Back to IndieWire

Review Roundup: Critics Go Ga-Ga for Soderbergh’s Outrageously Mesmerizing ‘Behind the Candelabra’

Review Roundup: Critics Go Ga-Ga for Soderbergh's Outrageously Mesmerizing 'Behind the Candelabra'

Critics are over the glittering, bedazzled moon for Steven Soderbergh’s Cannes competition entry “Behind the Candelabra,” set to premiere on HBO on May 26 and starring a no-holds-barred Michael Douglas and Matt Damon as the famed pianist Liberace and his younger lover, Scott Thorson. The Telegraph refers to it as a “gay Pygmalion myth: call it My Fair Laddie,” while the Guardian raves that “the film is mesmeric, riskily incorrect, outrageously watchable and simply outrageous.” Roundup below.

The Hollywood Reporter:

Behind the Candelabra is fabulous — so much so that, were
it not for the fact that it reveals everything about his private life that he
worked so hard to conceal, Liberace himself might well have loved it. The big
screen’s loss is HBO’s gain in what is billed as Steven Soderbergh’s farewell
to the cinema, at least for the time being. Superbly scripted, brilliantly
directed, smart but never smarmy and led by a lead performance by Michael
Douglas so good you often forget you’re watching an actor rather than the
famous character he’s playing, this is a rarity, a fully realized biographical
drama shot through with real feeling and an abundance of sly humor. It’s a
winner all around.


Ironically, despite being the most bigscreen-worthy film
that director Steven Soderbergh has made since “Che,” this eye-popping biopic
will unspool Stateside on HBO, while receiving theatrical treatment abroad,
where the star power of Michael Douglas and Matt Damon will draw masses to
performances unlike any in their careers.

Behind The Candelabra tells Thorson’s story of that
five-year relationship and the fallout from it, and Soderbergh treats this
source material with his usual piercing intelligence. In his hands it becomes a
gay Pygmalion myth: call it My Fair Laddie.

The film is mesmeric, riskily incorrect, outrageously
watchable and simply outrageous. Unlike ITV’s Vicious, which stars two famously
gay actors, Behind the Candelabra does not offer any extra-textual liberal
assurances in its casting. Michael Douglas is very funny as the great man
himself, a primped and toupéed peacock of the ivories whose undoubted technical
genius at the keyboard means he does not need to rehearse, and whose excess
energy and artistry is channelled into chasing after young men. Matt Damon is
Scott, the pert animal trainer and would-be veterinarian who wins Liberace’s
heart by artlessly offering to treat his blind poodle, Babyboy.

But the movie is at heart a two-hander, an intimate love
story between older flamboyant pianist showman (Michael Douglas) and his younger
lover Scott Thorson (Matt Damon). It is neither too big nor too small. It feels
just right. It was shot in 30 days–five fewer than “sex lies and

Douglas, who goes from preening in front of a theater full
of people to being stumbled upon, bald and sagging, fresh out of the shower,
plays Liberace as pulled between his need for control and his desire to care
and be cared for by someone not just there to freeload. It’s a terrific and
vanity-free performance, one that finds the conflicted, aging person underneath
the self-embraced caricature while also making it clear that caricature is
where Liberace is most comfortable. And Damon matches him by portraying Scott
as someone aware that he’s leaping onto a gravy train but who can’t
help but take seriously Liberace’s insistence that he’s the family Scott never
had, his yearning and mild avarice inseparable.

Both hilarious and heartrending too, “Behind The
Candelabra” is decadently entertaining, even if its basic rise-and-fall
structure is nothing new. Soderbergh finds the hollowness lying beneath the
“palatial kitsch” Liberace indulges in and takes viewers into a world
where love is the only escape from a life that is pure fiction.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox