Back to IndieWire

Review and Roundup: Neill Blomkamp’s ‘Elysium,’ Starring Damon, Absorbing Sci-Fi with Heavy-Handed Message UPDATE

Review and Roundup: Neill Blomkamp's 'Elysium,' Starring Damon, Absorbing Sci-Fi with Heavy-Handed Message UPDATE

South African writer-director Neill Blomkamp had a tall mountain to climb with his follow-up to low-budget Best Picture Oscar contender “District 9,” which scored $215 million worldwide. Ever since the indie pick-up put Blomkamp on the map as an original filmmaker with an extraordinary command over VFX, film fans have eagerly awaited his next. Sony primed the pump for his $90 million sci-fi thriller “Elysium” (August 9) at Comic-Con last year, where Hall H exploded over seven minutes of early footage. 

Set in 2154, in a world that has become our worst nightmare of a Third World trash dump, the film tracks Max (a streetwise yet vulnerable Matt Damon), a factory worker parolee trying to go straight in over-populated and infected hell-hole Los Angeles. When he is neglectfully exposed to lethal radiation in an industrial accident at his factory, he’s given five days to live. To save himself, he returns to his former criminal cronies, who send him on a dangerous mission to earn his ticket to Elysium, the fantasy resort satellite created by the 1 % who can afford to live in unpolluted luxury, where any ailment can be cured within seconds, orbiting peacefully above the Earth. 

Intercepting illegal earthlings (read aliens) on space shuttles and blowing them out of the sky is Elysium’s ruthless French security chief (a fearsome Jodie Foster, whose foreign accent is distracting). Her muscle on Earth is renegade military man (Sharlto Copley of “District 9”) who hunts down Max with an impressive arsenal, including droids, who also function as the world’s robocops (this is one of several upcoming films to address this topic). Copley’s the most entertaining character in the movie, and brings a welcome sense of humor to his anarchic Id on the rampage–when he starts blowing up Elysium we’re rooting for him. A less effective subplot featuring Alice Braga as Max’s angelic love interest with a terminally ill daughter unbelievably ratchets up the stakes. 

Blomkamp combines earnest politics and social commentary about wealth discrepancy and the gap between rich and poor with the satisfying explosive pyrotechnics of a violent action movie–I love his artful use of slow motion.  He shot the film, which he admits is influenced by Ridley Scott’s “Blade Runner,” in Canada and Mexico with much of his old crew and the same general approach as “District 9,” but with a much larger budget. But the movie doesn’t get over-pixellated. 

Blomkamp grounds “Elysium,” often sticking to Damon’s POV. The effects are realistic, characteristically gritty and on a far grander scale than “District 9.” The film was shot on location at the second largest garbage dump in the world in Mexico City, where the crew could wear gas masks but the actors could not as fecal matter dust was kicked up by roaring helicopter blades. Every detail seems thought-out as the filmmaker deploys a range of VFX houses and techniques (CG animation, mo-cap, miniatures and models) to execute a sophisticated mix of epic slum settings as well as futuristic Elysium and nifty spacecraft and weaponry, expertly designed by Weta. (Blomkamp’s script is James Cameron-level smart about setting up the weapons that will be used in various fight scenes and battles.) The complex sound design is superb, with a constant tech drone, and modulated contrasts between Earth’s din and the smooth whir of shuttles in space.  

That said, while in no way does this film devolve into formula–it is thankfully an original–and Blomkamp’s autonomy is evident, as the film was again set up as an indie pick-up, like many summer entertainments the technological expertise involved is greater than the sum of its characters. While I applaud the movie’s message, its heart gets lost in the noisy scramble. 

Our review round-up is below; critical reactions range from moderately positive to negative, with Variety calling the film “less dazzling [than ‘District 9’] but nonetheless highly absorbing and intelligent,” while The Wrap writes that Blomkamp has the political-message subtlety of a “sledgehammer,” and THR notes the film’s “very deflating final act script problems.” 

Check out our TOH! video interview with Blomkamp at 2012’s Comic-Con here.


So close and yet so far, the colony of Elysium hovers just
outside Earth’s atmosphere, a mere 19-minute shuttle ride away but figurative
light years for the downtrodden proletarian masses of the 22nd century. So
begins the much-anticipated second feature from South African writer-director
Neill Blomkamp, whose 2009 “District 9” was one of the few recent
sci-fi/fantasy pics (along with “Inception” and “Children of Men”) that
deserved to be called visionary. Here, Blomkamp delivers a less dazzling but
nonetheless highly absorbing and intelligent, socially conscious bit of
futurism, made on a much larger scale than its $30 million predecessor, but
with lots of the same scrappy ingenuity. Result confirms the helmer as much
more than a one-hit wunderkind.

The Wrap:

Science-fiction is, of course, often used as a vehicle to
tell stories about the here and now disguised as tales of the future — and
lest anyone miss out on Blomkamp’s thoughts on contemporary immigration and
health care, “Elysium” underlines and italicizes them before going over them
again in yellow highlighter.

Blomkamp is a master of creating action out of a grimy,
quotidian kind of next-gen hi-tech, but when it comes to metaphors, he prefers
the sledgehammer.

Hollywood Reporter:

A politically charged flight of speculative fiction makes an
exciting launch, only to tailspin into an ungainly crash landing in Elysium.
Coming in the wake of After Earth and White House Down, this marks Sony’s third
big-budget disappointment of the summer, the problems this time stemming from
very deflating final act script problems that one would think could have been
easily identified. Like Neill Blomkamp’s out-of-nowhere sci-fi triumph with
District 9 four years back, this one puts rugged action and convincing visual
effects at the service of a sociologically-pointed haves-and-have-nots
storyline, but when the air goes out of this balloon, it goes fast.


As with his 2009 debut, the Best Picture-nominated District
9, writer-director Neill Blomkamp’s follow-up mixes sci-fi action and social
parable — not consistently successfully but always emphatically. Recalling Mad
Max 2 (aka The Road Warrior) by way of WALL-E, Elysium is best appreciated as
an intense, brawny, effects-heavy spectacle that benefits from Matt Damon’s
sympathetic performance. Unfortunately, the film’s higher aspirations —
dramatic grandeur, political commentary — never come across as anything less
than heavy-handed, more enjoyably overblown than genuinely captivating.

The Playlist:

With “Elysium,” Blomkamp has made good on the
promise of “District 9” and proven that working on a bigger canvas
doesn’t mean compromising on smarts or aspirations to deliver tentpole sized
stories with a thoughtful backbone. And really, it’s those qualities which set
“Elysium” apart from the slog of sequels, spinoffs, remakes and
superhero movies. It has the audacity (at least in Hollywood terms) of aiming
for something original both in concept and design, and that Blomkamp’s nails it
in a fashion as entertaining, thrilling and memorable as this, is all the more
reason you need to see it.

Maybe Blomkamp’s next one will get a shot of nuance and take
a cleansing ride through a medical scanner to rid itself of plot
inconsistencies. (Those who like to gripe will have a lot of “wait, why didn’t
he just…?” type of complaints.) Still, this is my kind of movie. It’s visually
arresting, swings for the fences, has crazy weapons, wild technology and presents
a world where a cyborg can stumble down the street and no one blinks an eye.
Maybe the future isn’t all that terrible?

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox