×
Back to IndieWire

‘Fire Country’ Is Hot, ‘The Real Love Boat’ Is Not: 10 New Broadcast Shows Ranked by Premiere Viewers

New CBS procedurals have found an early audience, while the latest "Love Boat" adaptation is already capsized.

Fox's "Monarch" and NBC's "Quantum Leap."

Fox’s “Monarch” and NBC’s “Quantum Leap.”

Fox/NBC

Ranking the viewership of new fall broadcast series sounds easy — but like everything else about TV, it’s more complicated than it looks. Consider this ranking an educated snapshot.

IndieWire elected to rank freshman series by the overall-viewer averages of their series premieres. These Nielsen numbers include any viewer (age 2 or older) and counts one week of delayed viewing. We’ve included ratings in the key adults 18-49 demographics but elected to rank shows by total viewers. This lets us avoid tied rankings and provides more-digestible numbers, but it disproportionately rewards older-skewing shows (i.e., CBS). In general, CBS was the uncontested king of the rankings, with three of its series topping the list, all of which were given full-season pickups on Wednesday.

Nielsen does not measure streaming platforms in real time, and their delays are too substantial to make this story. Also not included are other non-linear VOD viewing.

Finally, we’ve focused on the Big 4 broadcast networks: CBS, NBC, Fox, and ABC. The new series are ranked from least- to most-watched; this post will be updated as more series debut.

“As Solid as the Rock of Gibraltar” – THE REAL LOVE BOAT pulls into the impressive port of Gibraltar where the new couples compete in their first challenge: running up a mountain while truthfully answering personal questions about their romantic history. Back on the ship, the winning couple enjoys a private dinner at The Captain’s Table while fallout ensues for the losing couples after some of the shocking answers, on THE REAL LOVE BOAT, Wednesday, Oct. 12 (9:00-9:59 PM, PT/ET) on the CBS Television Network and available to stream live and on demand on Paramount+*. Rebecca Romijn and Jerry O’Connell are the hosts.Pictured: Ezra Freeman. Photo: Sara Mally/CBS ©2022 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

“The Real Love Boat” on CBS.

CBS

“The Real Love Boat”

Rank: 10
Network: CBS
Date: October 5, 2022
Total viewers: 2.922 million
18-49 rating: 0.3

No love here. Of all the networks this season, CBS has (by far) the most new series to premiere thus far and the ones with the most success in getting eyeballs. That makes the sinking-ship viewership for the first episode of “The Real Love Boat” all the more alarming for the nautical reality show’s long-term prospects. Head to your Muster station.

Based loosely on the ’70s anthology series about passengers on a crew ship finding love, the series sees hosts and real-life couple Rebecca Romijn and Jerry O’Connell guide new couples through relationship-building exercises. But for whatever reason — the 35-year-old IP lacks the pull to rein in viewers? Those who fondly remember the old show have little interest in a reality competition? — the show has failed to find an initial audience, and has since taken a lifeboat to Paramount+.

"Monarch"

Fox’s “Monarch.”

Fox

“Monarch”

Rank: 9
Network: Fox
Date: September 11, 2022
Total viewers: 3.169 million
18-49 rating: 1.0

“Monarch” isn’t exactly king, but this is a pretty good performance for Fox. The “Empire”-but-with-country-music series can thank its generous NFL football lead-in for a large portion of its “live” viewership. (And definitely for that demo number.) It’s also worth noting that its 1.0 rating in the 18-49 demographic outpaces any other network premiere this season. “Monarch” is Fox’s only new series of the season to have debuted so far, so it’s queen (of Fox) for the day.

LOPEZ VS LOPEZ -- "Lopez vs Español" Episode 104 -- Pictured: (l-r) Brice Gonzalez as Chance, George Lopez as George -- (Photo by: Nicole Weingart/NBC)

NBC’s new George Lopez sitcom “Lopez vs Lopez”

Nicole Weingart/NBC

“Lopez vs Lopez”

Rank: 8
Network: NBC
Date: November 4, 2022
Total viewers: 3.318 million
18-49 rating: 0.4

The fourth sitcom starring comedian George Lopez with his name in the title, “Lopez vs Lopez” has predecessors in success (“George Lopez,” which aired for six seasons on ABC and later became a fixture of the Nick at Nite programming block in syndication), and in failure (“Saint George,” which was canceled after 10 episodes, and “Lopez,” which managed two seasons). This new show, which sees Lopez act with his real-life daughter Mayan as a working-class father-daughter pair, got off to a mostly uninspiring start, especially among young adults. Give it some time, this isn’t exactly the golden age for sitcoms.

THE ROOKIE: FEDS - ÒStar CrossedÓ Ð GarzaÕs unit gets roped into a complicated kidnapping case involving a forbidden relationship between two rival drug-dealing gangs. Meanwhile, SimoneÕs love life is heating up; Laura comes face-to-face with her past, and Carter tries to reconnect with his wife on an all-new episode of ÒThe Rookie: Feds,Ó TUESDAY, OCT. 11 (10:00-11:00 p.m. EDT), on ABC. (ABC)NIECY NASH-BETTS

Niecy Nash-Betts stars on ABC’s “The Rookie” spinoff “The Rookie: Feds.”

ABC

“The Rookie: Feds”

Rank: 7
Network: ABC
Date: September 27, 2022
Total viewers: 4.305 million
18-49 rating: 0.6

ABC’s “The Rookie,” an L.A.-based procedural starring Nathan Fillion, has been a relatively consistent performer for the network in its Sunday-night time slot, averaging around 6 million viewers in Season 4. Spinoff “Feds,” which retools the “oldest rookie” premise (Niecy Nash-Betts, training at FBI Academy), started with a more muted reception. Hopefully, the early two-episode crossover between the two series can put more eyes on this rookie.

Reggie Watts competes on ABC's "Celebrity Jeopardy!"

Reggie Watts competes on ABC’s “Celebrity Jeopardy!”

ABC

“Celebrity Jeopardy!”

Rank: 6
Network: ABC
Date: September 25, 2022
Total viewers: 4.342 million
18-49 rating: 0.5

Is “Celebrity Jeopardy!” a new show? That’s in the eye of the beholder. Plain old “Jeopardy!” dates back to the ’60s, and though it’s had a whole bunch of spinoffs, the only prior “Celebrity Jeopardy!” is the spoof you know from “Saturday Night Live.” Mayim Bialik hosts ABC’s very real “Celebrity Jeopardy!” ABC has had success with “Celebrity” versions of other game shows like “Family Feud” and “Wheel of Fortune.” It’s probably just a matter of time until “Celebrity The Chase.”

QUANTUM LEAP -- “Pilot” Episode Pilot -- Pictured: Raymond Lee as Dr. Ben Song -- (Photo by: Serguei Bachlakov/NBC)

Raymond Lee on “Quantum Leap

Serguei Bachlakov/NBC

“Quantum Leap”

Rank: 5
Network: NBC
Date: September 19, 2022
Total viewers: 5.518 million
18-49 rating: 0.7

One of the most high-profile premieres this season is NBC’s “Quantum Leap,” a continuation of the beloved 1989 sci-fi procedural with Raymond Lee stepping into the shoes of Scott Bakula as a scientist journeying through time. This “Leap” has a few things going for it: It debuted out of “The Voice” Season 22 premiere, it’s well-known IP, and NBC promoted it like hell. Even so, it’s in the middle of the ratings pack, but as one of NBC’s two scripted premieres, that hardly matters. The series has seen its initial order of 12 episodes extended to 18, boding well for a renewal.

ALASKA DAILY - ÒA Place We Came TogetherÓ Ð When Roz and Eileen find a lead in GloriaÕs case, Eileen calls in a favor to help them track down the person of interest. Meanwhile, Claire investigates why beloved local restaurant RitaÕs is selling to a big corporation. After landing her first front page story, Yuna learns that success in journalism sometimes comes at a cost on a new episode of ÒAlaska Daily,Ó THURSDAY, OCT. 13 (10:01-11:00 p.m. EDT), on ABC. (ABC/Darko Sikman)HILARY SWANK

Hilary Swank stars on new ABC drama “Alaska Daily.”

ABC

“Alaska Daily”

Rank: 4
Network: ABC
Date: October 9, 2022
Total viewers: 6.272 million
18-49 rating: 0.5

“Alaska Daily” was one of the more buzzy network premieres of the season thanks primarily to its lead, two-time Oscar winner Hillary Swank. She headed to broadcast for the first time since “Beverly Hills, 90210” to play a tough journalist investigating missing and murdered indigenous peoples cases around Anchorage, Alaska. That buzz translated into solid consumption of the first episode, although it ultimately landed a hair away from the Top 3.

"Co-Pilot" Margaret and Todd work two seemingly unrelated cases, only to discover a key piece of information from Todd’s civil case could help Margaret’s high-profile client, on “So Help Me Todd,” Thursday, Oct. 6. Coverage of the CBS Original Series SO HELP ME TODD, scheduled to air on the CBS Television Network. Pictured: Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin. Photo: Bettina Strauss/CBS ©2022 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin on CBS’ “So Help Me Todd.”

CBS

“So Help Me Todd”

Rank: 3
Network: CBS
Date: September 29, 2022
Total viewers: 6.604 million
18-49 rating: 0.5

This legal dramedy with an extremely cheesy pun of a title features Skylar Astin and Marcia Gay Harden as a P.I. son and his lawyer mother whose lines of work cause them to cross paths. At 6.6 million viewers, the series got off to a good start even if two other CBS premieres overshadowed it. But with the show picked up for a full season order, third place doesn’t seem so awful.

“Misdemeanor Homicide” – When two homicide victims – a young man from the housing projects and a fast-rising hedge fund partner – are discovered in the community, Deputy Inspector Regina Haywood fights to ensure both cases receive the same resources to bring the perpetrators to justice, on EAST NEW YORK, Sunday, Oct. 9 (9:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network and available to stream live and on demand on Paramount+.* Pictured (L-R): Jimmy Smits as Chief John Suarez and Amanda Warren as Regina Haywood. Photo: Scott McDermott/CBS ©2022 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Jimmy Smits as Chief John Suarez and Amanda Warren as Regina Haywood on CBS’ “East New York.”

CBS

“East New York”

Rank: 2
Network: CBS
Date: October 2, 2022
Total viewers: 7.168 million
18-49 rating: 0.7

Never doubt a CBS procedural’s ability to find an audience. The network with the “CSI” and “NCIS” franchises, “The Good Wife,” and “Elementary,” among others, always has room for one more. “East New York” tries to complicate that a bit by addressing modern debates about policing, but it doesn’t seem to bother the core CBS audience — a real bunch of blue bloods (get it? “Blue Bloods”), judging by its strong premiere viewership and its full season order from the network.

“The Fresh Prince of Edgewater” – After Bode requests to be transferred to a different city, his future in Edgewater hangs in the balance. Meanwhile, the crew joins forces to protect the town from a treacherous storm, on FIRE COUNTRY, Friday, Oct. 14 (9:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network and available to stream live and on demand on Paramount+*. Pictured: Kevin Alejandro as Manny Perez. Photo: Bettina Strauss/CBS ©2022 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Kevin Alejandro as Manny Perez in CBS’ “Fire Country.”

CBS

“Fire Country”

Rank: 1
Network: CBS
Date: October 7, 2022
Total viewers: 8.257 million
18-49 rating: 0.6

Jerry Bruckheimer knows how to build a hit (see: the “CSI” franchise, “Without a Trace,” “Cold Case,” “The Amazing Race”). His latest CBS project, about a convict who joins a prison firefighting program to battle the wildfires of Northern California, seems poised to join that lineup with the most-watched first episode of any network premiere this year and a full season order from the channel. Bruckheimer knows what his audience wants, which in this case is fire.

Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.

This Article is related to: Television and tagged , ,


Get The Latest IndieWire Alerts And Newsletters Delivered Directly To Your Inbox