Back to IndieWire

‘Iron Man 3’ Review and Roundup: Downey, Jr. in Top Form as Smart Superhero (TRAILER)

'Iron Man 3' Review and Roundup: Downey, Jr. in Top Form as Smart Superhero (TRAILER)

Marvel’s “Iron Man 3” finally opens stateside–after breaking box office records overseas— on May 3. This one marks a huge improvement on the disappointing second, which had to carry water for the upcoming “Avengers,” and was, director Jon Favreau has admitted, like “juggling chainsaws.” 

The latest installment, directed by ace writer-actioner Shane Black (“Kiss Kiss Bang Bang”) is so pixel-heavy that it’s certainly heading for several tech Oscar nominations, including VFX. Wisely, the well-constructed script gives iron-clad billionaire Tony Stark (Robert Downey, Jr.) some human-scale time to rely on his wits and abilities as a “mechanic”–most satisfyingly, with a great kid (Ty Simpkins) who helps him out while his beat-up Iron Man suit is recharging–before (SPOILER ALERT) all his obsessive-compulsive tinkering in the form of multiple smart robot Iron Men arrive like “Transformers”-inspired cavalry for the climactic battle.

The script satisfyingly finds time for loyal buds Happy Hogan (Favreau), Stark’s overzealous security guard, and Colonel James Rhodes (Don Cheadle), love interest Pepper Potts (Gwenyth Paltrow) and a brainy scientist (Rebecca Hall) as well as terrorist villains Guy Pearce (who is menacing without resorting to the over-the-top pyrotechnics he deployed in “Lawless”) and Ben Kingsley as The Mandarin, who warns: “You know who I am, but you don’t know where I am.” (On the negative side, Black and Drew Pearce’s terrorism plot veers perilously close to “The Dark Knight” on several fronts.)

Marvel overlord Kevin Feige (who spoke at the EW screening series Capetown) has masterfully managed the fast-moving multiple incarnations of his comics universe, now based at Disney, but 2008’s “Iron Man” illustrates why originals are so often more brilliant than their sequels–unless they closely follow existing literary material. “Iron Man 3” was the first time he oversaw a Marvel Studios-controlled third movie, he tells Geoff Boucher.
“Phase One was about convincing moviegoing audiences that this universe is connected,” he explained. “Phase Two, especially at the beginning with ‘Iron Man 3,’ is to show that they’re just as cool by themselves.

Back in 2011 at another Boucher Q & A, Favreau described the ideal scenario in which he and Downey Jr.–who had to test and fight for the role of Tony Stark that made him a global star–were creatively free, flying by the seat of their pants, dreaming things up, yet still working within the constraints of the Marvel universe. The minute Downey came on board everything changed, said Favreau, his personality informed Tony Stark, and Gwyneth Paltrow and Jeff Bridges wanted to play opposite him. On the first, added Downey, “when you have nothing to lose, you sometimes take risks. You might as well really make it trippy.”

Favreau believes strongly in hanging on to a real-world grounding, mixing CG with practical effects, and telling his story from the point-of-view of his protagonists. “You have to use CGI to augment reality,” he said, “and not drift to fantasyland…the minute it becomes spectacle it’s no longer a subjective experience.” Favreau liked starting off the movie with Stark in deep trouble, because it builds good will for the character.

There was no down time at all between the first and the second “Iron Man,” which had to follow all the crazy stuff they invented in the first one. It was harder to ground the second film in reality, said Favreau: “When it’s not real, you’re juggling chainsaws.” They could no longer do whatever they wanted on “Iron Man 2,” including two irreverent openings, one written but rejected and one filmed, because “now we had something to protect,” for Marvel and the studio, and had to fit in superhuman The Hulk and SHIELD elements to advance Joss Whedon’s upcoming “The Avengers.”

See review sampling and trailer below.

The Hollywood Reporter:

Looking, if anything, younger than he did in his last couple of spins for Marvel, Downey is at his superhero genius best here, rattling off dialogue both clever and boilerplate with non-repetitive aplomb. Clearly, part of the thinking behind this installment was to have Tony spend much of his time out of his Iron Man suit and force him to generate creative, rather than just physical, ways to solve problems, and this gives the actor more opportunities than he had in the second go-round. Hall’s offbeat presence in what is her first big-budget franchise outing is greatly welcome, Pearce brings an arresting presence to his role as an egghead villain, and a fabulously accoutered and adorned Kingsley has a field day as the elusive Mandarin.

The Playlist:

Trailers and promos so far have promised a darker take on the character than the previous two films, but happily, this is no dour Nolan-aping affair; if anything, it’s more committed to the action-comedy feel than the previous installments, even as Black and co-writer Drew Pearce manage to find space for some strong character work; this is the film that seems to get under Tony Stark’s skin the best, and lets Downey Jr find new notes to play.


The inevitable franchise fatigue — plus a markedly unmemorable villain — may account for the feeling that “Iron Man 3” is more perfunctory and workmanlike than its two predecessors, but this solid production still delivers more than enough of what fans expect to earn its weight in box office metal.

The Guardian:

Robert Downey Jr is back, smashing walls and cracking wise as the billionaire industrialist Tony Stark, now out of the closet as Iron Man, living the dream in his future-tech clifftop pad and cohabitating with the beautiful Pepper Potts – Gwyneth Paltrow’s excellent, relaxed performance making me wish she spent more time on film sets and less with her nutritional website.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox