Golden Globes and SAG Awards Tell Us Who’s Ahead in the Oscar Race

"Everything Everywhere All at Once," "The Fabelmans," and "Banshees of Inisherin" are strong contenders for the Oscar.
80th ANNUAL GOLDEN GLOBE AWARDS -- Pictured: Colin Farrell accepts the Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy award for "The Banshees of Inisherin" at the 80th Annual Golden Globe Awards held at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on January 10, 2023 -- (Photo by: Rich Polk/NBC)
Colin Farrell at the 2023 Golden Globe Awards
Rich Polk / NBC

Academy voters have never taken the Golden Globes seriously. It’s always been a celebratory party night with a genial Jack Nicholson type front and center (see: Brad Pitt) and revelers trawling the halls of the Beverly Hilton seeking the next hot party. (See… well, on this note the show fell decidedly short).

This year it was less about the specifics — awkward host Jerrod Carmichael; no-show winners Cate Blanchett (“TAR”) and Kevin Costner (“Yellowstone”) — than questions around the future of the entire enterprise. Dick Clark Prods.’ Todd Boehly is now transforming the 96-member HFPA into a for-profit venture that will pay employees $75,000 a year to vote for the Globes while adding a growing roster of (non-paid) international voters, some of whom are people of color.

The people who watch the show don’t care about any of that. Moments when the winners interacted with the tables in the room — like first winner and Oscar frontrunner Ke Huy Quan (“Everything Everywhere All at Once”) poignantly paying tribute to early mentor Steven Spielberg — were fun to see. A Globes winner does get some forward momentum, and a great speech can go viral on social media and propel, say, Meryl Streep into contention (2017’s “Florence Foster Jenkins”). Academy voters look at the videos, if not the show.

Pater familias Steven Spielberg had a great night as he won Best Director and Best Drama for “The Fabelmans” (Universal), burnishing the Toronto People’s Choice winner’s crowdpleaser credibility after its weak box office showing.

And “The Banshees of Inisherin” (Searchlight) took home not just Best Actor Comedy (really? a comedy?) for Colin Farrell (whose sweet speech leaned into his real-life bromance with costar Brendan Gleeson) but Screenplay and Best Comedy for Martin McDonagh. Best Comedy Actress winner Michelle Yeoh, who reminded viewers of her struggles as an Asian actress, did not go up against her presumed Oscar rival Blanchett, who won Drama, just as a drawling Austin Butler won in a Drama category without Farrell.

80th ANNUAL GOLDEN GLOBE AWARDS -- Pictured: Steven Spielberg accepts the Best Motion Picture – Drama award for "The Fabelmans" at the 80th Annual Golden Globe Awards held at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on January 10, 2023 -- (Photo by: Rich Polk/NBC)
Steven Spielberg at the 2023 Golden Globe AwardsRich Polk / NBC

Many in the greater Hollywood awards complex see the Golden Globes as essential to the Oscar machine, greasing the skids on the way to the big night. If anything, this show proved that the Globes are well past their prime, trying to conjure faded memories of their glory days, a rickety enterprise without solid foundation. January 15 brings the Critics Choice Awards (I’m a member) on the CW, which have a long way to go before they rival the broadcast clout or the brand recognition of the Golden Globes, but its diverse voting body is comprised of more than 500 working professionals. Multiple CCA members (including Deadline’s Pete Hammond) were refused invites to cover the Globe event, although non-members were welcome. A Golden Globe rep did not return calls at press time.

The Screen Actors Guild Awards are far more predictive than the Globes. SAG’s film and TV nominating committee of 4,200 is more mainstream than the Academy actors branch’s 1,302 (the largest Oscar voting bloc), but they do overlap. The big winner at the SAG nominations was Netflix, which managed to get charming “Hustle” star Adam Sandler and his equally engaging Globe nominees Ana De Armas (“Blonde”) and Eddie Redmayne (“The Good Nurse”) into the SAG lineup.

That doesn’t mean they’ll repeat on Oscar nominations morning January 24. But Oscar voting begins Thursday, January 12 and ends Monday January 17. More voters will sample the SAG nominees before they make their final decisions.

After two Globe wins and five SAG nominations, “Everything Everywhere All at Once” is building a mighty head of steam. Not only did the SAG committee place it in Ensemble — often an Oscar bellwether — but Globe-winner Yeoh landed in Female Leading Role with two of her costars in Supporting: both Jamie Lee Curtis and Stephanie Hsu. (The Supporting Actress category boasted two Asian-American actresses, as Hong Chau got in for “The Whale.”) Also included at SAG was the expected Quan, who should continue his winning streak all the way to the Oscars.

Golden Globe winner and SAG nominee Angela Bassett (“Black Panther: Wakanda Forever”) should continue on her way to an Oscar slot. This is a legacy award as much as a recognition of her intense performance as a regal leader grieving the loss of her son. At the Globes, Bassett reminded (one of many peering at her iPhone) that she was last on that stage as a winner in 1994, for “What’s Love Got to Do with It?” That’s an irresistible Oscar narrative.

Also with five SAG nominations was “Banshees of Inisherin,” which nabbed an Ensemble nod as well as slots for Leading Male Farrell, Supporting Males Gleeson and Keoghan, and Supporting Female Kerry Condon, who McDonagh credited Tuesday night with stealing the movie from her male costars.

“The Fabelmans” managed an Ensemble nod, which is terrific, but only Paul Dano scored an acting mention: Michelle Williams and Judd Hirsch were snubbed.

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA - DECEMBER 15: Brad Pitt attends the premiere screening of 'Babylon' at the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures on December 15, 2022 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Emma McIntyre/WireImage)
Brad Pitt at the “Babylon” premiereWireImage/Getty

Similarly, while composer Justin Hurwitz took home the only Golden Globe win for Hollywood saga “Babylon” (without mentioning director Damien Chazelle) the film surprisingly wound up in SAG Ensemble, a sign of strength with the actors. But Globe nominees Margot Robbie and Brad Pitt did not score SAG slots — a sign of weakness. And again, while Sarah Polley’s “Women Talking” landed a much-needed place at the SAG Ensemble table, none of its actors (who were competing with each other) notched a nomination.

Left out of Ensemble but included in Best Stunt Ensemble was “The Woman King,” while the popular Viola Davis was slotted in Leading Female Drama, along with rising star Danielle Deadwyler of “Till.” Both should wind up in the Oscar race for their powerful emotional performances. Included in Stunt Ensemble but excluded from other SAG mentions were Oscar contenders “Top Gun: Maverick” and “Avatar: The Way of Water,” which will surely perform well through Oscar categories. But Tom Cruise can kiss another Oscar acting nomination good-bye.

One thing to look forward to Oscar night: While “RRR” failed to win Best Foreign Film at the Globes, it did win Best Song for “Naatu Naatu,” and assuming the shortlisted song gets Oscar-nominated, its two Indian superstars, N.T Rama Rao Jr. and Ram Charan, told me that they are more than ready to perform in tuxedos.

Daily Headlines
Daily Headlines covering Film, TV and more.

By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

PMC Logo
IndieWire is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2023 IndieWire Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.