You will be redirected back to your article in seconds
Back to IndieWire

Top Oscar Surprises: Gary Oldman and Demian Who?

Top Oscar Surprises: Gary Oldman and Demian Who?

The awards season zooms ahead now that the Oscar nominations have been announced. What didn’t we see coming? And what were those voters thinking? Never mind; a pointless question. Here’s a look at the biggest surprises and how they change the race.


This is still George Clooney’s award, with Brad Pitt the runner up. But there were two terrific surprises. Gary Oldman, virtually ignored by other awards except the BAFTAs, turned  up for his amazing, restrained performance in Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy. And Demian Bichir – I know, Demian who? – squeaked in for his affecting role as a Mexican gardener in A Better Life. (Photo below; he also played Castro in Steven Soderbergh’s Che.)

Bichir displaced the presumed nominee, Michael Fassbender in Shame. Maybe the still-staid Academy didn’t want to sit through all those Michael Fassbender penis jokes that have also seemed inevitable. Oh, yes, Jean Dujardin from The Artist was nominated too; snooze. Much more on this race to come.  


There could have been as few as five or as many as ten under this year’s wackadoodle rules, and a smaller number would have focused attention on the inevitable battle between The Artist and Hugo – or is it The Artist vs. The Descendants? With nine nominees, the possibilities for spreading votes changes the dynamics. There should have been seven. The Help, Moneyball, Midnight in Paris were all expected. Tree of Life wasn’t, which sends a message somebody wants to be seen as artistic. Then there were the lily-livered nominations: War Horse is there because it’s big and it’s by Spielberg. The mediocre Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close is there because … well, who knows? Earnest 9/11 subject?   

The Descendants seems less and less likely — I’m on Team Hugo.


 Anything that cuts down on those bloated, cringe-inducing production numbers is fine with me. This year’s Best Song nominees are from The Muppets (“Man or Muppet”) and Rio (“Real in Rio”). Kid-friendly music may not make for the most sophisticated Oscar show, but it’s pretty hard to go wrong with Muppets!  


Albert Brooks, widely considered a sure thing for a Supporting Actor nomination for Drive, wasn’t. But as he Tweeted yesterday , the nominations were only going to tell him if he had to show up for another awards ceremony where Christopher Plummer won.

The race is just heating up and will be fascinating to watch – maybe more fascinating than the Billy Crystal old-timers show. 

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Awards and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,