×
Back to IndieWire

Judgment Against Asghar Farhadi in Plagiarism Case Not Final Despite Filmmaker’s Apparent Loss

The guilty verdict for the Oscar-winning director, who allegedly took the concept of "A Hero" from a former film student, is not final, according to sources.

A HERO, (aka GHAHREMAN), Amir Jadidi, 2021. © Amazon Studios / courtesy Everett Collection

“A Hero”

Amazon/Courtesy Everett Collection

Updated, 1:41 p.m. ET: Representatives for Farhadi shared a statement with IndieWire from Memento Films producer Alexandre Mallet-Guy, collaborator with Farhadi on eight films including “A Hero” and “The Salesman,” excerpted here:

“We firmly believe that the court will dismiss Ms. Masihzadeh who cannot claim ownership on matters in the public domain given that the prisoner’s story has been disclosed in both press articles and TV reports years before Ms. Masihzadeh’s documentary was published.”

Updated, 12:29 pm ET: A day after an Iranian court ruled in favor of Azadeh Masihzadeh, the former film student of Asghar Farhadi who claimed stole the idea for his film “A Hero” from her own documentary, the Oscar-winning director has reportedly been found guilty of plagiarism. The Hollywood Reporter has reported that the court sided with Masihzadeh, who just yesterday won a defamation suit filed by Farhadi alleging false claims.

However, sources tell IndieWire that the guilty judgment is not final. Reports on this matter have conflicted, with THR insisting that the judgment by the court in Tehran is binding and not eligible for appeal. Farhadi’s lawyer, Kaveh Rad, on social media said (per Deadline), that “the decision is not the final verdict of the court and is considered part of the trial process, and in the continuation of the trial process, the case will be reexamined first in the second criminal court and then in the appellate court.”

Earlier: As alleged by the student, Farhadi lifted the premise for “A Hero” (a man on leave from debtor’s prison stumbles upon a bag of money that he then decides to publicly turn over to authorities to rehabilitate his image) from Masihzadeh’s documentary “All Winners, All Losers,” which screened at an Iranian film festival in 2018. Masihzadeh conceived of the documentary during a film workshop taught by Farhadi, whom she alleged later asked her to sign a document saying the idea for the film was his own.

The THR report also suggests that a second judge will now determine the sentencing for the “A Separation” and “A Salesman” director. Penalties include forfeiting all profits from “A Hero” (which was released stateside by Amazon Studios) to Masihzadeh, as well as possible prison time.

Globally, “A Hero” has earned around $2.5 million to date and is currently available to stream on Amazon Prime Video.

While Farhadi admitted the film was based on the same true story that served as the basis for “All Winners,” he did not give his former film student credit for discovering the material. He had claimed his own independent research of the story of a Mr. Shokri, an inmate in debtor’s prison who, similar to the protagonist of “A Hero,” found a bag of gold during a prison leave and decided to return it.

Masihzadeh, in her initial accusation, claimed that “[Shokri’s] story was never in the national media, it was never on TV, it was not available online or in the public record. It was a story I found and researched on my own.”

Her acquittal in the defamation suit means she will not have to face up to a possible two-year prison sentence.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Film and tagged ,


Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox