By Michael Koresky | Indiewire September 12, 2009 at 11:44AM
Following in the grand tradition of austere European filmmakers, Bruno Dumont gives religious faith quite a workout in his new film, "Hadewijch." Not that this should come as a surprise to anyone who's followed Dumont's career. One of French cinema’s most illustrious provocateurs, Dumont has moved rather swiftly from contentious Cannes-winning enfant terrible (when his “Humanité” won three awards in 1999, including for his non-actor actors) to loathed international auteur (“Twentynine Palms"), while always finding transcendence in the oddest, most desolate, and often bloody, of places.
Narratively, "Hadewijch" finds Dumont on unexpectedly direct and accessible ground, even if at film's end there remains a baffling opaqueness, both in terms of the director's and the characters' motivations. Thought-provoking, troubling, and inevitably frightening, it provides the most overt psychological portraiture yet seen in a Dumont work. Whereas normally the filmmaker's Bressonian instincts and predilection for grandiose statement making (about capital-letter topics as large and impossible to pin down as War, the West, and Race) disallow his characters of being much more than archetypes, or, to be less charitable, cutouts, the main character of this film, Celine, played magnificently by Julie Sokolowski, feels like perhaps his first fully rounded, intensely personalized creature. That said, she's also unknowable, and perhaps capable of the unthinkable, a tension that makes this, in some ways, Dumont's most discomfiting film.
Though utterly devoted to Christ, Celine is kicked out of a convent, where she has sought refuge from a world and self she might not understand, for not adjusting properly to their rules of conduct. Cast from the convent's garden (initially bare in the dead of winter, though we will see it once again, crucially, in the spring), Celine finds herself searching for connection, although only if it will get her closer to God. Certainly she doesn't find solace in the grotesquely ornate confines of her self-identified technocrat (French minister) father's Parisian apartment (or kingdom, more appropriately); and neither does she wish to express her love for her new friend (and wannabe lover) Yassine (Yassine Salihine), whose Islamic beliefs provide contrast to hers but who cannot comprehend her undying commitment, at the expense of all others, to a being she cannot see or touch.
In focusing on Celine's growing relationship with Yassine, and then, more crucially, to his far more religious, backroom theologian brother, Nassir (Karl Sarafidis), Dumont paves the way for some sort of discourse on contemporary religious zealotry, illustrating the fervent believer's need for catharsis. Whether or not Dumont himself believes that such catharsis is possible fuels the final movement's ambiguities. As in all of the director's previous films, acts of terrible finality ironically refuse to provide any sort of resolution, and Dumont remains silent in the back row.
Of course, as always, our responses to his images as viewers are more important than those of the characters onscreen, even despite Sokolowski's surprisingly warm presence and acute depiction of desperation. However, this putting on of a "human face" ironically distances us further from Dumont's film; for Celine's actions both confound and explain our own desire for narrative catharsis. And Dumont's final grace note is both too little too late (for her and for us), and somehow a bit too much.