Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Critic's Picks: The Top 10 Best Female Lead Performances of 2013 According to Indiewire's Film Critic

Photo of Eric Kohn By Eric Kohn | Indiewire December 12, 2013 at 12:07PM

Awards season reduces a lot of people to smiling objects, but actresses experience this dilemma worse than most.
20

6. Tallie Medel, "The Unspeakable Act"

New York filmmaker Dan Sallitt, whose has been making under-appreciated character studies for years, uses a dialogue-heavy approach necessitates strong performances. They carry particular weight in "The Unspeakable Act," a remarkable showcase for newcomer Tallie Medel. The actress plays Jackie, the angst-riddled, virginal 17-year-old middle child of an upscale single parent Brooklyn family who harbors an unhealthy attraction to her older brother Matthew (Sky Hirschkron). Rather than exploit this risqué scenario, Sallitt takes it at face value, assuming his protagonist's perspective and using her fixation -- more than a taboo, it's just a bad idea -- to tell a uniquely compelling coming of age story.

Referring to her desire to indulge in "the 'I' word," she constantly voices her reservations over feeling attracted to anyone save for her brother -- not only to the man himself, but also her oddly withdrawn mother, a savvy therapist, and us, in a muted voiceover commentary that shows just how restricted her worldview has become. The wild-eyed Medel suggests a young Christina Ricci, but Jackie exists in a class of her own: Her affluent background allows for a character both wise beyond her years and hopelessly trapped in them. "I'm prematurely old," she whines -- but unlike, say, Juno, she's not snarky about it. There’s an intensity to Medel’s performance that makes it both creepy and totally authentic at once.

5. Cate Blanchett, "Blue Jasmine"

Woody Allen famously — or some might say infamously — avoids giving his actors much advice. In "Blue Jasmine,” that plays into his favor, as Blanchett single-handedly takes control of the movie and directs herself. The story features the actress as the spoiled housewife of a wealthy Madoff-like schemer (Alec Baldwin) who commits suicide in prison. "You hire her and get out of the way," Allen said in a widely circulated interview, although he's actually done the opposite: Constantly framing her in extreme close-ups, he places her skill under the microscope, and Blanchett ably meets the challenge. Tasked with a throwaway line involving the ordering of a Stoli martini with a hint of lime, she conveys shocking depths of sadness with the slightest twitch in her eye. Later, conveying a panic attack during the scene that recounts the end of her marriage, she delivers an intensely physical expression of her rage. Blanchett appears in almost every scene and frees it from the limitations of Allen's style, pushing it to far sharper results than any of the more traditional movies, good and bad, that he's churned out in the past dozen or so years. She owns it.

4. Berenice Bejo, "The Past"

Ahman (Ali Mosaffa) arrives in Paris from his native Iran four years after separating from wife Marie (Bérénice Bejo) in order to finalize their divorce. He finds the family at an uneven crossroads: While Marie plans to marry Samir (Tahar Rahim), Lucie (Pauline Burlet) -- her teen daughter from an earlier marriage -- maintains distance from her mother, frustrated by the older woman's string of fleeting romances. Initially it seems as though Ahman exists at the center of this drama, until all the puzzle pieces become clear, and we understand that he’s merely an observer of it. Bejo, however, buries memories of her giddy turn in “The Artist” with a fiery, assertive performance secretly at the root of the story. Inhabiting a role originally intended for Marion Cotillard, Bejo tows a fine line between credible fragility and melodramatic overstatement, particularly during the handful of shouting matches between the two older men in her life that kick the emotion into high gear. If her destructive tendencies seem at times overstated, she's also the evident victim of other agendas, including those of her angst-riddled daughter and husband-to-be. Like the window wipers superimposed over the title card, "The Past" involves a constant process of demystification for everyone involved. Bejo is the catalyst for making sure that process barrels forward.

3. Brie Larson, "Short Term 12"

This was a good year for Larson, who appeared in three well-received titles: “The Spectacular Now,” “Don Jon” and “Short Term 12.” But it’s only the latter title, a remarkably believable dose of sentimentalism from director Destin Daniel Cretton, where she really stands out as the key ingredient that holds the entire picture together.

To date best known for her role on the now-defunct "United States of Tara," Larson delivers a tremendously involving turn as Grace, the young supervisor of the eponymous foster care home drawn into the distinctive needs of various patients while maintaining a warm relationship with co-worker Mason (John Gallagher Jr., subdued but equally believable). Behind closed doors, they engage in charmingly believable romantic chatter, but when among the patients they display a different sort of passion subtly realized over the course of a patiently constructed narrative. More than anyone else, however, Grace emerges as the most complex focal point, as a women driven not only to help others but to help herself overcome the demons of her past that led her to take on this work in the first place. At one point, she champions a commitment to "talk about what's going on inside your head." But Larson’s textured performance makes it possible to consider her character’s thoughts even when she’s completely silent.

2. Paulina Garcia, "Gloria"

There was no bigger discovery at the 2013 Berlin International Film Festival than Paulina García, star of Chilean director Sebastián Lelio's competition entry "Gloria." If García isn't your average young newcomer, that's part of the point: Her electrifying performance in "Gloria," for which she won the festival's Best Actress prize, finds her playing a 58-year-old divorcee coping with the advent of a midlife crisis as she falls into a questionable romance with a man her own age. The role finds García in frequent closeup, displaying a physical intimacy rarely seen with actresses her age in contemporary movies.

Anchored by Garcia's nuanced performance, the movie explores the heroine’s fragile state of being with extraordinary astuteness. It's an open-ended question whether Gloria ever finds the happiness she seeks while dodging the current of middle-aged isolation, but her constant search is a valiant and deeply involving one.

1. Adele Exarchopoulos, "Blue is the Warmest Color"

The story of the sex in “Blue is the Warmest Color” often threatened to overwhelm the many accomplishments of this tender love story, chief among them the discovery of its young lead. Exarchopoulos delivers a bold, thoroughly credible breakthrough performance at the movie's center, portraying her character as a woman trapped by the mixed messages around her. Sex is less the main ingredient in "Blue is the Warmest Color" than the overall ways that physicality impacts romantic attraction. While Lea Seydoux complements Exarchopoulos’ journey with a spunky alternative to the younger woman’s hesitations, it’s ultimately Adele’s show. Striking a tone between shyness and blind curiosity, she’s the main reason why anyone assailing “Blue” for turning its characters into targets of the director’s lust weren’t paying attention for most of the movie. This isn’t a coming out or a coming of age story in any traditional sense — it’s just Adele’s story, and we experience it with her because Exarchopoulos makes the role so genuine.


This article is related to: Reviews, Best Performances 2013, Critic's Picks, Anna Margaret Hollyman, Sharni Vinson, Mary Margaret O'Hara, Rooney Mara, Tallie Medel, Cate Blanchett, Bérénice Bejo, Brie Larson, Paulina García, Adèle Exarchopoulos, Blue is the Warmest Color, Gloria, Short Term 12, Blue Jasmine, The Past, The Unspeakable Act, Ain't Them Bodies Saints, Museum Hours, You're Next, White Reindeer