Back to IndieWire

Oscars 2019 Review: The Academy Giveth and It Taketh Away, But That Was One Helluva Show

An overdose of "Bohemian Rhapsody" with a "Green Book" kicker can't quite kill a ceremony that benefitted from what's kept the Oscars engaging for 91 years.

THE OSCARS® - The 91st Oscars® broadcasts live on Sunday, Feb. 24, 2019, at the Dolby Theatre® at Hollywood & Highland Center® in Hollywood and will be televised live on The ABC Television Network at 8:00 p.m. EST/5:00 p.m. PST. (ABC/Craig Sjodin)CHARLIE WACHTEL, SPIKE LEE, DAVID RABINOWITZ, KEVIN WILLMOTT

Spike Lee at the 2019 Oscars


No host, no problem. Though the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences shouldn’t get too much credit for pulling a solid show out of the trash heap of remedied decisions leading up to it (and a few uncorrected voter errors), the 91st Academy Awards proved to work just fine sans host. None of the Oscar staples were cut, and nearly all of them proved to be a huge benefit to the telecast — from the performed songs (including an instant classic “Shallow” staging) to the would-have-been cut categories (the “Skin” creators were the most excited winners of the night) to the length and pacing (this year clocked in as the shortest in at least six years), the 2019 Oscars ran smoother and were far more absorbing than many expected.

And there was a promising indicator as to why. So much focus was put on the bad choices The Academy had been making leading up to this year’s ceremony, the one very, very good choice was largely forgotten: bringing in a more diverse voting body. Despite some problematic forward-facing winners, this year’s Oscars offered many positive steps forward. The new voting body led to a historic, long overdue win for Spike Lee; it led to four black women winning the first five trophies; it led to a record number of black winners overall; it led to women directors sweeping the shorts categories (even though no women directors were nominated for feature directing); it led to a streaming company edging closer to full-blown acceptance in Hollywood’s inner circle; and, yes, it led to a few surprises, including “Green Book” winning Best Picture.

That last pick doesn’t exactly fit the progressive narrative, but progress takes time. This is what happens in transitional years: a mixed bag of statement wins and tone-deaf choices. Plus, less across-the-board cohesion is bound to happen with a larger voting body anyway.

But “Green Book’s” win helps the telecast. Some viewers may be upset, but they can’t deny the show itself was entertaining, which leads us to the critical takeaway: The Oscars thrived in 2019 because they were the Oscars. The Academy didn’t so much get out of its own way, as it was forced out of its own way by public opinion. The pared down version of the show brought all the attention back to the movies and the people who made them, and what do you know? It came alive! It was raw, surprising, and heartfelt! It felt like it was coming from the deep recesses of Oscar’s being, its past self crying out, and what escaped was “haaa ah ah ah ah, aaah aaah, ah ah ah ah haaa!!”

THE OSCARS® - The 91st Oscars® broadcasts live on Sunday, Feb. 24, 2019, at the Dolby Theatre® at Hollywood & Highland Center® in Hollywood and will be televised live on The ABC Television Network at 8:00 p.m. EST/5:00 p.m. PST. (ABC/Ed Herrera)LADY GAGA, BRADLEY COOPER

Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper perform “Shallow” at the 2019 Oscars

ABC/Ed Herrera

The first hour was all about efficiency. The Queen opening numbers with frontman Adam Lambert mercifully kept it to two songs, perhaps cutting a potential third after seeing Javier Bardem get a little too excited during “We Will Rock You.” (Or they just knew how many Queen songs would be slipped into the ceremony throughout the night.) A confusing montage filled with nominees and snubbed movies alike swept in right after; presumably, it was only there to give the team time to clear the stage for presenters, as there thankfully wasn’t another random montage after that, but there’s no reason to highlight movies like “Won’t You Be My Neighbor?” and “The Old Man and the Gun” with clips and voiceover when these movies could’ve been but weren’t, in the end, nominated.

Still, things moved along nicely from there. Tina Fey, Amy Poehler, and Maya Rudolph (future stars of Netflix’s “Wine Country”) were even more energizing than a legendary rock group (as if there was ever a doubt); “We are not your hosts, but we are going to stand here a little too long so the people who get a USA Today tomorrow think we hosted,” Fey said, before the trio made smart quips to defuse the Oscars controversy that preceded the ceremony: “We won’t be presenting awards during the commercials, but we will be presenting commercials during the awards,” Poehler said, before a general plug for mayonnaise. “If we had hosted, it probably would’ve gone like this,” Rudolph said, before they made purposefully cheap cracks like “Bust-er Scruggs? I hardly know her!” and “Roma’s on Netflix, what’s next, my microwave makes a movie?”

Cries for them to just keep hosting picked up steam on Twitter, but it soon became clear that the show was moving along just fine without a single leader. Jason Momoa bro’d out for “Free Solo’s” win with a fitting fist pump; Melissa McCarthy and Brian Tyree Henry made the most of an obvious costume gag (“This is the correct amount of stupid,” as my sister texted me at the time); Keegan Michael-Key flew down from the ceiling a la Mary Poppins to introduce its nominated song, performed by Bette Midler. All of these presenters and more kept any lingering feelings of absence at bay, but the speeches were what really came in clutch.

THE OSCARS® - The 91st Oscars® broadcasts live on Sunday, Feb. 24, 2019, at the Dolby Theatre® at Hollywood & Highland Center® in Hollywood and will be televised live on The ABC Television Network at 8:00 p.m. EST/5:00 p.m. PST. (ABC/Craig Sjodin)OLIVIA COLMAN

Olivia Colman at the 2019 Oscars

ABC/Craig Sjodin

Regina King got the night off on the right foot, taking a breath to honor the moment before paying tribute to her visibly moved mother, sitting and watching with tears in her eyes. Ruth Carter and Hannah Beachler were earnest and excited on stage, as the first ever black women to be nominated and win Best Costume Design and Production Design, respectively. Alfonso Cuaron staggered his speeches, starting with a quick and poignant nod to his longtime friend and cinematographer, Emmanuel “Chivo” Lubezki, before spending a little more time behind the mic for “Roma’s” Best Foreign Language Film win, and finally letting his excitement break through the nerves when he won his second Best Director trophy.

But long before Cuaron’s third solo win, the show took on a life of its own. First, the much-anticipated, heavily hyped “Shallow” performance from Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga somehow shattered those sky-high expectations. With a brilliant choice to show it in one uncut take, masterful blocking, and a raw yet honed turn from the two stars, the Oscar telecast burst to life and never looked back. Sure, “Green Book’s” following win for Best Original Screenplay was a little awkward, but any memories of Nick Vallelonga urges for unity were erased when Spike Lee jumped into Samuel L. Jackson’s arms. More than that, he earned a second Oscar for his speech (presumably), which ended with a loving, well-earned, and pointed nod to his best film, “Do the Right Thing.”

In the end, the unpredictable nature of the Oscars worked in its favor. When the winners feel inevitable, it gets boring. When the speeches are bad, the energy suffers. When there are awkward montages or bits that bomb, the crowd turns. None of that happened this year (at least, not enough to tip favor against the show, though all those Queen songs sure came close). It’s very easy to imagine things going the other way, and this version of the telecast being an utter snoozefest. In future years, The Academy would be ill-advised to rely so heavily on great speeches, a bevy of surprises, and a hostless show garnering this much buzz. But in 2019, the Oscars got to be the Oscars, and everyone won. Even “Green Book.”

Grade: B+

The 91st Academy Awards took place Sunday, February 24, 2019 at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood, CA and aired on ABC.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Awards and tagged , ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox