"Rebel Without a Cause"
What, you don't think this movie is gay? Think again. Or, better yet, watch it again and put a little more of your focus on Plato, played beautifully by the haunting Sal Mineo. Watch the way Plato looks at James Dean. I've always felt his feelings went beyond idolatry, but I can't decide whether the film paints them in visible, broad strokes or not. Perhaps it's because any viewer probably feels the same way gazing up at James Dean the screen. [Austin Dale]
“The Rocky Horror Picture Show”
Initially a box office bomb upon its release in 1975, Richard O’Brien’s gender-bending rock musical became a cult phenomenon thanks to audience participation heavy midnight screenings and an outcast friendly message of “Don’t dream it. Be it.” The film finds a young couple getting lost in a rainstorm and taking shelter in a giant castle housed by mad scientist Dr. Frank N. Furter (Tim Curry) and his bizarre servants. “Rocky Horror” takes the underlying homoeroticism of films like “Frankenstein” and brings it to the forefront as Frank tries to create his own man/sex object. Legions of fans still show up at screenings dressed as Curry’s “sweet transvestite” Frank N. Furter and Susan Sarandon and Barry Bostwick’s naïve couple Brad (“Asshole!”) and Janet (“Slut!”) to sing along, shout out their own lines, spray water pistols and throw toast. If you haven’t lost your “RHPS” virginity yet, there’s no time like the present. [Devin Lee Fuller]
“A Single Man”
Colin Firth’s titular single man, George, is a college professor whose longtime partner recently died in a car accident. Facing life alone is unbearable for George, so over the course of one day he plans his suicide. Tom Ford’s directorial debut is as impeccably art directed as one would expect from the fashion designer; he alternates from using a faded color palette to a bright one whenever George sees something (or someone) attractive in front of him. And while some may find the stylistic touches to be a little much, there’s nothing excessive about Firth’s pitch-perfect performance. While Firth won an Oscar the following year in “The King’s Speech,” his performance here is less showy and far more affecting. [Devin Lee Fuller]
21 Comments
Carlos | June 8, 2012 2:43 PM
Surprised that Pricilla Queen of the Desert
or
To: Wong Fu: Thanks
carlos | June 8, 2012 2:41 PM
I am surprised that Jeffery (or is that Geoffry?) with Patrick Stewart wasn't on the list
Kenny | June 7, 2012 3:49 PM
Surprised "Latter Days" wasn't on there.
doris | June 6, 2012 12:58 PM
it's sad that there are so few lesbian films and most of them are horrible
Adam | June 6, 2012 9:58 AM
PHILADELPHIA and I LOVE YOU PHILLIP MORRIS are two films that I'm surprised didn't jump right away into the minds of the staff.
In regard to the lack of lesbian films. It's both sad and unfortunate that there are not more Women and Lesbian films and filmmakers on this list and in the world of filmmaking in general. But to be honest the films mentioned by some people below either suck or at best mediocre, and that is why they didn't come to the minds of the Indiewire staff. Furthermore, I misogyny is a terrible word to be throwing around so lightly, and it borders on slander.
The great art historian, Linda Nochlin profoundly summed it up best in her famous essay, 'Why are There No Great Women Artists?' It was written about women in painting and sculpture, but I think it applies well to film as there have only been a few great female directors.
"What is important is that women face up to the reality of their history and of their present situation, without staking excuses or puffing mediocrity. Disadvantage may indeed be an excuse; it is not, however, an intellectual position. Rather, using as a vantage point their situation as underdogs in the realm of grandeur, and outsiders in that of ideology, women can reveal institutional and intellectual weaknesses in general, and, at the same time that they destroy false consciousness, take part in the creation of institutions in which clear thoughtâand true greatnessâare challenges open to anyone, man or woman, courageous enough to take the necessary risk, the leap into the unknown."
Sridhar Rangayan | June 6, 2012 8:52 AM
I too noticed the rather low quotient of lesbian themed films, but there are also very few transgender themed films - what about Transamerica, one of the cult trans themed films?
bob hawk | June 6, 2012 5:32 AM
Wonderfully eclectic and idiosyncratic list -- and the previous 13 commentators have amply fleshed things out. A few more to add to the pot (some iconic, some purely personal, not all of them p.c.): BIG EDEN, BOYS IN THE BAND; CAMP; CELLULOID CLOSET; COLMA: THE MUSICAL; THE CONSEQUENCE; EBAN AND CHARLEY; EDGE OF SEVENTEEN; EDWARD II; THE FOURTH MAN; FOX AND HIS FRIENDS; GODS AND MONSTERS; L'HOMME BLESSE; I AM LOVE; I KILLED MY MOTHER; LAW OF DESIRE; LILIES; MAKING LOVE; MAURICE; MY OWN PRIVATE IDAHO; MYSTERIOUS SKIN; THE OWLS; PERSONAL BEST; PRICK UP YOUR EARS; PRISCILLA, QUEEN OF THE DESERT; SAVAGE GRACE; SEBASTIANE; SHOW ME LOVE [aka FUCKING AMAL]; STONEWALL [!]; SUNDAY, BLOODY SUNDAY; SWOON; TAXI ZUM KLO; UNDERTOW [aka CONTRACORRIENTE] -- and my favorite porno of all time (it has a plot, and an arc!): Tom DeSimone's THE IDOL (1979).
Andrew | June 6, 2012 1:22 AM
I know the second half of the film is a litte "out there" but why no Tropical Malady?
JV | June 6, 2012 12:42 AM
Where is Happy Together? One of most erotic, complicated, elusive, and powerful films in "Gay" Cinema starring the late gay icon Leslie Cheung and Tony Leung.
CF | June 5, 2012 11:14 PM
Silver Life: The View from Here (1993) is a definite must watch, on the surface the film deals with the pains that AIDS inflicts on both the individual and the family, but also it shows a most beautiful love story.
POWER UP FILMS | June 5, 2012 8:21 PM
Dear Indiewire, I do love you, but where are the films Celebrating Lesbians? AND it is 2012 why are any Non-LGBTQ films included? WOW, Misogyny hurts!
Reading this list may leave Lesbians feel not only forgotten and trumped by non-Queer films, but punched in the stomach and transported back 20 years to where we should be simply grateful for the chance to be an innuendo; or killed; or mocked; or abused; or loathed on-screen. Not exactly my idea of Celebrating Lesbian Pride!
As a professional Film Producer of Queer Indie Films and the President of Film Production & Distribution for POWER UP Films - the only 501(c)(3) non-profit Educational Organization and Film Production Company for Women & the LGBTQ Community - I am truly shocked & disappointed that only (approx) 3.333 films out of the 43 films selected by the creators of this bizarre list are Lesbian.
While the LGBTQ Community (for political ease) is categorized together, in reality, the representation and interests of those very distinct categories do not necessarily overlap. As such, I would like to list a few wonderful Lesbian films (mysteriously not included) that feel more like Celebrating Lesbians: Desert Hearts; Imagine Me and You; Entre Nous; High Art; Go Fish; The Incredibly True Adventures of Two Girls in Love; Chutney Popcorn; Gia; and, to toot POWER UP Films own horn ITTY BITTY TITTY COMMITTEE and DEBS.
Enjoy, and May The Pride be with you!
Lisa Thrasher
For more information about POWER UP Films: @thrashPOWrUPfLm www.powerupfilms.org
Lisa Thrasher | June 5, 2012 7:18 PM
Dear Indiewire,
I do love you, but ⦠where are the films âCelebratingâ Lesbians? AND itâs 2012 ⦠why are any Non-LGBTQ films included? WOW, Misogyny hurts!
Reading this list may leave Lesbians feel not only forgotten and trumped by non-Queer films, but punched in the stomach and transported back 20 years to where we should be simply grateful for the chance to be an innuendo; or killed; or mocked; or abused; or loathed on-screen. Not exactly my idea of âCelebrating Lesbian Pride!â
As a professional Film Producer of Queer Indie Films and the President of Film Production & Distribution for POWER UP Films - the only 501(c)(3) non-profit Educational Organization and Film Production Company for Women & the LGBTQ Community - I am truly shocked & disappointed that only (app) 3.333 films out of the 43 films selected by the creators of this bizarre list are âLesbian.â
While the LGBTQ Community (for political ease) is categorized together, in reality, the representation and interests of those very distinct categories do not necessarily overlap. As such, I would like to list a few wonderful âLesbianâ films (mysteriously not included) that feel more like âCelebratingâ Lesbians: Desert Hearts; Imagine Me and You; Entre Nous; High Art; Go Fish; The Incredibly True Adventures of Two Girls in Love; Chutney Popcorn; Gia; and, to toot POWER UP Filmsâ own horn ⦠ITTY BITTY TITTY COMMITTEE and DEBS.
Enjoy, and âMay âThe Prideâ be with You!â
For more information about POWER UP Films: @thrashPOWrUPfLm www.powerupfilms.org
Drew | June 5, 2012 6:00 PM
How can you forget 'The Killing of Sister George?" A landmark lesbian movie.
Not only the first X-rated movie in the mainstream, but one of the first (if not the first) films to depict lesbian couples and lifestyles.
"The Killing of Sister George" paved the way for movies like "The Kids are All Right."
Great list though... :P
HWD911 | June 5, 2012 5:07 PM
what no 'SPORK' !?
Deborah A | June 5, 2012 3:59 PM
Did I miss The Incredibly True Adventure of Two Girls in Love, Desert Hearts, Puccini for Beginners
on your list?
Jim Tushinski | June 5, 2012 3:26 PM
Kind of a strange list. There are so many wonderful films that most people don't even know about. Why pad the list with stuff like Madonna or Eddie Murphy or even Rebel Without a Cause? What about Parting Glances (the most perfect Pride month film imaginable)? What about I've Heard the Mermaids Singing? My Beautiful Laundrette? Urbania? Poison? (oh ok...three Todd Haynes films on one list might be a bit much) Bound? Born in Flames? And come on...Flaming Creatures? Yes it's influential, but so are Pink Narcissus, Bijou, Scorpio Rising...all more watchable than Flaming Creatures and all just as groundbreaking. I'd say 50% of the list is good and 50% is questionable choices. But that's always the case with film lists. I'm sure my list would be seen as odd or perverse by many.
Dennis Doros | June 5, 2012 3:17 PM
PORTRAIT OF JASON (1967), THE QUEEN (1968), WORD IS OUT (1977), BEFORE STONEWALL (1984), PARTING GLANCES (1986) and COMMON THREADS (1989) are equally important (and just as remarkable) films. You can also throw in Derek Jarman's CARRAVAGIO and Rosa von Praunheim's work including I AM MY OWN WOMAN. Supporting the Outfest Legacy Project (http://www.outfest.org/legacysite/) would be a great way to celebrate.
YAH | June 5, 2012 2:27 PM
Have a sense of humor, Nah!
nah | June 5, 2012 2:25 PM
got through the 3rd page w/rando unnecessary suggestion of eddie murphy as being gay at which point i decided another 10 clickthroughs aren't necessary