Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Celebrating 17 Years of Film.Biz.Fans.
by Peter Knegt
November 12, 2009 2:16 AM
25 Comments
  • |

For Your Consideration: The 50 Most Despicable Oscar Snubs of the 2000s

Scenes from "Kill Bill," Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" and "4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days."

Before any of you get all optimistic about this year's awards race, I decided to utilize this week's column to remind you of how horribly wrong things can turn out. As the end of this decade approaches, and you start considering your favorite films and performances, you may or may not be surprised (though I'm guessing "may not") to find that many of them - if not the majority - failed to receive any recognition from ye ol' Academy. From "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" to Uma Thurman's work in the "Kill Bill,"'s to a seemingly endless batch of foreign language favorites, it's a frustratingly long list. Attempting to narrow it down to 50 was no small feat, and I'd expect there's going to be some disagreement. But let me first explain where I was coming from.

Essentially, I focused on only nine of the most often discussed categories: best picture, best director, best actor, best actress, best supporting actor, best supporting actress, best original screenplay, best adapted screenplay, and best foreign language film. I realize that the remaining categories offer a plethora of angering exclusions - from "Far From Heaven"'s costume design to "Requiem For A Dream"'s original score to the truly obscene absence of original song, "America, Fuck Yeah" from "Team America, World Police," not to mention the list-in-itself that is the best documentary feature category ("Grizzly Man," "The Gleaners and I," "The King of Kong," etc, etc, etc) - but one can only take on so much.

I also figured there should at least be some theoretical chance that the "snub" could have been nominated. One might argue that including the likes of John Cameron Mitchell's work in "Hedwig and the Angry Inch" or Christian Bale's in "American Psycho" goes against this idea, but I beg to differ. Mitchell - if you can believe it - got a Golden Globe nomination for "Hedwig" (it seems Ricky Gervais ain't the only thing the HFPA has on the Oscars). I mean more along the lines of suggesting Michael Haneke's "The Piano Teacher" as a snub for a best picture nomination or Tony Leung and Maggie Cheung as snubs in the acting categories for "In The Mood For Love." Ridiculously deserving as they were, those weren't snubs. They were complete impossibilities. I can however, bitch about how both those films were shut out of the foreign language film category. And speaking of which, another "rule" - I didn't include foreign films that weren't submitted by their countries, as that wasn't totally the Academy's fault (though their pesky rules are somewhat to blame).

I'm sure I missed loads, and I encourage thoughtful use of the comments section to offer your own choices, and to make predictions about some potential 2009 non-nominees that might warrant a slot on an updated list some day in the future... Paul Schneider in "Bright Star," anyone? Or how about Michael Stuhlbarg in "A Serious Man"?

So for what it's worth, here are my picks for the 50 most despicable Oscar snubs of the 2000s (though it's actually more like 70 given some of the "grouped" snubs), in descending order for your anticipatory pleasure. It's meant mostly as a fun exercise for both myself and (hopefully) you, and as a little reminder as we begin to enter the depths of Oscar season: Only a small percentage of the truly great performances, scripts and films actually end up participating in it.

A scene from Vincent Paronnaud and Marjane Satrapi's "Persepolis."

50: Tina Fey for best adapted screenplay (Mean Girls, 2004)

49: Persepolis for best foreign language film (Vincent Paronnaud and Marjane Satrapi, 2007)

48: Hugh Grant and Toni Collette for best actor and supporting actress (About a Boy, 2002)

47: Emily Blunt for best supporting actress (The Devil Wears Prada, 2006)

46: Naomi Watts for best actress (Mulholland Drive and King Kong, 2001 & 2005)

45: Hope Davis for best supporting actress (American Splendor, 2003)

44: Gomorrah for best foreign language film (Matteo Garrone, 2008)

43: Andy Serkis for best supporting actor (The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, 2002)

42: Adaptation for best picture (Spike Jonze, 2002)

41: Christian Bale for best actor (American Psycho, 2000)

40: Evan Rachel Wood for best actress (Thirteen, 2003)

39: Woody Allen for best original screenplay (Vicky Cristina Barcelona, 2008)

38: Rosemarie deWitt for best supporting actress (Rachel Getting Married, 2008)

37: Cache and The Piano Teacher for best foreign language film (Michael Haneke, 2001 & 2005)

36: Peter Sarsgaard for best supporting actor (Shattered Glass, 2003)

35: Michelle Williams for best actress (Wendy & Lucy, 2008)

Shareeka Epps in a scene from Ryan Fleck's "Half Nelson."

34: Shareeka Epps for best supporting actress (Half Nelson, 2006)

33: Kristin Scott Thomas for best actress (I've Loved You So Long, 2008)

32: L'Enfant and Le Fils for best foreign language film (Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne, 2002 & 2005)

31: Marlon Wayans and Jennifer Connelly for best supporting actor and actress (Requiem For a Dream, 2000)

30: Mulholland Drive for best picture (David Lynch, 2001)

29: Gillian Anderson for best actress (The House of Mirth, 2000)

28: David O. Russell for best original screenplay (I Heart Huckabees, 2004)

27: United 93 for best picture (Paul Greengrass, 2006)

26: Volver for best foreign language film (Pedro Almodovar, 2006)

-This article continues on the next page-

John Cameron Mitchell in a scene from "Hedwig and the Angry Inch."


25: Steve Buscemi and Scarlett Johansson for best supporting actor and actress (Ghost World, 2000)

24: Alexander Payne for best adapted screenplay (About Schmidt, 2002)

23: John Cameron Mitchell for best actor and director (Hedwig and the Angry Inch, 2001)

22: City of God for best foreign language film (Fernando Meirelles, 2002)

21: David Fincher and Robert Downey Jr for best director and supporting actor (Zodiac, 2006)

20: Sacha Baron Cohen for best actor (Borat, 2006)

19: Ewan McGregor and Baz Luhrmann for best actor and director (Moulin Rouge!, 2001)

18: Julie Delpy for best actress (Before Sunset, 2004)

17: Alfonso Cuarón for best director (Y Tu Mama Tambien and Children of Men, 2002 & 2006)

16: The Dark Knight for best picture (Christopher Nolan, 2008)

15: Jim Carrey for best actor (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, 2004)

Catherine O'Hara in a scene from Christopher Guest's"A Mighty Mind."


14: Catherine O'Hara for best supporting actress (Best In Show, A Mighty Wind, and For Your Consideration, 2000-2006)

13: Patricia Clarkson, Dennis Quaid and Dennis Haysbert for supporting actor and actress (Far From Heaven, 2002)

12: Almost Famous for best picture (Cameron Crowe, 2000)

11: Charlie Kaufman for best original screenplay (Synecdoche, New York, 2008)

10: David Cronenberg, Viggo Mortensen and Maria Bello for best director, actor and supporting actress (A History of Violence, 2005)

9: 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days for best foreign language film (Cristian Mungiu, 2007)

8: Sally Hawkins and Eddie Marsan for best actress and supporting actor (Happy-Go-Lucky, 2009)

7: Bjork for best actress (Dancer in the Dark, 2000)

6: Paul Giamatti for best actor (American Splendor, 2003, and Sideways, 2004)

Sally Hawkins and Eddie Marsan in a scene from Mike Leigh's "Happy-Go-Lucky."


5: In The Mood For Love for best foreign language film (Wong Kar-Wai, 2001)

4: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind for best picture (Michel Gondry, 2004)

3: Uma Thurman for best actress (Kill Bill, Vol. 1 & 2, 2003 & 2004)

2: Todd Haynes for best director (Far From Heaven and I'm Not There, 2002 & 2007)

1: Finding Nemo, The Incredibles, Ratatouille and WALL-E for best picture (Andrew Stanton or Brad Bird, 2003-2008)

"For Your Consideration" is a weekly column by indieWIRE Associate Editor Peter Knegt. Check out his previous editions:

For Your Consideration: Assessing The Major Oscar Categories
For Your Consideration: Oscar's Gay Tendencies
For Your Consideration: 11 Underdog Performances
For Your Consideration: History Repeats as Major Foreign Films Left Off Academy List
For Your Consideration: 10 Things The Fall Fests Told Us About Awards Season

25 Comments

  • ERM | January 8, 2014 7:18 AMReply

    Why are there like seven comments here claiming Ellen Burstyn should be on this list for her performance in Requiem for a Dream?
    She's not on the list because she was nominated for her performance. She wasn't snubbed.
    so yeah

  • gregg | December 24, 2013 8:32 PMReply

    A few that should have made the list: Daniel Day Lewis, Gangs of New York (best actor), Ellen Burstyn, Requiem for a Dream (best actress), Michael Fassbender, Shame (Best actor), Melancholia (best picture), Blue Valentine (best picture), Michelle Williams & Ryan Gosling (actress and supporting actor), Marion Cottillard, Rust and Bone (best actress), Don Cheadle, Hotel Rwanda (best actor), to name a small few

  • ReverendBenzo | October 3, 2012 10:44 PMReply

    Paul Giamatti for Sideways is easily one of the worst Best Actor snubs of all time.

  • Will | May 11, 2012 4:32 PMReply

    Great list, but don't forget
    Best Actor- Richard Gere for Chicago(2002)
    Best Director- Peter Jackson for LOTR-TTT(2002)
    Best Supporting Actor- Aaron Eckhart for The Dark Knight(2008)

  • TF | October 18, 2011 4:54 AMReply

    Uma Thurman DESERVED that Oscar...goes to show you how they never take action movies/actors seriously no matter how brilliant they are. She worked het butt off for those scenes, but no one cares.. But wait, the second a pretty actress makes her self look unattractive for a role, Oscar comes running...lol

  • Lily | June 16, 2011 8:38 AMReply

    James McAvoy - Atonement or Last King of Scotland

    Both Keira Knightley and James McAvoy were totally snubbed by the Oscars for their performances in Atonement, I think, but McAvoy more so. His performance as Robbie Turner was spectacular in and of itself, and it was his portrayal of Robbie's emotional journey that was really the heart of the film (and keep in mind - the film itself got multiple nominations.)

    The Last King of Scotland was also a hugely successful movie, and one of its leads, Forest Whitaker, took home the award for best actor. While Whitaker definitely deserved the award, I do think that as a result, they overlooked McAvoy's performance, which was no less compelling or masterful.

  • Michelle | April 13, 2011 7:02 AMReply

    Ray Liotta - Goodfellas.

  • Brooke M | December 2, 2010 2:53 AMReply

    Bjork - Dancer in the Dark, and Naomi Watts - Mullholland Drive are two of my top five performances,but i would have to agree with Sally Hawkins almost as much.

    I second JGL- Mysterious Skin, and I would have to add Marion Cotillard - Nine, Miranda Richardson/Ralph Fiennes - Spider, Christina Ricci - Monster, Gary Oldman - Sid and Nancy and Jennifer Jason Leigh - Georgia as the main ones which really piss me off to this day. The fact that Oldman and Leigh have never been nominated is worse as they have both given many oscar worthy performances.

  • TimothyVincent | November 22, 2009 3:24 AMReply

    Joseph Gordon-Levitt for Mysterious Skin (2004)

  • fatwally | November 15, 2009 9:42 AMReply

    i stand corrected thanks

  • Peter Knegt | November 15, 2009 6:38 AMReply

    Fatwally: Not true. Brazil submitted it in 2002 and it was not nominated. The following year the Academy made up for it when it was deemed eligible for other categories, nominating it for 4 major awards:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Brazilian_submissions_for_the_Academy_Award_for_Best_Foreign_Language_Film

  • fatwally | November 15, 2009 6:33 AMReply

    City of god declined to be in best foreign language film category

  • Hazeliiis | November 15, 2009 6:14 AMReply

    I get ticked off everytime I think of Christian Balegetting snubbed for "American Psycho." It was such a BRILLIANT performance. He gave it his all and itsecured him as one of the best actors of my time. In retrospect, he should've also been nominated for "Empire of the Sun," which was such a brilliant and serious performance for a boy of his age. AND..."Rescue Dawn" was brilliant. I mean, Owen Wilson got nominated for his little war movie that didn't remotely compare to "Rescue Dawn." What are these people thinking???? I think it is damn time for Bale to get rewarded for his dedication to his craft. My hopes are in "The Fighter" for next year. It all depends on how the movie's pieced together, but I guarantee you...you will see Dickie Ecklund, and not Christian Bale. I will buy the most expensive bottle of champagne I can afford and toast his success because I have enjoyed his work over the years tremendously and I just want to see it REWARDED. Hell..even a nomination, for God's sakes. Is that too much to ask for? He was brilliant in "3:10 to Yuma." I mean, he went from hot-to-trot Bruce Wayne, to a dirt-poor rancher, loser, begger, and dirt-covered, desperate man (believably). What's he got to do to get an Oscar???? It's INSANE!!!!!

  • rberney | November 15, 2009 5:41 AMReply

    "Pan's Labyrinth" for Best Foreign Film. Guillermo should have won and it would have been the best (but possibly totally bleeped) thank you speech.

  • worrywort | November 15, 2009 2:30 AMReply

    the Eddie Marsan inclusion is right on.. I'll add Zeta-Jones for Traffic.

  • rurban | November 14, 2009 11:59 AMReply

    There are of course many best foreign language films missing, but basically a full ack.
    Burstyn for Requiem? Please read the book first, and then come back. She totally overplayed it.

  • PubbyPab | November 14, 2009 12:48 AMReply

    Wow. Way to pointedly snub Thora Birch by choosing her co-stars.

  • hoeyjeinen | November 13, 2009 9:25 AMReply

    oop! I f'ed!! Guess I got to overzealous. But let's hear it again! Ellen Burstyn!

  • Peter Knegt | November 13, 2009 9:23 AMReply

    hoeyjeinen: the list is specifically nomination snubs, which Burstyn is not... otherwise I totally agree she was very deserving over Ms. Roberts.

  • Maryland Clay | November 13, 2009 9:20 AMReply

    Saw "Half Nelson" on a SAG DVD sent to my actress wife and loved it. Also loved that it had redemption and a low-key happy ending.

  • hoeyjeinen | November 13, 2009 8:32 AMReply

    This may be my own vendetta, but I was surprised to not see Ellen Burstyn for 'Requiem' at the tippy-top of this list. I seem to run into all kinds of people who are also preoccupied with figuring out that one! Maybe it's also because Julia Roberts may as well have been ribbon-dancing during that awful acceptance speech.

  • tamaraluciano | November 13, 2009 4:20 AMReply

    Hm, I'm with you on Lynch and Rosemarie DeWitt, but Woody Allen's Vicky Christina Barcelona for Best Original Screenplay? Not so much. The narrator and Scarlett Johanson ruined it for me. Penelope deserved that Oscar, though.

  • pr_gmr | November 12, 2009 10:46 AMReply

    Totally agree with the vast majority of these. And 'Kill Bill' rocks.

  • Maryland Clay | November 12, 2009 9:44 AMReply

    Kill Bill was a mindless movie. Does this make any difference?

  • HollywoodBabylon | November 12, 2009 4:07 AMReply

    NO