Back to IndieWire

Here’s What the Critics’ Choice Awards Winners Mean for the Oscar Race

"The Shape of Water" claimed Best Picture, and its director and executive producer used their speeches to champion Fox Searchlight amid the Disney merger.

Guillermo del Toro and the cast and crew of "The Shape of Water" accept the award for best picture at the 23rd annual Critics' Choice Awards at the Barker Hangar, in Santa Monica, Calif23rd Annual Critics' Choice Awards - Show, Santa Monica, USA - 11 Jan 2018

Michael Stuhlbarg, Taylor, Octavia Spencer, Richard Jenkins, Sally Hawkins, and J. Miles Dale flank Guillermo del Toro as he accepts the Critics’ Choices Awards Best Picture honors for “The Shape of Water.”


Critics’ Choice Awards voters were less keen on “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri” than the Hollywood Foreign Press Association. The film drama winners at the CCAs mostly matched those at the Golden Globes four nights prior, with the exception of Best Picture and Best Screenplay. While the 90-member HFPA gave both honors to Martin McDonagh’s drama about a grieving mother opposing her town’s police department , the 300 national BFCA critics voted “The Shape of Water” Best Picture, recognizing “Call Me by Your Name” and “Get Out” for respective adapted and original screenplays.

Additional favorites have emerged in the acting races: Frances McDormand for Best Actress (“Three Billboards”), Gary Oldman for Best Actor (“Darkest Hour), Allison Janney for Best Supporting Actress (“I, Tonya”) and Sam Rockwell for “Three Billboards.” The CCAs have proved particularly adept at predicting the Best Supporting Actor Oscar winner — in eight of the past nine years, the same person has accepted both awards. McDormand and Oldman also won the HFPA’s lead acting awards in the dramatic categories, while on Sunday, Saoirse Ronan (“Lady Bird”) and James Franco (“The Disaster Artist”) took home Globes for their musical/comedy turns.

Sam Rockwell and Frances McDormand in “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri”

Fox Searchlight

Although Franco also won the Best Actor in a Comedy CCA, he was notably absent from the ceremony, which took place on the same day five women came forward in The Los Angeles Times to accuse him of sexually exploitative behavior. This time Best Actress in a Comedy went to Margot Robbie for “I, Tonya.”

“The Shape of Water” was the most-nominated film at both ceremonies (seven Globe nods, 14 CCAs; the later has nearly twice as many categories), and the same will be true at the BAFTA Awards on February 18 (12 nods). Director Guillermo del Toro repeated his Globes win, receiving a standing ovation from the Broadcast Film Critics Association (BFCA) and the Broadcast Television Journalists Association (BTJA) for his tenth feature. Starring Sally Hawkins as a mute janitor who falls in love with the Amazonian creature (Doug Jones) who is tortured at the lab where she works, “The Shape of Water” also claimed CCAs for Best Production Design and Best Score.

Jessica Chastain, Greta Gerwig. Jessica Chastain, left, and Greta Gerwig speak in the audience at the 23rd annual Critics' Choice Awards at the Barker Hangar, in Santa Monica, Calif23rd Annual Critics' Choice Awards - Show, Santa Monica, USA - 11 Jan 2018

Jessica Chastain and Greta Gerwig at the Critics’ Choice Awards


If del Toro’s Cold War-era fable lands both Best Director and Best Picture statuettes, he’ll only be the second winning director since 2013 to avoid a split result (the other was Alejandro G. Iñárritu, del Toro’s longtime friend). A del Toro Best Director Oscar win would also make Damien Chazelle (“La La Land”) the only non-Mexican director to win the category in five years; Iñárritu prevailed back-to-back for “Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance)” and “The Revenant,” following Alfonso Cuarón’s “Gravity” triumph.

“Three Billboards” had a trio of victories. The Best Director and Best Picture speeches both turned into pleas to save Fox Searchlight, the studio behind “The Shape of Water” and “Three Billboards.” A longtime backer of indie favorites and award-winners (including “Little Miss Sunshine,” “Juno,” “Slumdog Millionaire,” and “12 Years a Slave”), Fox Searchlight’s future has been speculative since mid-December, when Walt Disney announced it would purchase 21st Century Fox for $52.4 billion.

Gal Gadot accepts the #SEEHER award at the 23rd annual Critics' Choice Awards at the Barker Hangar, in Santa Monica, Calif23rd Annual Critics' Choice Awards - Show, Santa Monica, USA - 11 Jan 2018

Gal Gadot at the 23rd annual Critics’ Choice Awards


Speaking “about things that give me hope,” del Toro singled out “the fact that there are still companies like Fox Searchlight, because I think things are dwindling, and it’s a rarity…we always want to tell stories that matter, and that are difficult to pitch.” “The Shape of Water” producer J. Miles Dale was less subtle: “[Fox Searchlight is] making the kind of movies that we need to make, we want to make, and people need to see. So I don’t know if [Disney chairman and CEO] Bob Iger is out there right now and I don’t know what’s going to happen with this Disney thing, but I urge you not to mess this up. They’ve got a good thing going and they rock.”

The 23rd annual ceremony took place at the chilly Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, California. “Get Out” and “Wonder Woman” were crowd favorites, each accepting two trophies. Gal Gadot took home the CCA’s second #SeeHer award — given by the Association of National Advertisers for “increasing the accurate portrayal of women and girls in media and advertising” — succeeding Viola Davis.

Hours two and three were televised on The CW, but the home audience missed when “The Florida Project” actress Brooklynn Prince, age seven, wept when presented with Best Young Actor/Actress. After adorably suggesting she and her fellow nominees “get ice cream afterwards” and — like a Hollywood veteran — thanking “my team,” she dedicated her CCA “to all the Halleys and Moonees out there. Guys, this is a real problem. We need to go out there and help [with hidden homelessness].”

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Awards and tagged , , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox