Does 'Doctor Who' Have Room Peter Capaldi?

“I am not your boyfriend,” announces Peter Capaldi’s 12th Doctor, to Jenna Coleman’s lame duck companion Clara Oswald, near the end of “Deep Breath,” the first episode of the 8th season of “Doctor Who” (BBC America).
Of course the announcement is not directed only at Clara, who has been somewhat thrown for a loop by the fact that the handsome young 11th Doctor (Matt Smith), with whom she was half in love, has been replaced by a man who is not just older (Capaldi is 56) but light years less dreamy and ingratiating than his immediate predecessors, David Tennant’s swashbuckling 10th Doctor (2005–10) as well as Smith’s manic 11th (2010 to 2013).
The rub is that the youth and glamour and gung ho spirit of those Doctors was central to the hugely successful revamp engineered by producer Russell T. Davies to re-launch the series in 2005, after a 14 year “hiatus,” as  a faster-paced and more contemporary action show than it had been in its Classical phase, with an occasional dash of romance and way better production values. (In the 1970s one could often see the hacksaw marks in the Styrofoam used to build the sets.)
Capaldi was a brilliant choice to play the Doctor, and he performs brilliantly in “Deep Breath,” by turns irritable and irritating, childish, heroic and highhanded, sometimes within the span a single sentence. No one who enjoyed his performance as Malcolm Tucker in the political satire “The Thick of It” will be surprised to learn that Capaldi has the verbal dexterity and the steamrolling energy to play the role this way.

But this conception of the role is also a reversion, knowingly retro, a jumping backward in time over the heads of Smith and Tennant, to the spikier style of the greatest early Doctors, Patrick Troughton’s 2nd (1966–69) and Tom Baker’s 4th (1974–81).

The mode of what has now been officially designated “Classic Doctor Who” is firmly in the tradition of the troublesome British eccentric hero, which is bound to strike many in the show’s huge new audience as somewhat fussy and old fashioned. (Baker played Sherlock Holmes for the BBC, as well, and it’s surely no accident that “Deep Breath” is set in Victorian London.)

Capaldi’s debut, written by show runner Stephen Moffett and directed by young Turk Ben Wheatley (“Kill List”), is an exciting and at times genuinely scary episode about a crew of alien cyborgs harvesting human organs in order to transform themselves, piece by piece, into biological beings. Its attractions include a sweetly docile CG T-Rex and some tasty explosions.

The story is also elegantly thematically consistent. If we wanted to get high-fallutin’ about it we could say that “Deep Breath” is about the masks people adopt and their relationship to their true identity. To put it another way, the central issue is: How much does the Doctor actually change when he regenerates? Is he an entirely different person or a variation on a theme?

Pains are taken early on to disabuse young Clara of the notion that the Doctor’s drastically altered appearance is a definitive indication that he’s no longer the goofy and engaging do-gooder she admired. That persona was merely a mask, she’s told, concealing his utterly alien true identity.

Of course the situation is tricky here because it’s a firmly established convention of the show that it isn’t just the Doctor’s face that changes with each Regeneration, but also his personality. In a powerful later scene, the Doctor himself confronts the issue, gazing into a mirror, shocked by the signs of aging on his new face, soliloquizing on its implications: “It’s covered with lines, but I didn’t do the frowning. Who frowned me this face?” And he wonders, “Why this one? Why did I chose this face? It’s like I’m trying to tell myself something. Like I’m trying to make a point. But what’s so important that I can’t just tell myself what I’m thinking?” (Masks are a motif throughout the episode, but we can’t run through any of the others without dropping major spoilers.)

Capaldi, I think, has the potential to become one the great Doctors, with a grave sense of wonder that could carry the show pretty deeply “into darkness,” the destination announced in the trailer for his second episode. It’s an open whether the shinier, perkier current version of the show has room for that kind of greatness, any longer.

Daily Headlines
Daily Headlines covering Film, TV and more.

By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

PMC Logo
IndieWire is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2023 IndieWire Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.