Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Celebrating 17 Years of Film.Biz.Fans.
by Eric Kohn
December 19, 2011 11:57 AM
17 Comments
  • |

'The Tree of Life' Tops Indiewire's Poll For the Best of 2011 Film; Fassbender Ties With Shannon For Performance

"The Tree of Life." FSL

With 63 votes among 162 critics, journalists and other tastemakers, Terrence Malick’s Palme d’Or-winning “The Tree of Life” led the charge in Indiewire's Poll For the Best of 2011 Film. Malick also nabbed 18 mentions for Best Director, placing him in first place for that category as well.

Since it premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in May, “The Tree of Life” has remained a divisive movie that made mainstream audiences to throw up their hands, but it has maintained serious leverage among international critics in recent months, winning polls conducted by Film Comment and Sight & Sound last week ahead of Indiewire’s poll, which closed Friday.

However, “The Tree of Life” faced sizable competition for Best Film from both the Iranian drama “A Separation,” which opens December 30 and received 59 mentions, and Lars Von Trier’s allegorical tale of the apocalypse, “Melancholia.” With 52 mentions for Best Film, “Melancholia” wound up on fewer ballots than “A Separation,” but received a higher ranking on more lists.

While many critics singled out “The Tree of Life” and “Melancholia,” very few voted for both. The two movies’ final showdown provides a reminder of the competition they began back at Cannes, when some critics discussed the juxtaposition of Malick’s spiritual and noticably Christian worldview with Von Trier’s bleak and secular alternative.

Unsurprisingly, Von Trier and Malick were also neck-and-neck for best director, although Malick won out with 18 votes over Von Trier’s 11. Critics including Roger Ebert, Peter Travers, Karina Longworth and Richard Brody cast their votes for “The Tree of Life.” Those whose votes supported the competition from “Melancholia” included The Village Voice’s J. Hoberman and Amy Taubin, who discussed the film in a conversation moderated by Indiewire last month.

There was less blatant contention over the cinematography category, where “The Tree of Life” easily took first place with 62 mentions, way ahead of “Hugo,” which received nine. Clearly, while “The Tree of Life” was a film that made some critics roll their eyes and others fall asleep, few could deny the allure of cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki’s roaming camera and sweeping views of natural beauty. A vote for the cinematography of “The Tree of Life” seemed to endorse not only Lubezki’s accomplishment but also the frequently overwhelming sense of wonder that Malick usually employs with his poetic visual style.

“The Tree of Life” did not dominate in other categories; nor did any other film. Instead, all the performance categories, as well as those for screenplay, first feature and documentary, came down to close calls -- and, in one case, a shared prize. The number one spot for Best Performance was shared by two actors whose turns as seriously damaged men have garnered acclaim: Michael Shannon, playing a possibly schizophrenic blue-collar worker prophesying the end of days in “Take Shelter,” and Michael Fassbender, whose turn as a sex-addicted New Yorker in “Shame” has landed even more approval than the movie itself. Fassbender received 45 mentions, just one more than Shannon, but the ranking of various lists led to a tie.  

In the Best Supporting Performance category, Christopher Plummer’s crowdpleasing role as a man who comes out of the closet in his 70s in Mike Mills’ “Beginners” received 44 mentions, nudging ahead of Albert Brooks’ menacing turn in “Drive,” which received 41. (Further down the list, a few voters tried to give “The Artist” hero Uggie the Dog some leverage. He received four presumably sincere votes.)

“A Separation,” another popular favorite for best film, landed in first place for Best Screenplay, a few steps ahead of Kenneth Lonergan’s “Margaret.” That movie, the subject of much discussion among critics over the last few weeks when a petition was launched to convince distributor Fox Searchlight to screen the little-seen film to more critics’ groups, still won one category: Best Ensemble, a recognition of committed performances from a cast that included Anna Paquin (who also came in second for Best Lead Performance), J. Smith Cameron, Jeannie Berlin, Mark Ruffalo and Matt Damon.

On the other side of the arena from name actors and established auteurs, the category for Best First Feature went to another Fox Searchlight release: Sean Durkin for his acclaimed debut “Martha Marcy May Marlene,” which premiered at Sundance in January and eventually led Durkin and his colleagues at Borderline Films to land a first-look deal with the film’s distributor.

Another Sundance premiere won Best Documentary: “The Interrupters,” a sprawling account of activism against Chicago street violence from “Hoop Dreams” director Steve James, received 17 mentions, just ahead of Patricio Guzman’s equally acclaimed “Nostalgia for the Light,” a mesmerizing portrait of the Chilean desert. Indiewire interviewed Guzman, who recently won accolades from the IDA and Cinema Tropical awards, earlier this year.

Even in the category of Best Undistributed Film, where critics usually vote for a wide variety of titles based on what they manage to see at various festivals, the top spot was nearly a tie. “The Color Wheel,” Alex Ross Perry’s acerbic comedy about sibling rivalry, won first place with 15 mentions, just ahead of Sophia Takal’s sexual thriller “Green,” which received 12.

Still, the films that received many votes might not interest readers as much as those that received only one. In every category, many critics chose to single out movies, performances, screenplays and technical feats that either nobody else saw or felt compelled to recognize. While these individual votes have no real sway over the movies at the top of the list, they still sit on our results page for your browsing pleasure. (Of note: A rogue vote for “Scream 4” as the best film of 2011 and another for “Monkey Man” from “Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives” as best performance.)

And that’s the good news: The publication of Indiewire’s poll marks the launch of the site’s temporary Criticwire design, which went into hibernation when the rest of the site relaunched with a new look last month. We know it’s nothing flashy yet and plan to launch a far more exciting version of the Criticwire network early next year. For now, you can still peruse critics’ year-end ballots and grades for new releases to get a sense of the varying opinions at the end of the year.

As we march forward with plans for Criticwire’s new life, we really want to know what you’d like to see it become; if you have any suggestions, please don’t hesitate to contact us at editors@indiewire.com.

Stay tuned for more coverage of Indiewire’s 2011 film poll throughout this week.

17 Comments

  • Wayne | January 9, 2012 5:33 PMReply

    Oh yeah, and on the directors’ list – Lu Chuan director of City of Life and Death and Chuan Lu director of City of Life and Death, those are obviously the same guy. Next year perhaps you could have somebody actually read the lists before you post them.

  • Wayne | January 3, 2012 5:01 PMReply

    Extraordinary Stories and Historias Extraordinarias are the same movie. Le Quattro Volte and . La Quattro Volte are the same movie. Black Power Mixtape 1967-1975 and Black Power Mixtape are the same movie.

  • A Separation / Filmnegah Site & Indiewire 8) | December 23, 2011 9:56 AMReply

    A Separation / Filmnegah Site & Indiewire :

    http://filmnegah.com/pdata/khabar/khabar.php?id=179

    http://filmnegah.com/pdata/khabar/khabar.php?id=178

    http://filmnegah.com/pdata/khabar/khabar.php?id=64

    http://filmnegah.com/pdata/khabar/khabar.php?id=52

  • A Separation / Filmnegah Site & Indiewire 8) | December 23, 2011 9:54 AMReply

    A Separation / Filmnegah Site & Indiewire

    فیلمنامه «جدایی نادر از سیمین» بهترین فیلمنامه سال 2011 از نگاه منتقدان ایندی وایر

    http://filmnegah.com/pdata/khabar/khabar.php?id=179

  • Danial | December 22, 2011 12:08 PMReply

    A separation ... "The Best"

  • Razi | April 24, 2012 2:30 PM

    Very Good! *-:

  • Razi | April 24, 2012 2:29 PM

    Very Good!

  • Achilles420 | December 20, 2011 3:55 AMReply

    Emmanuel Lubezki is listed twice ...lol ...first as Tree of life at rank 1 then as Emmanuel Lubezki , Tree of life. Same for Hugo-Robert Richardson :) :)

  • Eric | December 20, 2011 5:51 PM

    This is the result of an error in data entry and should be corrected shortly. Thanks for your concern.

  • Mehrdad | December 20, 2011 2:44 AMReply

    A Seperation... ;)

  • Thomasi | December 19, 2011 5:49 PMReply

    How does one see which critics voted for a particular film (or performance, etc.) without clicking through each and every individual critics' page? For example, is there a way to see a list of the 17 critics who included "Le Havre" in their best film lists, or the 10 critics who cited John C. Reilly for supporting performance?

  • MDL | December 19, 2011 5:29 PMReply

    Note a slight error in the list regarding LE and LA.
    Le Quattro Volte is listed twice in the poll. Once, correctly, as LE Quattro Volte at #26 with 17 mentions and once, incorrectly, as LA Quattro Volte and tied for #72 and 1 mention. So it really should be #25 with a score of 93 and 18 mentions.

  • Rich | December 19, 2011 4:58 PMReply

    I'm having trouble figuring out how to send an email to those that run this site. I was wondering if the webmaster knew that all of the links at the bottom of the previous years' poll intros are broken. Will the results of those polls ever return for the sake of posterity? These indiewire polls are some of the best film polls on the web, and it would be a shame if they were only around for a limited period of time.

  • Rania | December 19, 2011 3:46 PMReply

    Please note that for the "Undistributed" category, we critics were asked to "try and double check that the film has indeed not found distribution yet..." This makes the list a great resource for distributors and programmers looking for material. It also precludes many of the selections found in Film Comment's "Unreleased 2011" category, with films that will have a theatrical run in 2012.

  • James McNally | December 19, 2011 3:02 PMReply

    Do you explain your methodology anywhere? I put together an end of year Best Film award with about 50 local film bloggers here in Toronto and I'm wondering how our methods compare?

  • Betsy McLane | December 19, 2011 12:25 PMReply

    The top documentary gets on 17 votes...what sort of critical panel is this?

  • Eric | December 19, 2011 1:49 PM

    It's a panel of 162 critics with many different opinions on the best documentary of the year.