Back to IndieWire

Producers Guild Nominations Snubs and Surprises: ‘Wonder Woman,’ ‘I, Tonya’ Make the Grade, ‘Phantom Thread’ Doesn’t

Guild nominations bring the Oscar picture into focus as mainstream hits "I, Tonya," "Molly's Game," and "Wonder Woman" join lauded indies.

I Tonya Margot Robbie

“I, Tonya”


With the Producers Guild of America Awards nominations, think mainstream and big-scale. The (largely male) producers tend to reward spectacle and scope, which brings degree of difficulty. They are less likely to go with indies like “The Florida Project,” unless they really love them. That means that PGA nominees “The Big Sick,” “Lady Bird,” and “Get Out” (all WGA and SAG ensemble nominees) are robust Oscar contenders indeed.

And ever since the Academy opened up their Best Picture slots to a maximum possible 10 in 2009, the PGA has stuck with their inclusionary practice of always including an even 10 nominees — until now: A tie yielded a list of 11. That will not repeat on Oscar nominations morning January 23; with such a wide-open field, the likelihood is there will be fewer than nine or eight Best Picture nominees.

The next Oscar guessing game: Which three or four PGA nominees won’t make the Best Picture list? The surprise PGA nominees include “Wonder Woman,” “I,Tonya,” and “Molly’s Game.”

“Wonder Woman”

Steady as they go

As expected, Warner Bros.’ studio spectacle “Dunkirk” made the grade — along with the studio’s far-from-surefire DC entry “Wonder Woman.” This movie could be a Best Picture contender after all.

Otherwise the PGA list includes the usual lauded indie suspects: “The Big Sick” (Judd Apatow/Amazon/Lionsgate), “Call Me By Your Name” (Sony Pictures Classics) (which was denied an Editors Guild nod this week), “Get Out” (Jason Blum/Universal), “I, Tonya” (Neon), “Lady Bird” (Scott Rudin/A24), “Molly’s Game” (Mark Gordon/STX), “The Post” (Amy Pascal/Fox) (which missed a WGA nod), and Fox Searchlight’s two awards behemoths, “The Shape of Water” and “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.”


“Phantom Thread”

Laurie Sparham/Focus Features


Not feeling the love this week was Paul Thomas Anderson’s critically hailed, late-breaking “Phantom Thread,” which did not land WGA, Editing, or even Art Directors Guild nominations. This suggests the Annapurna/Focus Features release may have to settle for an expected Best Costume Oscar nod. While the Working Title/Focus Winston Churchill drama “Darkest Hour” is still in the game for multiple Oscar nominations, including Best Actor Gary Oldman, its Best Picture chances are not favorable.

Among the studio entries that did not make the list are “All the Money in the World” (Sony) and strong technical contenders “Blade Runner 2049” (Alcon/Warners), which landed an Editors Guild nomination,  Fox’s “War for the Planet of the Apes,” and WGA nominee “Logan,” along with Netflix’s awards hopeful “Mudbound,” which did land a SAG ensemble nomination as well as a WGA nod, which suggests that acting and writing nominations are in the offing.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Awards and tagged , , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox