ScreenJunkies and Honest Trailers Remain Dark Following Andy Signore’s Dismissal

The popular YouTube channel's creator was fired for allegedly harassing women. Its next chapter is unclear.
Dan Murrell, Joe Starr, Spencer Gilbert, Michael Bolton, Andy Signore. Dan Murrell, from left, Joe Starr, Spencer Gilbert, Michael Bolton, and Andy Signore arrive at night one of the Television Academy's 2017 Creative Arts Emmy Awards at the Microsoft Theater, in Los AngelesTelevision Academy's 2017 Creative Arts Emmy Awards - Red Carpet - Night 1, Los Angeles, USA - 09 Sep 2017
Andy Signore at the 2017 Creative Arts Emmy Awards

It’s been almost two weeks since Andy Signore — creator of the YouTube channel and online movie magazine ScreenJunkies, and senior vice president of content for its parent company, Defy Media — was suspended after several women came forward with allegations of sexual harassment and assault. The next day, Defy terminated Signore — the same day as Harvey Weinstein, and about a week before Amazon Studios’ head Roy Price resigned for inappropriate behavior.

Yet while The Weinstein Company and Amazon Studios work to convince the public that they’re back to business as usual, Defy does little to hide it’s in crisis mode.

On October 8, the day Signore was fired, ScreenJunkies and Defy (which oversees eight brands, including Smosh, Smosh Games, and Clevver) tweeted the official statement announcing Signore’s firing. Since then, those Twitter accounts have been silent and the official Defy Media statement wasn’t prominently displayed on ScreenJunkies’ YouTube channel, which has 6.2 million subscribers, versus 145K Twitter followers (that statement was the pinned YouTube comment underneath the last video Signore hosted).

The statement also confirmed the timeline established by accusers who tweeted (see here and here) that they reported Signore’s misconduct, then made themselves available for interviews over two months, but weren’t contacted by investigators. “While you were still ‘engaged in this investigation,’ he was still around many female employees, many female guests,” said YouTube host Philip DeFranco in a video blog that has been viewed 1.4 million times. “What kind of HR department allows that?”

Read More: Andy Signore Fired From ScreenJunkies for His ‘Egregious and Intolerable Behavior’

Signore hosted ScreenJunkies’ “Movie Fights” and co-created both “The ScreenJunkies Show!” and the twice Emmy-nominated “Honest Trailers,” which provided weekly, deadpan, four-to-eight-minute film recaps. However, ScreenJunkies hasn’t uploaded any new content since Signore’s exit. “The silence from SJ is disconcerting,” wrote commenter Kevin Johnson. Others chimed in.

Some members of the channel’s creative team requested patience from fans on their personal social media pages. “We have met, talked, & tried to work through this every day since we found out,” tweeted Screen Junkies film critic and producer Dan Murrell. “We need more time.”

Joe Starr, an Honest Trailers writer, expressed gratitude to those who helped ScreenJunkies exceed 1.8 billion pageviews to date.

ScreenJunkies News editor-in-chef and Girls on Film host/producer Roth Cornet assured her followers that post-Signore, the team is “meeting daily to find a good path forward.”

IndieWire made multiple attempts to contact Defy representatives, but emails went unanswered and phone calls rang without response (and the main number’s voicemail was full). Via its website, Defy’s headquarters in midtown Manhattan encourages, “If you’re in town, drop a line and swing by,” so IndieWire did just that. The lobby suggested business as usual: four flat-screen televisions played ScreenJunkies programming on a loop, and a receptionist sat behind a desk decorated with a banner of Halloween ghosts. IndieWire requested Jodi Smith-Bulhack, Defy’s senior VP communications, and the receptionist said she’d be out shortly. Instead, a lawyer came to the lobby: Adam Silverman, Defy’s assistant general counsel and senior VP of business and legal affairs. He said she was “unavailable,” but we should continue emailing her to set up an appointment.

That evening, Smith-Bulhack wrote in an email, “Screen Junkies programming will resume shortly. I will keep you updated.” When pressed for additional details, she redirected us to their Oct. 8 statement.

ScreenJunkies fans are encouraging the channel and its parent company to take as long as necessary before returning with new episodes. One of Signore’s accusers, April O’Donnell, criticized those seeking the swift return of their beloved shows. “If you’re one of the people complaining that you didn’t get an honest trailer or movie fights this week you need to re-evaluate yourself,” she tweeted. (She did not respond to requests for comment by press time.)

Daily Headlines
Daily Headlines covering Film, TV and more.

By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

PMC Logo
IndieWire is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2023 IndieWire Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.