Oscars 2017: Best Actor is Now Denzel Washington vs. Casey Affleck

Affleck had been winning all the Best Actor Awards until Denzel Washington won SAG. Has the tide turned?
'Fences' Denzel Washington
Denzel Washington in "Fences"
David Lee/Paramount Pictures/REX/Shutterstock

By now, the Best Actor Oscar race usually has settled on an anointed frontrunner. And that was the case — until Sunday’s SAG Awards. Not anymore. It’s a two-way race.

Here are my Best Actor picks in order of likelihood to win:

Casey AffleckThroughout the awards season, the “Manchester By the Sea” star has been steady as he goes. He won awards at the Gothams, National Board of Review, New York Film Critics Circle, Critics Choice, and Golden Globes for carrying Amazon Studios’ $10-million Sundance pickup “Manchester by the Sea” (Roadside Attractions) as Lee, a capable Boston janitor weighed down by sadness, anger, and depression. What happened to make him this way? That is what writer-director Kenneth Lonergan’s precisely crafted movie reveals.

Casey AffleckShutterstock

While Affleck has delivered many fine performances, often supporting, and was nominated eight years ago for “The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford,” he has never taken on such a complex, internal and emotional role. You’ve seen the film’s defining scene, the one that sets grown men sobbing, when Lee runs into his ex-wife Randi (Michelle Williams) on the street. It seems simple enough: Back in Manchester after his brother’s funeral, the estranged couple runs into each other on the sidewalk. She wants to meet with Lee so they can talk. He says he can’t.

“A friend said to me once about acting, ‘If you do something really truthfully, it doesn’t matter what it is, it’s going to be interesting,’” Lonergan told me. “And I believe that that’s true. I found a long time ago that real life — as best I can transcribe it — the details are always richer than leaving them out.”

Affleck managed another feat; he’s gleaned a trick or two from his older brother, actor-writer-director Ben, who emerged victorious from Oscar season 2012/2013 with Best Picture-winner “Argo.” Affleck has navigated the awards circuit not only with a scraggly beard but also with poise and self-deprecating charm — not expecting too much, just grateful enough.

Check out my video interview with Affleck, which ranges from his first film at age 18 (“To Die For”) and how all his experience prepared him for “Manchester” 23 years later.


Simmering under Affleck’s frontrunner status was media coverage (including The New York Times) of a settled 2010 sexual assault lawsuit. But there seemed to be no slowing of the respected actor’s momentum — until the SAG Awards.

Denzel WashingtonIt’s impossible to know why Affleck’s support flagged just as his main rival picked up steam. Sunday night SAG actors accorded their highest honor to Critics Choice and Golden Globe nominee Denzel Washington, who directed himself in the film version of August Wilson’s Tony-winning play “Fences” (Paramount) as a Pittsburgh ex-baseball slugger turned garbage man who is angry at the world. He knocked it out of the park.

“What I knew was, we have to make sure we don’t start where we finished,” Washington told me. “We’ve got to go back and infuse as much love, or there’s nothing to lose … I was here to serve August Wilson first — before anybody else. That’s the deal. I like it. August Wilson wrote a masterpiece. It works on the stage and it works on film. I was determined; I had decided. I was going to film what he wrote. There are a lot of different versions of it, and I had to work through this and that, and boil it back down to what he wrote.”

Also helping: the veteran New York theater actor and movie icon is a charismatic star who knows how to work the room. While it was a surprise that BAFTA did not recognize the African-American star, the film is riding a holiday box office surge ($51 million to date), not to mention a collective desire to show Donald Trump and the world that the Oscars are inclusive and not so white.

READ MORE: Denzel Washington Interview: How He Opened Up ‘Fences’

Ryan Gosling is riding the coattails of PGA and likely Best Picture Oscar-winner “La La Land” (Lionsgate). He broke out at the Telluride Film Festival as a dapper singing, dancing, piano-playing jazz man in Damien Chazelle’s audacious reinvention of the musical. Gosling (who received a 2007 Best Actor nomination for indie drama “Half Nelson”) nabbed Critics Choice, SAG, and BAFTA mentions, and won the Comedy/Musical Golden Globe. If “La La Land” stages a full — if unlikely — sweep, Gosling could also win Best Actor.

See our video interview below:


Andrew Garfield: Mel Gibson’s bloody World War II drama “Hacksaw Ridge” (Lionsgate) scored with critics and audiences in Venice, who praised well-cast Andrew Garfield’s performance as a pacifist medic trying to save his fellow soldiers on the Okinawa battlefield. He went on to land Critics Choice, Golden Globe, SAG, and BAFTA nominations. The movie also hit big at the box office ($65 million domestic). Lending him momentum: rave reviews in Martin Scorsese’s “Silence” as a starving Jesuit missionary in Japan, as well as six “Hacksaw Ridge” Oscar nominations including Picture and Director for Gibson.

Watch our video interview with Gibson and Garfield.


Viggo MortensenCritics Choice, Screen Actors Guild, Golden Globes, and BAFTA all nominated the popular and respected “Captain Fantastic” star for his role as a beleaguered single father raising his sprawling brood off the grid in deep forest. Somehow Mortensen bonded with all those children and helped director Matt Ross keep them engaged and believable. “There’s something about Viggo,” Ross told IndieWire. “He’s a man’s man, but he’s also physically fit, and believes intellectually the words coming out of his mouth.”

Viggo Mortensen in Captain Fantastic
“Captain Fantastic”

Clearly, actors love this performance, but this little indie ($5.9 million domestic) may not be widely viewed by the entire Academy.

READ MORE: Viggo Mortensen Doesn’t Need to make Big Movies Anymore. 


1. Casey Affleck (“Manchester by the Sea”)
2. Denzel Washington (“Fences”)
3. Ryan Gosling (“La La Land”)
4. Andrew Garfield (“Hacksaw Ridge”)
5. Viggo Mortensen (“Captain Fantastic”)

Check our our award season video interviews.

READ MORE: 2017 Oscar Predictions

Daily Headlines
Daily Headlines covering Film, TV and more.

By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

PMC Logo
IndieWire is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2023 IndieWire Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.