Back to IndieWire

Joe Carnahan Attacks Film Critic Over Mixed ‘El Chicano’ Review, Then Deletes His Twitter

Carnahan produced and co-wrote the low-budget superhero movie, directed by Ben Hernandez Bray.

"El Chicano"

“El Chicano”

Briarcliff Entertainment

Joe Carnahan has deleted his Twitter account after lashing out at a film critic who gave the new film “El Chicano” a mixed review. Carnahan produced the superhero movie and co-wrote the script with first-time director Ben Hernandez Bray. Film critic Carlos Aguilar reviewed “El Chicano” for the Los Angeles Times, calling the film “solidly acted” and a “technically accomplished spectacle” despite a troubling script that creates “separation between Mexican Americans and Mexican nationals, presented only as demonized, criminal, carnage-friendly, nationalist invaders.”

Aguilar submitted his review to Rotten Tomatoes as a positive one, but his criticisms clearly rubbed Carnahan the wrong way as the filmmaker used Twitter to attack the critic. Carnahan responded to Aguilar’s tweet about the review by saying, “You suck as a writer.”

“This motherfucker is proof that the days of Pauline Kael, Roger Ebert, and Andrew Sarris are dead,” Carnahan wrote about Aguilar in a now-deleted post. “Mexico City ain’t East LA, homie. Your ‘review’ missed by miles. Should have had [fellow LA Times critic] Justin Chang review ‘El Chicano.’ He’s from Orange County, gets it, and is ten times the writer.”

Aguilar is a critic with bylines at various publications, including IndieWire, and he was immediately supported on social media by fellow members of the press. As the backlash against Carnahan grew, the director deleted his remarks and posted another blunt message to film critics.

“I deleted the ‘offensive’ tweet but it’s fascinating how many of you ‘critics’ rushed in to defend one of your own, like some tribal council,” Carnahan wrote. “Maybe look at that. At the fear and loathing you live in because of your reluctance and/or inability to create yourselves.”

“El Chicano” is now paying in theaters courtesy of Briarcliff Entertainment. Next up for Carnahan is “Boss Level,” a science-fiction action movie starring Mel Gibson and Frank Grillo. The film does not have a release date. IndieWire has reached out to Carnahan’s representative for further comment.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Film and tagged ,

Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox