Back to IndieWire

Review: Kate Lyn Sheil Is the Beating Heart of ‘The Heart Machine’

Review: Kate Lyn Sheil Is the Beating Heart of 'The Heart Machine'

At SXSW, I must admit I was rather underwhelmed by the
offerings. Maybe it was all the Brooklyn settings, or the abundance of 20 and
30-something malaise. Hasn’t this become stale by now? And this is coming from
someone in the key demo to appreciate 20 and 30-something malaise.

However, one performance stuck with me. Kate Lyn Sheil (“Sun Don’t Shine”),
a ubiquitous face in the indie scene if not yet a well-known name like, say,
Greta Gerwig or Joe Swanberg, is undeniably a standout in Zachary Wigon’s tale of
long-distance relationship woes and paranoia, “The Heart Machine.” Sheil stands
out not because she “kills” the performance — it’s not a big, showy turn —
but rather because she underplays it. It’s a difficult, somewhat inscrutable
role — and, alas, female characters who make murky choices typically throw
viewers for a loop — but as I watched her I felt like I knew that person she was playing. This isn’t easy to do.

“The Heart Machine” isn’t literally about a long-distance
relationship. Cody (“Newsroom”‘s John Gallagher Jr, playing off-type) has made a strong
online connection with Virginia (Sheil), who has told him she’s studying abroad
for six months in Berlin. But Cody is having doubts. Things don’t add up — the
sirens he hears in her background over Skype aren’t the instantly recognizable
drone of European ambulances, and the plug outlets in her apartment are
suspiciously square and three-prong. Is Virginia lying to him about where she
lives? And, if so, why? She’s clearly as into him as he is into her.

Cody becomes unhealthily obsessed with discovering Virginia’s
whereabouts, and he turns into a downright creep in the process. As Cody
devolves, scouring the East Vilage for hints and traces of his allusive
girlfriend, and as Virginia meanwhile fights her own demons, we realize these
two are indeed suffering from being “long-distance.” The internet can bring
people together but also create an unsettling amount of space between them.
This isn’t a new idea, but it’s effectively communicated in “The Heart Machine.”

The film, well directed by first-time feature helmer Wigon, does make the occasional misstep. There’s an implausible scene where
Cody stalks a would-be Facebook friend of Virginia’s, and near the film’s end
Virginia gives an on-the-nose explanation of her behavior, which isn’t needed.

But good characters anchor a film, even when it’s plotting or
dialogue are momentarily derailed. In Sheil’s strong performance and her subtly
written role created by Wigon, we feel the substantial amount of observant nuance
— and heart — in “The Heart Machine.”

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , , , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox