will get the pants sued off of them from stealing over millions of dollars from film submissions, Jill Miller and Keri Putnam will be working at Walmart, John Cooper will be a waiter for I-Hop, and all filmmakers will wake-up to the injustice that has been done for over 25 years. Oh one more thing>>>>. Filmmakers will learn how INDIEWIRE, Filmmaker Magazine, and others all "covered-up" the law-suit against Sundance, and buried this pertinent information from you independent filmmakers, because they are corrupt just like Sundance. http://www.sundancefilmfestival2013.com

  • Ann | December 29, 2012 6:16 PMReply

    I was just a little girl when the first Universal Soldier came out, and I loved it back then and still to this day! I just introduced one of the guys I work with at DISH to the original U.S. since he had no idea how cool Jean-Claude Van Damme used to be. Thanks so much for ranking Day of Reckoning in the top ten because if you hadn't, I never would've found out through DISH's Blockbuster @Home that there are a total of four more U.S. movies that I never knew about. I'm so glad that they carry so many titles, and that I'll be able to share them with my friend. Thanks again for making this!

  • Bart. | December 19, 2012 11:26 AMReply

    Great list

  • tuly | December 18, 2012 2:21 PMReply

    Agree with Yuri

  • yuri | December 11, 2012 11:40 AMReply

    Sensible list

  • vat? | December 10, 2012 11:17 PMReply

    Your Sister's Sister was kind of a piece of shit. I'm not a fan of Lynn Shelton, but I like Mark Duplass, and the Duplass brothers' films are getting progressively better - more conventionally comedic.

  • anonymous | December 10, 2012 9:38 PMReply

    None of what you talk about The Master is in there. Its a boring insultingly hollow film.

  • rob | December 10, 2012 7:46 PMReply

    great selection

  • Crisp | December 10, 2012 1:21 PMReply

    Wonderfully white. Sad.

  • Phil | December 11, 2012 1:23 PM

    I don't agree with Crisp but Portugal is a country inhabited by white people lol. Iran/Turkey kind of are as well...

  • Christopher Bell | December 11, 2012 1:50 AM

    Tabu? This Is Not A Film? Once Upon A Time In Anatolia?
    Portugal, Iran, Turkey.
    What are you talking about? Or did you just have this comment ready to go before you even read the list?