Back to IndieWire

Sleeper of the Week: ‘About Elly’

Sleeper of the Week: 'About Elly'

Sleeper of the Week takes a film that only
few critics have seen and shines some light on it.

“About Elly”
Dir: Asghar Farhadi
Criticwire Average: A-

Iranian writer-director Asghar Farhadi burst onto the scene in 2011 with “A Separation,” a masterful Chekhovian drama that won him an Oscar for Best Foreign Film and earned raves as one of the best films of the first half of the decade. (The A.V. Club put it second after “The Master.”) His follow-up, “The Past,” played at the Cannes Film Festival, where star Berenice Bejo won a richly-deserved Best Actress prize. Farhadi has another film out this week, only it isn’t a new one: “About Elly” played the festival circuit in 2009 but is only just now seeing a Stateside release. 

The film covers the disappearance of a kindergarten teacher after a near-drowning of one of the children. While the film’s plot has earned comparisons to Michelangelo Antonioni’s “L’Avventura,” “About Elly” is more concerned with how people caught in the middle of a terrible situation blame others and hold back the full truth in order to deflect blame themselves. Farhadi is concerned with human nature, with the reasons behind people’s lies, and with how people fall apart when disaster strikes. If it isn’t quite on the level of his subsequent masterworks, it still shows him growing into one of the finest dramatists working today.

More thoughts from the Criticwire Network:

Godfrey Cheshire, RogerEbert.com

“Opening spaces” is precisely what Farhadi’s films do, both literally and figuratively. Indeed, the various ways great Iranian directors articulate visual space comprise one of the most fascinating and significant dimensions of Iranian cinema, from the contemplative and symbolic uses in some films to the poetic and documentary-like in others. Read more.

A.A. Dowd, The A.V. Club

“About Elly” isn’t as formally or structurally accomplished as “A Separation”… Even still, this is clearly the work of a master in the making, an artist on the cusp of greatness. Farhadi may be fixated on fibbers, but there’s almost no one working today who makes films so emotionally honest. Read more.

Andrew O’Hehir, Salon

As with the Antonioni film that Farhadi has so ingeniously turned to his purposes, you shouldn’t go see About Elly hoping for a Hitchcock-style thriller that will answer all your narrative questions. But if “L’Avventura” is a deliberately frustrating portrait of European postwar anomie and a study in abstract, black-and-white composition, “About Elly” is more dynamic and more realistic. Read more.

    Matt Prigge, Metro

    If it can be a touch too narratively byzantine and heavy-handed, it’s still a quietly devastating throwback to the classics of drama — a form that has largely disappeared from the cinema landscape. Read more.

    Scott Tobias, The Dissolve

    “About Elly” offers further confirmation of Farhadi’s peerless skills as a dramatist, with a special talent for drawing prismatic meaning from simple premises and writing fully developed characters up and down the ensemble. Read more.

    Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

    This Article is related to: Reviews and tagged , ,

    Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox