You will be redirected back to your article in seconds
Back to IndieWire

Paul Thomas Anderson’s Beautiful Struggle: Trump, Retirement, and Death Made ‘Phantom Thread’ One of His Hardest Films

Major changes — both personal and professional — impacted the filmmaker's experience on his new movie, but he remains undeterred.

Paul Thomas Anderson


Anderson tends to his wind his way through interviews by either folding them into the subjects of his movies, or by embracing the random tangents that some interviewers toss his way (hence recent stories about his thoughts on “Star Wars” and his free Netflix account). He evades pressure to get political, or to address the climate of the film industry as a whole. In this case, he has no interest in digging into the sexual harassment scandals rocking the business.

“It is the last thing I’d like to think about,” he said, but acknowledged that his movie — which explicitly involves male-female relationships in a workplace environment that cross more than one line — may provide some window into the nature of that struggle. Even here, however, he discussed it through the framework of the story, and it all comes down to the provenance of the word “mannequin.”

Recalling the 1987 Andrew McCarthy movie of the same name, Anderson noted that “a mannequin is something that has no moving parts, it stands still in the window. Now, go back to the ‘50s, and the mannequin was actually the moving model. They were referring to a flesh-and-blood woman who was moving around as a mannequin. Somewhere along the way, these words were interchanged so that these plastic things that didn’t move were called mannequins and a model became a real flesh-and-blood person.”

The evolution of that term spoke to the contrast between the treatment of women as objects of fashion and the occasional tendency to push back. “There are probably a million other designers who would prefer the women not to say anything at all, just to stand there,” he said. “That was maddening to me. More times than not, there’s a real give and take in relationships between the model, the muse, the mannequin, and the creator.”

In extracting aspects of Reynolds’ character from the biography of Spanish designer Cristóbal Balenciaga, he found a vessel for the movie’s central clash of personalities. “The kind of requirements that were put on these women were all about this discipline, and the discipline of serving the creator,” he said, “but the stories that we read that were most fascinating were the relationships Balenciaga had with the women who would bite back.”

Ultimately, “Phantom Thread” works around Day-Lewis’ outsized presence, until Krieps — a genuine discovery whom Anderson plucked from hundreds of possibilities — becomes the movie’s true centerpiece. “She had that thing where if she wants you to know what she’s thinking, she’ll make it very clear in her words, her face, her body language,” Anderson said. “But if she wants to make you guess, you will have no idea what’s going on behind her eyes.”

Vicky Krieps in Phantom Thread

Vicky Krieps in “Phantom Thread”

That struggle between understatement and clear direction lies at the heart of all Anderson movies, and his tendency toward perfectionism trickles down into his distribution approach as well. Ever since he forced The Weinstein Company to release “The Master” on 70mm, Anderson has continued his crusade to make his movies available on pristine film prints. For him, it doesn’t matter that the number of theaters committed to showing movies on film around the world has dwindled; that only simplifies the process.

“It’s not that many phone calls,” he said. “It used to be impossible. We know pretty much everybody that runs film, and that kind of makes things a bit easier. At this point, it’s a tight group of people.” For instance, he added, “You know you can call The Metrograph and say, ‘Hey, make sure to run it on a seven,’ or, ‘How’s it look?’ You actually, genuinely can have a personal connection to the majority of projectionists in this country and Europe.”

Any discussion about Anderson’s unorthodox distribution beliefs leads to conversations about the nature of the marketplace. “You’re not going to get me to take a shit on Netflix!” Anderson said, with a shy laugh, perhaps aware of likeminded theatrical purist Christopher Nolan’s condemnatory remarks earlier this year. “Would I ever go into business with Netflix? Well, I don’t know. I suppose.” He acknowledged that his colleague Scott Frank recently developed the Western series “Godless” for the platform. “I don’t know how you make an eight-hour movie,” Anderson said. “But are two-hour movies good for Netflix? Don’t know. Don’t think so.”

He drew a distinction between committing to the presentation of his own work and the shifting industry. “It’s not even a fight; it was more like calling people and the appetite was there,” he said. “It’s never been a chore. There is no thrill that’s as unbeatable as sitting in a movie theater when it’s big and loud.” He clarified: “I’m old,” said the 47-year-old filmmaker. “I’m set in my ways. That’s how I like my product.”

Ironically, Anderson dipped into the arena of digital distribution two years ago with “Junun,” an experimental concert documentary featuring longtime collaborator Jonny Greenwood (who scored “Phantom Thread”) and several Indian musicians, which was released on the streaming platform MUBI just days after premiering at New York Film Festival. “It was kind of hilarious,” Anderson said. “We made it for fun, and we put it out there in a way that we thought was interesting, but fucking nobody’s seen it.”

Anderson fought for final cut on his debut “Hard Eight” 20 years ago, and he remains devoted to developing movies aligned with his aesthetic. However, his mentors have steadily dropped out of the picture. He lost his close colleague Robert Altman over a decade ago, and the closing dedication of “Phantom Thread” to Jonathan Demme speaks to that filmmaker’s ongoing relationship to the director over the years.


“Demme was my man,” Anderson said, noting that he described “Phantom Thread” to him the last time they spoke. Word that Demme was fading reached the “Phantom Thread” set in late April, a few days before he passed away. “It was a really melancholy day to be sort of celebrating at the end of this really challenging film we’d worked really hard on, and here we had this really terrible news,” Anderson said. “I could hear his voice ringing around in my head, being really happy for me for finishing the film.”

As he drifts closer to middle age, Anderson may sound more wistful and solitary than before, but it hasn’t altered his commitment to the medium. “What I do is deeply important to me,” he said. “It’s the only thing I’ve ever done. It’s the only job I’ve ever had. It’s the only thing I could see myself doing.” The beautiful struggle involved in getting his movies made has shown no signs of wear, though he insisted that the challenges of “Phantom Thread” amounted to business as usual. “I didn’t feel any less pressure than I normally do,” he said. “The amount of panic and fear and excitement that goes into any day of shooting is the same. Always.”

“Phantom Thread” opens theatrically on December 25, 2017.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Film and tagged , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox